Mitteln Anhängsel
[Prasad Beeraka]
Observes
that that the conventional (allopathic) action and the homeopathic action of a
remedy are opposite to one another, but this is not always the case
Originally published in the Simillimum /
: https://hanp.net/simillimu Reprinted
courtesy of the author.
Abstract
An
interesting and new observation regarding the pharmacological action of
homeopathic remedies is presented. All substances (remedies) have two
pharmacological actions.
One
is the conventional (allopathic) pharmacological action (that caused by
administration of the undiluted material form or mother tincture of the
substance) and the other is the homeopathic pharmacological action (that caused
by administration of the homeopathically diluted, potentized form of the
substance).
Usually,
it is seen that the conventional (allopathic) action and the homeopathic action
of a remedy are opposite to one another but this is not always the case. There
are a few remedies in the materia medica in which the conventional and
homeopathic pharmacological actions are similar to each other instead of being
opposite.
It
has been observed in my study that the location of a remedy’s pharmacological
receptor within the cell determines whether the homeopathic action of that
remedy is similar to or opposite to the conventional action of that remedy.
This
is the interesting phenomenon discovered and the same is presented in this
article. Thus, this article provides a scientific explanation for the anomalous
pharmacological behaviour of some of the remedies in the materia medica.
Further work and research in this aspect could lead to a deeper understanding
of the fundamental mechanism of action of homeopathy.
As
we are all aware, all substances (remedies) have two pharmacological actions,
one is the conventional (allopathic) pharmacological action (that caused by
administration of the undiluted material form or mother tincture of the
substance) and the other is the homeopathic pharmacological action (that caused
by administration of the homeopathically diluted, potentized form of the substance).
Remedies
mentioned in the materia medica also possess this dual pharmacological action
and the pharmacological behaviour of some of the remedies in the materia medica
was studied. An analysis of the pharmacological behaviour of the remedies led
to the following two observations:
1.
The
conventional pharmacological action and the homeopathic pharmacological action
of a remedy were found to be opposite to each other when the pharmacological
receptor of the remedy is located on the cell membrane.
2.
The
conventional and homeopathic pharmacological actions of a remedy were found to
be similar to each other when the pharmacological receptor of the remedy is
located free within the cytosol (i.e., not anchored to the cell membrane or any
other cellular membrane).
Bell., Op., Jab.,
Coff., Arn.
and Colch., are some of
the remedies in the materia medica whose pharmacological site of action in the
body has been well established and these remedies were selected for the study.
Bell. (active
principle is atropine) acts on the muscarinic acetylcholine receptor, while Op. (active principle is morphine and other opiate
alkaloids) acts on the opioid receptors, and Coff. (active
principle is caffeine) acts principally on the adenosine receptor. Jab (active
principle is pilocarpine) acts on the muscarinic acetylcholine receptor;
Arn. (active
principle is helenalin) acts on NF-κB and Colch. (active
principle is colchicine) acts on tubulin. The pharmacological action of these
remedies in the conventional and homeopathic domains was studied and was
correlated with the location of their respective receptors.
Let
us start with Belladonna.
Belladonna
when administered in the conventional material form (i.e., as a mother tincture
without subjecting it to homeopathic dilution) causes the following symptoms-
fever, dryness of mouth, flushed, hot and dry skin, dilated pupils, tachycardia
and hallucinations1.
Coming
to the pharmacological action of homeopathically diluted Belladonna,
the primary reaction (proving symptoms) of homeopathic Belladonna is
similar to the set of symptoms caused by undiluted Belladonna mentioned above4,
while the secondary reaction is opposite to the pharmacological action caused
by the conventional undiluted form of Belladonna (the secondary reaction is
always opposite to the primary reaction or proving symptoms of a homeopathic
remedy).
The
secondary reaction is to be considered as the final pharmacological action of
any homeopathic remedy as the primary reaction is only temporary and the
secondary reaction is permanent. Thus, it can be observed that, in the case of Belladonna,
the pharmacological actions of the conventional and homeopathic forms of the
remedy are opposite in nature.
Let
us consider Opium
now. Opium
when administered in the conventional, undiluted form has the following
pharmacological actions- analgesia, sedation, euphoria, respiratory depression,
pinpoint pupils, nausea and vomiting, urinary retention, flushing of skin and
pruritus1.
The
final pharmacological action (secondary reaction) of the homeopathic form of Opium can be
observed to be opposite to the pharmacological action of the conventional form
of Opium
(the proving symptoms of homeopathic Opium are similar to the
pharmacological actions of undiluted Opium mentioned above)4.
Likewise,
is the case with Coffea
and Jaborandi.
Coffea
(active principle is caffeine) causes increased locomotor activity, wakefulness
and insomnia when taken in the undiluted conventional form and homeopathic Coffea causes
reduced locomotor activity and induction of sleep as its final pharmacological
action1, 4.
Conventional
undiluted Jaborandi
(active principle is pilocarpine) causes excessive perspiration and
homeopathically diluted Jaborandi is used to treat abnormal sweating.
So,
in all these four remedies (Belladonna, Opium, Coffea, Jaborandi), the conventional and
homeopathic pharmacological actions are opposite to each other. These four
remedies which have this similarity also have one feature in common regarding
their pharmacological receptors in the body.
The
pharmacological receptors of these four remedies, namely the muscarinic
acetylcholine receptor (for Belladonna and Jaborandi), the opioid receptors (for Opium) and
the
adenosine receptor (for Coffea) are all located at the cell membrane and are
anchored to the cell membrane5.
Now,
if we study the pharmacological actions of Arnica and Colchicum, an opposite
pharmacological behaviour can be observed. Arnica (active principle is helenalin)
has
an anti-inflammatory and anti-hemorrhagic action when administered in the
undiluted, conventional form to patients with closed wounds of muscle and soft
tissue6.
Homeopathically
diluted Arnica
also, has the same pharmacological action as undiluted Arnica and is
used popularly in homeopathy to treat closed wounds.
Similarly,
Colchicum
in its conventional, undiluted form has an anti-inflammatory action and homeopathically
diluted Colchicum
too, has a similar anti-inflammatory action.
Thus,
these two remedies, Arnica and Colchicum have similar pharmacological action in their
conventional undiluted form as well as their diluted homeopathic form.
This
is in contrast to the pharmacological behaviour of Belladonna, Opium, Coffea and Jaborandi
(remedies acting on cell membrane receptors) which have opposing actions
in
their conventional and homeopathic domains.
It
is interesting to note that Arnica and Colchicum act on cytosolic receptors and not on receptors
located at the cell membrane. Arnica (active principle is helenalin) acts on NF-κB (nuclear transcription factor) and
Colchicum
(active principle is colchicines) acts on tubulin. Both these receptors are
located free within the cytosol and are not anchored to any cellular membrane.
The
pharmacological behaviour exhibited by the four remedies acting on membrane
receptors mentioned above (Belladonna, Opium, Coffea, Jaborandi) is also seen in all
other remedies acting at membrane receptors with hardly any exceptions (Digitalis is
one exception I could find in the materia medica).
The
majority of pharmacological substances act at membrane located receptors and a
relatively minor percentage act at cytosolic (non-membrane) receptors. Colchicum and Arnica are the
only two remedies I could identify in the materia medica that act at cytosolic
(non-membrane) receptors and hence, only these two remedies are mentioned as
examples of remedies acting at cytosolic (non-membrane) receptors. Both these
remedies exhibit a pharmacological behaviour that is opposite to that of the
remedies acting
at
membrane located receptors.
In
summary, remedies acting at cell membrane anchored receptors exhibit opposite
pharmacological actions in their conventional and homeopathic domains, and
remedies acting at cytosolic (non-membrane anchored) receptors exhibit similar
pharmacological actions in their conventional and homeopathic domains.
The
“fixity” or “restricted mobility” of membrane anchored receptors as opposed to
the free mobility of cytosolic receptors could probably be the reason for this
contrasting pharmacological behaviour of remedies acting at these two different
cellular locations.
Conclusion
The
article reaches the following conclusions:
1.
The
conventional pharmacological action (that caused by administration of
undiluted, material form of the remedy) and the homeopathic pharmacological
action (that caused by administration of the homeopathic dilution of the
remedy) are opposite to each other in the case of remedies acting at membrane
anchored receptors, and the conventional pharmacological action and the
homeopathic pharmacological action are similar to each other in the case of
remedies acting at cytosolic (non-membrane anchored) receptors.
2.
The
“fixity” or “restricted mobility” of membrane anchored receptors as opposed to
the free mobility of cytosolic receptors could be responsible for this
interesting phenomenon.
3.
Further
work and research on this phenomenon could lead to a deeper understanding of
the fundamental mechanism of action of homeopathy.
[Prasad Beeraka/Hans Wolff]
Unser eigentliches physiologisches Leben spielt sich in Milliarden von Zellen ab, aus denen unser Organismus besteht. Dieses Leben einer Zelle teilt sich in drei Funktionen auf:
1. Aufnahme von Nahrung und Sauerstoff für das eigene Überleben
2. Reproduktion für das Überleben der Art
3. Verteidigung durch das Immunsystem
Zur Verteidigung verfügt die Zelle über drei Abwehrmechanismen.
Auslösend können jede Invasion von Krankheitserreger, Toxine, Emotionen sein.
1. Abwehrmechanismus: hauptsächlich die Entzündung (Bronchitis/Hepatitis/Tonsillitis). Ohne Entzündungen würden Infektionen nicht bemerkt,
Wunden würden niemals heilen.
Aber nicht die Bakterien/Mikroben/Viren/Pilze/Toxine der wahre Grund einer Pathologie sind, sondern die Veränderung des Zellgewebes = die Einladung für die Erreger und
daraus entsteht die Entzündung. Hierbei ist alles plötzlich und anfallsartig, mit starken Schmerzen und Rötung.
Aber der Patient spricht gut auf eine Behandlung an und erholt sich sehr schnell.
2. Abwehrmechanismus: oft ist die Reaktion Wachstum und Verdickung (Polypen/Warzen/Zysten/Verkalkung). Die so errichtete Mauer soll die Zellen vor Irritationen schützen.
3. Abwehrmechanismus: Die destruktive Verteidigung, wenn die 1. und 2. Abwehr versagt, wählt der Körper den Untergang eines Teils des Organismus, um den Rest zu retten. Hierbei zeigen sich z.B. Gangrän - Nekrose = Absterben des Gewebes oder ganzer Organbezirken.
Zusammenfassend:
All diese Vorgänge haben ihre Wurzel im genetischen Apparat der Zelle. Er ist die Wurzel der Intelligenz des Organismus, verfügt nicht nur über vererbtes Wissen, sondern befindet sich auch in einem ständigen Lernprozess.
Entscheidet letztendlich auch, ob der Mensch feige oder mutig, verwegen oder schüchtern, zornig oder ängstlich, hochmütig oder unterwürfig ist.
Z.B. anhand von drei Mitteln: Lyc. Nux-v. Sulph.
Lyc. war in der Urzeit so groß „Wie eine Palme“ hat aber nur überlebt bis auf den heutigen Tag, indem sich diese Palme immer kleiner machte, bis zum Schluss nur ein
Farn übrig blieb.
Was blieb, war die Erinnerung an diese alte Größe, aber das Problem ist, die jetzige Kleinheit, daraus wuchs
- Geringes Selbstwertgefühl
- Tyrannisches, herrisches, arrogantes Verhalten gegenüber der Familie und
Menschen mit weniger Autorität (also da, wo ich kann)
- Verbeugt sich nach oben, tritt nach unten.
- Spürt seine Minderwertigkeit und wird sehr scheu
- Selbstüberhebung, Egoismus
- Intellektuell
„Bist du der Beste in deiner Klasse?“
würde ganz verlegen, er wäre gerne der Beste, ist es aber nicht.
Er kennt seine Grenzen und leidet darunter.
Nux-v.
- Intellektuell, ungeduldig, ehrgeizig.
- Er ist der Beste.
- Aggressive Persönlichkeit
- Peinlich genau
- Wut durch Widerspruch
- Durch seinen Strychningehalt gut bei Spasmen und Krämpfe/Störungen des Nervensystems.
„Bist du der Beste in deiner Klasse?“
straft mit Verachtung, ist persönlich gekränkt, dass man es wagt, ihm diese Frage zu stellen, er schweigt, aber eine Viertelstunde später platzt es aus ihm heraus:
„Ich bin der Beste“, was auch stimmt.
Sulphur (gelber Schwefel)
- Unglaublich intelligent
- Philosophisch
- Selbstvertrauen ist unerschütterlich
- Faul
- Schlampig - Kleider haben Flecken vom Mittagessen der vergangenen Woche. Haar ist fettig und ungekämmt, das Hemd falsch zugeknöpft
- Stört aber alles nicht
- Sein Wirkungskreis sieht aus wie ein Katastrophengebiet
„Bist du der Beste in deiner Klasse?“
ist wahrscheinlich das Intelligenteste, das es überhaupt gibt, aber es ist ihm egal.
Ein Philosoph kann wunderbare Geschichten erzählen, sie sind zwar gelogen, alle wissen es, trotzdem sind alle fasziniert.
Akutmittel, die besonders zu den „R-Monaten“ gehören.
Lyc.:
< im Allgemeinen 16 – 20 h.
Kopfschmerz r.
Otitis media r.
Dicke, gelbe übelriechende Absonderung aus den Ohren
Rachenentzündung r.
Schlaf, schläft in r. Seitenlage
Klebriger, übelriechender Schweiß
Lautes Rumoren im Bauch
Geblähter und aufgetriebener Bauch, sogar nach kleinsten Nahrungsmengen
Bauch- und Magenschmerz, > Reiben des Bauches (Kleinkind/Säugling)
Stuhl ist anfänglich hart o. verstopft und wird dann weich oder flüssig
Sodbrennen, saures Aufstoßen
Grippaler Infekt
Nux-v.:
Niesen und Schnupfen morgens erwachend
Säuglinge mit Koliken, mit wütendem Durchbiegen des Rückens
Grippe o. andere fieberhafte Erkrankungen mit hohem Fieber und Schüttelfrost
Muss in jedem Fieberstadium zugedeckt sein
Frösteln beim Aufdecken, will dann aber nicht mehr bedeckt sein
Trockene Hitze des Körpers
Blasenentzündung mit ständigem Harndrang, nur das Entleeren kleiner Mengen
verschafft für Augenblicke Linderung. > Wärme
Schnupfen fliesend am Tag, verstopft nachts.
Heiserkeit mit Kratzen im Hals
Husten führt zu berstendem Kopfschmerz.
Sulph.:
Höhenangst, sogar wenn andere sich an einem hochgelegenen Ort befinden.
Grippaler Infekt
<: 11 h./im Winter/nachts.
Unmäßiges Schwitzen - übelriechend
Kopfschmerz am Wochenende
Entzündung der Lidränder mit Ausfallen der Wimpern
Nasennebenhöhlenentzündung, chronisches eitriges Nasensekret
Sodbrennen
DURST auf eiskalte Getränke
Durchfall o. weicher Stuhl, morgens gegen 5 h. sehr übelriechend
Enuresis (Knaben)
Husten, < nachts im Bett
Grünlicher, eitriger, süßlicher Auswurf
Schleimrasseln
Atemnot mitten in der Nacht, > Hochsitzen
Schläft in l. Seitenlage
Eup-per.
Grippaler Infekt: 1. Frostschauer, 2. mit hohem Fieber (morgens 7 – 9 h.)
enorme Schmerzen in den Knochen
Steifheit in den Gliedmaßen
DURST auf kalte Getränke, besonders während des Froststadiums.
Kopfschmerz, der während o. nach dem Fieber auftritt
Rückenschmerz „Als ob Rücken zerbrochen“
Gels.
Beschwerden, die seit einem grippalen Infekt nicht mehr verschwinden wollen.
Durstlos
Herabfallen der Augenlider, kann kaum die Augen offen halten.
Beim Fieberanstieg, wie betäubt und gelähmt.
Beim Fieber, will festgehalten werden, weil er so zittert.
Fieber mit Schwindel
Trockener Husten mit Wundschmerz in der Brust und Fließschnupfen.
Bry.
< allgemein durch jede Art von Bewegung/gegen 21 h./Liegen auf der schmerzhaften Seite; > durch Druck;
Schwindel durch die geringste Bewegung
Durst auf große Mengen
Erkältungen wandern zur Brust herab.
Trockener, harter schmerzhafter Husten, muss sich die Brust halten.
Schläft in l. Seitenlage
Heiserkeit < im Freien
Hackender Husten, durch Reizung in der oberen Luftröhre.
Stiche in der Brust
Fieber innerlich, fühlt sich äußerlich normal bis kalt an.
Rhus-t.
Durstig, trinkt in kleinen Schlucken am liebsten kalte Milch.
> Jede Art von Bewegung
Grippe mit SCHMERZ, Patient dreht sich dauernd um die Lage zu verändern.
Fieber steigt sehr schnell, besonders 10 h.
Zunge ist trocken und braun.
1. Frösteln, „Als ob kaltes Wasser über ihn gegossen würde“, 2. Hitze und Neigung zum Gliederstrecken.
Trockener, quälender Husten von Mitternacht bis Morgen, sowie beim Schüttelfrost o. Hände aus dem Bett haltend.
Bell.
durstlos
Fieber, fühlt sich an, „Als ob die Hand bei der Untersuchung verbrennen“.
Gesicht, rot, heiß, selten bläulich rot, glüht beim Fieber.
Fieberkrampf
Eitrige Mandelentzündung, < r.
Kitzelnder, kurzer, trockener Husten
Kehlkopf sehr schmerzhaft.
Hohe, pfeifende Stimme, Stöhnen bei jedem Atemzug.
Pupillen erweitert.
Halluzinationen, explosionsartige Wutausbrüche.
Mittelohrentzündung, hochgradige pulsierende Schmerzen (gewöhnlich rechtsseitig).
< nachts.
Cham.
< Allgemein gegen 9 h. o. zwischen 21 – 22 h.
Jämmerlich und unruhig, Zorn, reizBAR
Will nicht untersucht werden.
Muss umher getragen werden.
Mittelohrentzündung eher links.
Fieber mit einseitiger Frostschauer, Gesicht einseitig rot.
Kolik - Kleinkind, Säugling, lässt sich nicht trösten, biegt sich nach hinten durch,
schreit zornig.
Durchfall während des Zahnens, riecht nach faulen Eiern.
Füße sind heiß, werden unter der Bettdecke hervorgestreckt.
Dros.
Heftige Hustenanfälle, die so stark sein können, dass der Patient keine Luft bekommt und blau anläuft.
Husten verursacht Nasenbluten/< nach Mitternacht
Bronchitis, Krupp, Keuchhusten, ist sein Anwendungsgebiet.
Husten, Kitzeln im Kehlkopf.
Fieber und kein Durst/mit innerem Frösteln/mit kalten Schauern/mit heißem Gesicht/mit kalten Händen
Immer zu kalt, auch im Bett.
< nach Mitternacht.
Phos.
Jede Erkältung schlägt auf die Brust.
Heiserkeit
Anhaltender, kitzelnder Husten.
Enormer Durst auf kalte Getränke.
Schläft auf der rechten Seite.
Atemwegsinfekte, Bronchitis, Erkältungen, Grippe, Krupp.
Fieber mit klebrigem Nachtschweiß, mit kalten Knien nachts.
Fieber, egal welche Erkrankung dahinter steckt, Fieber ist etwas ganz normales und wir sollten dankbar sein, dass der Körper in der Lage ist, sich zu wehren.
Die Frage ist, wie gehen wir damit um.
1. Die Mama muss beruhigt werden, damit sie nicht aus lauter Angst dauernd Fieberzäpfchen gibt.
2. Das Continua-Fieber = anhaltendes Fieber, ohne wesentliche Schwankungen.
Meist über 39° C und nicht um mehr als 1° schwankend.
Sehr wichtig: Hier hilft kein Belladonna!
Phos. Gels. Bry. Rhus-t.
Dieser Fieber-Typus gehört nicht zur Hausapotheke (z.B. Typhus)
3. Remittierendes-Fieber = stärker schwankend, aber stets über Normaltemperatur.
Aconitum, Belladonna, Bryonia, Chamomilla,
Gelsemium, Eupatorium-perfoliatum.
- Kleinkind, bei: Die wichtigsten Mittel sind hier: Aconitum, Belladonna, Chamomilla und Gelsemium. Nur dieses remittierende Fieber gehört zur Hausapotheke.
4. Das intermittierende Fieber = Fieberspitzen wechseln mit unter- o. Normaltemperatur. Das Fieber ist schubweise oft unterbrochen von einem bis mehreren fieberfreien Tagen. Auch dieser Fiebertypus gehört nicht zur Hausapotheke (Malaria).
Zusammenfassend die Hausapotheke gehört nur zum remittierenden Fieber, also stärker schwankend, aber stets über Normaltemperatur.
[Mir Zahid]
A
Indications for Medium, High and Low Potencies in Homeopathy. The potency
selection guidelines in this article are a collection of personal views of
various authors and are based on individual experiences.
Editor’s Note: The potency selection guidelines in this article are a collection of
personal views of various authors and are based on individual experiences. These
are not definite indications for the use of any potency and some of the
guidelines might not get approval from many modern homeopaths. These guidelines
can add to our understanding of the complex issue of homeopathic posology but
should not be followed blindly in any case.
HIGH POTENCIES
In
acute diseases 1M and 10M are the most useful. From 10M to the MM are all
useful for all ordinary chronic diseases in persons not so sensitive.
In
persons suffering from chronic sickness and not so sensitive, the 10M may first
be used, and continued without change so long as improvement lasts; then the
50M will act precisely in the same manner, and should be used so long as the
patient makes progress toward health; them the CM may be used in the same
manner, and the DM and MM in succession. By this use of the series of potencies
in a given case, the patient can be held under the influence of the similimum,
or a given remedy, until cured. …… (Kent)
The
more similar the remedy, the more clearly and positively the symptoms of a
patient take on the peculiar and characteristic form of the remedy, the greater
the susceptibility to that remedy, and the higher the potency required.
Generally
speaking, susceptibility is greatest in children and young, vigorous persons,
and diminishes with age. Children are particularly sensitive during
development, and the most sensitive organs are those which are being developed.
Therefore the medicines which have a peculiar affinity for those organs should
be given in the medium or higher potencies.
The
higher potencies are best adopted to sensitive persons of the nervous, sanguine
or choleric temperament; to intelligent, intellectual persons, quick to act and
react; to zealous and impulsive persons.
If
the potency is too high its action may be too deep and far reaching, and the reaction
too great for the weakened vital power to carry on. Such remedies as Sulphur,
Calcarea carbonica, Mercurius, Arsenic and Phosphorus, given in the 50M or CM
potencies, have sometimes hastened tubercular or tertiary syphilis cases into
the grave. In beginning treatment of such suspicious or possibly incurable
cases it is better to use medium potencies, like the 30th or 200th and go
higher gradually, if necessary, as treatment progresses and the patient
improves… (S. Close)
When
the symptoms of a case clearly indicate one remedy, whose characteristic
symptoms correspond closely to the characteristic symptoms of the case, we give
high potencies—thirtieth, two hundredth, thousandth, or higher according to
the prescriber’s degree of confidence and the contents of his medicine case.
…………………. (Jahr)
If
a case seems relatively curable and free of physical pathology, higher initial
potencies may be tried, ranging from 30 to CM. The primary guiding principle
here is the degree of certainty which the homoeopath has about the remedy. If
the medicine seems very obvious and covers the case very well, a very high
potency may be given in a person with a curable system. If the remedy is not so
clear, it is better to begin with a potency closer to 30. …………………………………… (George
Vithoulkas)
In
children with acute ailments (because their defensive mechanisms are quite
strong), it is best not to give potencies lower than 200; thus 200 to CM
potencies can be given, depending upon certainty of the medicine for acute
ailments.
An
M.D with a few years’ experience in homoeopathy attempted to treat a child
suffering from severe mental disorders. The patient had received approximately
fifteen remedies, some of which had partial actions and others of which had no
action. The case was sent to me and the case taken during the initial interview
showed clearly Veratrum Album, which had been given only as the tenth
prescription amidst a variety of others. Based upon this initial interview,
Veratrum Album 50M (it is best to with go high potencies if possible in such
cases) was given again with instructions to wait after that for a full three
months in order to fully evaluate the direction of the
remedy……………………………….(George Vithoulkas)
MEDIUM POTENCIES
From
30th to 10M will be found those curative powers most useful in very sensitive
women and children.
In
sensitive women and children, it is well to give the 30th or 200th at first,
permitting the patient to improve in a general way, after which the 1M may be
used in similar manner. After improvement with that ceases, the 10M may be
required.
Some
patients are very sensitive to the highest potencies and are cured mildly and
permanently by the use of 200th or 1000th. There are other individuals who are
torn to pieces by the use of the highest potencies.
Patients
who have heart disease, or who are suffering from phthisis are apt to have
their sufferings increased and the end hastened by the higher potencies; they
do better under 30th or 200th.
If
you strike too high she is not sensitive, it is not sufficient. Keep to the
mild potency so long as it works. It is not well to jump too many degrees. From
the crude to 10M there is a range of degrees in ordinary persons. . (Kent)
A
single dose of the appropriate nosode (In a case, which is not at all susceptible
to the indicated remedy) in a moderately high potency, will sometimes clear up
a case by bringing symptoms into view which will make it possible to select the
remedy required to carry on the case. ……………………………………… (Stuart Close)
A
correctly chosen remedy given in too low or sometimes too high a potency, or in
too many doses, may cause an aggravation of the existing symptoms as to
endanger the life of the patient; especially if the patient be a child or a
sensitive person and if a vital organ, like the brain or lung be affected. Belladonna
in the third or sixth potency, given in too frequent doses in a case of
meningitis, for example, may cause death from over-action; whereas the
thirtieth or two hundredth potency given in single dose or in doses repeated only
until some change of symptoms is noticed, will speedily cure. Phosphorus 3rd or
6th in pneumonia under similar circumstances may rapidly cause death. The low
potencies of deeply acting medicines are dangerous in such cases in proportion
to their similarity to the symptoms. ……………………………. (Stuart Close)
Oversensitive
patients present a unique problem for potency selection. There are patients who
are excessively “nervous” reactive to all physical and emotional stimuli,
usually lean and quick in their movements, restless, sensitive to odors and
noise and light, and frequently suffering strongly from exposure to chemicals
in the environment or food. Such people are very reactive both to low potencies
(on physical level) and high potencies (on electrodynamic level). Consequently,
it is better to restrict initial prescriptions to 30 or 200 in such patients;
depending upon their reaction, later potencies might go higher or lower. But
initially at least, 30 or 200 are the best selections for oversensitive
patients. …(George Vithoulkas)
On
the other hand, another young person comes to you with a similar complaint, but
you cannot decide whether she needs Pulsatilla or Sulphur. You finally decide
upon Pulsatilla after many hours of careful study; in this instance, you would
tend to give only a 30 or 200 for the initial prescription because of the lack
of clarity.
In
still another case with a skin eruption, you may see clearly that Pulsatilla is
indicated. Yet the patient reports that she able keep her skin eruption under
control by using cortisone ointment “only” twice a week. Further you observe
that there are other weaknesses of the organism—a weak vitality, the patient
is easily tired, easily affected by chemicals in the environment. In this type
of case you would not give a potency higher than 200; otherwise you may witness
an unnecessary prolonged aggravation.
If
the patient is elderly, chronically weakened, or even if severely weakened by
the acute ailment (for example, if it has developed into a severe pneumonia), a
200 potency would be preferable for the initial prescription, even if the
remedy is quite obvious. …(George Vithoulkas)
LOW POTENCIES
Sometimes
very sensitive patients will do well on a high potency if they have been
prepared for it by the use of a lower one. (connect sentences) I have seen
Sulphur and Phosphorus act so strongly that I have regretted it. In lung cases,
consider whether she has lung space enough to make recovery probable. If she
can bear it, give it in low potency, but do not give it if there is not lung
space enough to warrant it. ……. (Kent)
Where
the symptoms are not clearly developed and there is an absence or scarcity of
characteristic features; or where two or three remedies seem about equally
indicated, susceptibility and reaction may be regarded as low. We give,
therefore, the remedy which seems most similar, in a low (third to twelfth)
potency. …………………. (Jahr)
Lower
potencies and larger and frequent doses correspond better to torpid and
phlegmatic individuals, dull of comprehension and slow to act; to coarse
fibered, sluggish individuals of gross habits; to those who possess great
muscular power but who require a powerful stimulus to excite them. Such persons
can take with seeming impunity large amounts of stimulants like whisky, and
show little effect from them. When ill they often require low potencies, or
even sometimes material doses. …………(Stuart Close)
If
the grade of the disease is low, and the power of reaction low, the remedy must
be given low. Thus we find, in such cases, that the symptoms of the patient are
usually of a low order; common, pathological symptoms; organ symptoms; gross
terminal symptoms; symptoms that correspond to the effects of crude drugs in
massive toxic doses. The finer shadings of symptoms belonging to acute
conditions, in vigorous sensitive patients, do not appear. Potentized medicines
will not act. The case has passed beyond that stage, and finer symptoms with
it. Yet the symptoms remain and the almost hopeless conditions they represent,
are still within the scope of the homoeopathic law; and they sometimes yield to
its power, when the related law of posology is rightly understood and applied.
People
who are accustomed to long and severe labour out-of-doors, who sleep little and
whose food is coarse, are less susceptible. Persons exposed to continual
influence of drugs, such as tobacco workers and dealers; distillers and brewers
and all connected with the liquor and tobacco trade; druggists, perfumers,
chemical workers, etc. often possess little susceptibility to medicines and
usually require low potencies in the illnesses.
The
seat, character and intensity of the disease has some bearing upon the question
of the dose. Certain malignant and rapidly fatal diseases, like cholera, may
require material doses or low potencies of the indicated remedy.
Occasionally
a case will be met which is not at all susceptible to the indicated remedy. Hahnemann
has recommended in such cases, the administration of Opium, in one of the
lowest potencies, every eight or twelve hours until some signs of reaction are
perceptible. By this, he says, the susceptibility is increased and the new
symptoms of the diseases are brought to light. Carbo-veg, Laurocerasus, Sulphur
and Thuja are other remedies suited to such conditions. They sometimes serve to
arouse the organism to reaction so that indicated remedies will act. ……….(S. Close)
There
are certain types of cases in which relatively low potencies should be used¯ at
least initially. Patients who have weak constitutions, old people, or very
hypersensitive people should initially be given potencies ranging, roughly,
from 12x to (space)200. The reason for this is that higher potencies can over
stimulate the weakened defense mechanism, resulting in unnecessary powerful
aggravations.
Children
who are suffering from severe problems should generally be given low potencies.
An infant with severe eczema or psoriasis is likely to have a severe
aggravation if given a high potency. Consequently, such cases might be given
just a few doses (say daily) of a 12x, or just one dose of a 30 or 200.
Generally,
cases with known malignancy should not initially be given potencies above200. If
a case is merely suspected to have a malignant or premalignant condition, the
initial prescription should not be higher than 1M. Again such potency
restriction is in order to avoid unnecessary powerful physical aggravations,
which require considerable experience to manage. ……………… George Vithoulkas)
—————————————
Excerpted from : The
Appropriate Potency by Dr. Mir Zahed
Dr. Zahed in an honorary
lecturer at the Homoeopathic Academy of Niagara- Canada. He has authored the
following books:
1. How to Understand the
Homoeopathic Materia Medica.
2. Case Taking in the Light of Organon.
3. The Appropriate Potency.
Cures
of Animals with High Potencies
Vorwort/Suchen Zeichen/Abkürzungen Impressum