Mitteln Anhang 2
[David Little]
A Comparison of the C and LM Potency 5th and 6th
Organon
Part 1: Development of the LM Potency
A homoeopath should have a deep knowledge of the models of the 4th and 5th
Organon to understand the Homoeopathy of the 1840s, which is found in the 6th
edition. Homoeopathy as commonly practiced today is based on the single dry
dose wait and watch method of the 1st Chronic Diseases (1828) and
the 4th Organon (1829).
In this method a single pellet dose of the centesimal potency is used as
long as the patient is improving even in the slightest manner. Many of the
great 19th century homoeopaths like James Kent were masters of this
method.
The dry dose may only be repeated when there is a definite relapse of
the old symptoms calling for repetition. H. was not completely comfortable with
this method in cases that only slowly improved over a longer period of time.
For this reason, in the 5th Organon (1833) H. introduced
olfaction and the oral medicinal solution as a new delivery system for
homoeopathic remedies. The change from a dry static pellet dose to a dynamic
medicinal solution succussed prior to administration had an immediate impact on
his posology and case management strategies.
In the 5th Organon he suggested any "striking
progressive improvement" precludes the repetition of the remedy because
the cure is already taking place at the fastest possible rate.
Part 2: Differences between the C and LM Potencies
The high potency Cs are diluted more times then the LM potency although
they receive less succussions at each dilution
level of potency. The higher potency Cs like 200c and 1M have a smaller
amount of substance, and more commutative numbers of succussions and dilutions
than the LM potency.
For this reason, some persons think the LMs are low potency remedies.
The LM potency, however, has a much larger dilution ratio that greatly
transforms the medicinal qualities of the LM remedies. In footnote f to
aphorism 270 of the 6th Organon (O'Reilly edition) H. suggests the
following:
"In earlier instructions,
I specified that a whole drop of a liquid in a given potency be added to 100
drops of wine spirit for higher potentization.
"But meticulous
experiments have convinced me that this proportion of the dilution medium to
the medicine being dynamized (100:1) is much too narrowly limited to develop
the powers of the medicinal substance properly and to a high degree, by means
of a large number of succussions, unless one uses great force."
The Founder realized that continuing to increase the number of dilutions
and succussions of the centesimal potency did not fill the desired therapeutic
lacuna in his new healing art. He came to see that the 1 to 100 dilution ratio
is limited by its smaller dilution factor so he began to experiment with new
larger dilution ratios rather than raising the C potency to higher and higher
degrees.
He also noticed that when strong succussions were used in such a small dilution
medium as the centesimal 1 to 100 ratio it makes aggressive medicines prone to
quick aggravation and unproductive secondary curative effects in the long run.
"With a ratio of the
dilution medium to the medicine as low as 100:1, very many impacts by means of
a powerful machine, as it were, are forced in. As a result, medicines arise
that, especially in
the higher degree of dynamization, almost instantaneously but with
stormy - indeed dangerous - intensity, impinge on patients (especially the delicate
ones) without bringing about an enduring,
gentle counter-action of the life-principle."
Once again we see the importance of the balance of the primary action of
the remedy and curative response of the vital force. When too many dilutions
and strong succussions have been forced into the higher centesimal potencies it
makes medicines that are prone to aggressive primary actions and strong
aggravations that do not produce an "enduring gentle counter action of the
life principle".
Such furious or prolonged aggravations are to be avoided at all cost as
they disrupt the natural symptom pattern, waste vitality, and complicate the
cure.
The LM potency, on the other hand, is given in the smallest liquid dose
so it produces a mild primary effect and a long enduring gentle counter action
of the vital principle.
During the period of the 5th Organon (1833) Hahnemann used
the unmodified liquid dose made up each time from 1 or 2 poppy seed size
pellets. In aphorism 29 of the 5th Organon H. described how the
centesimal method works. He wrote that the similar homoeopathic remedy
"pushed into the place of the weaker natural disease" against which
the instinctive vital force was "compelled to direct an increased amount
of energy".
The idea of pushing into place and compelling the vital force to
increase its energy against the remedy is based on the phenomena of the
homoeopathic aggravation. The methods of the 4th and 5th Organon are based on a crisis-like
aggravation in contrast to the gentle medicinal solution and the non-invasive
LM method.
Aggravation in the 5th edition (1833)
The centesimal model of cure still involves the idea of crisis where
aggravation of symptoms compels the vital force to increase energy in order to
remove the remedy disease and begin convalescence.
The idea of crisis as an integral part of the cure is very ancient. This
is before H. discovered the non-invasive method of the LM potency, the
medicinal solution, and the split-dose.
Vide aphorism 279 of the 5th edition (1833).
"The pure experience
shows UNIVERSALLY...
A DOSE OF THE HOMOEOPATHIC
SELECTED REMEDY CAN NEVER BE PREPARED SO SMALL THAT IT SHALL NOT BE STRONGER
THAN THE NATURAL DISEASE, AND SHALL NOT BE ABLE TO OVERPOWER, EXTINGUISH, AND
CURE IT, AT LEAST IN PART, AS LONG AS IT IS CAPABLE OF CAUSING SOME, THOUGH BUT
A LIGHT PREPONDERANCE OF ITS OWN SYMPTOMS, OVER THOSE OF THE DISEASE RESEMBLING
IT (slight homoeopathic aggravation, aph. 157-160) IMMEDIATELY AFTER ITS
INGESTION." [Capitals by DL.]
The need for aggravation was also stressed as an integral part of cure
in aphorism 282.
"The smallest possible
dose of homoeopathic medicine capable of producing only the very slightest
homoeopathic aggravation, will because it has the power of exciting symptoms
bearing the greatest possible resemblance to the original disease (but yet
stronger even in the minute dose), attack principally and almost solely the
parts in the organism that are already affected, highly irritated and rendered
excessively susceptible to such a similar stimulus".
H. goes on to say that this medicinal disease alters the vital force
that rules the susceptible parts to a state of very similar artificial disease
"so that the living organism now suffers from the artificial medicinal
disease alone, which, from its nature and owing to the minuteness of dose, will
soon be extinguished by the vital force that is striving to return to the
normal state".
The idea of a crisis-like aggravation compelling the vital force to
increase its energy was part of the old dry dose and unadjusted liquid dose
method of the 1830s.
In the 6th Organon H. replaces the model that includes the
necessity of a aggravation-like crisis with the idea that the dose can never be
made so small that it cannot overcome the disease without aggravation.
In the LM model aggravation at the start of treatment is a sign of too
large a dose or too high a potency and unnecessary repetition of the remedy.
Vide aphorism 279 of the 6th Organon (1842).
"This pure experience now
shows UNIVERSALLY that:
1. if considerable corruption
of an important [vital organ] organ does not obviously lie at the base of the
disease (even if the disease is chronic and complicated) and
2. if during treatment, all
other foreign medicinal impingements on the patent have been withheld, then THE
DOSE of a HOMOEOPATHICALLY CHOSEN, HIGHLY POTENTIZED REMEDY FOR THE BEGINNING
OF TREATMENT OF AN IMPORTANT (CHRONIC) DISEASE, AS A RULE CAN NEVER BE PREPARED
SO SMALL THAT IT WOULD NOT:
BE STILL STRONGER THAN THE
NATURAL DISEASE,
BE ABLE, AT LEAST IN PART, TO OVER-TUNE
THE NATURAL DISEASE,
EVEN BE ABLE TO EXTINGUISH
A PART OF THE NATURAL DISEASE IN THE FEELING OF THE LIFE PRINCIPLE, THUS
PRODUCING A BEGINNING OF THE CURE." [Capitals by DL.]
All of the references to the need for crisis-like aggravation to push
the remedy in place of the natural disease and compel an increase of energy of
the vital force are removed from the 6th Organon. There is no need
to force, push, compel, or aggravate in the non-invasive LM method of the
1840s.
This represents a shift in the homoeopathic paradigm from compelling
through aggravation to a completely non-invasive method of posology. In
Hahnemann's advanced methods there is no need
of aggravations, crises, over medication, antidotes, long periods of
waiting, or any excess counter reactions.
All these side effects have been removed from the homoeopathic system of
the 1840s.
The old dry dose method is like a roller coaster ride as first comes the
homoeopathic remedy, then comes waiting out the crisis-like aggravation, then
comes waiting out any improvement, and then comes waiting for the relapse. Then
the dry dose is given again and the whole "up and down start and stop
process" begins all over again.
The idea that aggravation is necessary is common among 4th
and 5th Organon homoeopaths, especially those who use too many dry
pills as a dose. This is because too many pills of the high potency centesimals
can cause aggravations that can run for days, weeks, and months.
H. noted clearly that too large a dose (too many pills) will cause an
aggravation even if the potency is correct. Many consider aggravations
necessary because the idea of the need for aggravation
is over stressed in the Homoeopathy of the 1820's and 1830s.
To overcome these side-effects Hahnemann used the medicinal solution of
the LM potency made from 1 poppy seed size pill in a minimum of 7 tablespoons.
From this solution 1, 2, or 3 teaspoons was stirred into a glass with 8 to 10
tablespoons of water and 1, 2, or 3 teaspoons was given to the patient.
In this method the size of the dose is greatly reduced as the potency is
gradually increased so that the vital force never receives the same exact dose
twice in succession. In this way, the vital force
can receive the single dose or a series of doses in medicinal solution
without the aggravations witnessed in the dry or unmodified liquid dose. In
this way, we can speed the cure to one half, one fourth, or less than the time
of the old method.
Part 3: Primary and Secondary Effects
There are many powers in nature, but the potentized remedy is a unique
creation of the intellect of H. In aphorism 64 of the 6th Organon
the Founder recorded that there were two types of secondary actions.
The first is the opposing counter action where the organism
automatically presents an opposite state proportionate to its energy. The
second is the curative counter action to a homoeopathic remedy where the vital
force directs its whole energy to remove the mistuning from without while
reestablishing homeostasis.
Vide part two of aphorism 64 of the 6th Organon.
"If there is no state in
nature exactly opposite to the initial action, THE LIFE FORCE APPEARS TO STRIVE
TO ASSERT ITS SUPERIORITY by extinguishing the alteration produced in itself
from without (by the medicine), in place of which it reinstates its norm
(after-action, curative-action)." [Capitals by DL.]
This action by the life force to assert its superiority is the power of
the curative secondary action. To accomplish this goal the vital force heals
the pathology in stages from within to without in response to the remedy as
seeks control over homeostasis thus completely removing the dynamic mistuning.
This establishes another aspect of H.'s Direction of Cure, as compiled
in Hering's Laws.
If the balance between the primary action and the secondary action is
maintained there will be no aggravations or excessive counter actions during
the process of cure. The instinctive vital force does not react in an opposing
manner to a potentized remedy, but rather, seeks to manifest its superior
vitality over the remedial disease from without while reestablishing
homeostatic balance within.
The life force may produce opposing reaction against the wrong remedy
and too large a dose. If the remedy has been given in the medicinal solution in
a proper small amount the vital force will have little problem removing the
remedial influence and no antidotes will be needed. If the dose is too large or
in too high a potency it may mistune the vital force with a long term medicinal
disease (aphorism 276).
For this reason, the dose, potency and repetition must be carefully
controlled.
Opposing Secondary Actions
In aphorism 65 H. gives several examples of the primary and opposing
secondary actions that take place under the influence of various medicinal
powers (counter-action - after action, aph. 64, point 1).
"Where there is such a
one, the life force brings forth the exact opposite condition-state
(counter-action, after-action) to the impinging action (initial action) that
has been absorbed into itself.
The counter-action is produced in as great a degree as was the impinging
action (initial action) of the artificial morbific or medicinal potence on it,
proportionate to the life force's own energy."
Here the vital force is compelled to produce an antagonistic secondary
action in which it presents the opposite state in proportionate energy. The
following 3 examples represent the principles very well. Vide Organon aphorism
65:
"A hand bathed in hot
water is at first much warmer than the other unbathed hand (initial action),
but once it is removed and thoroughly dried, it becomes cold after some time,
and then much colder than the other hand (after-action)."
"An arm immersed in the
coldest water for a long time is at first far paler and colder than the other
one (initial action), but once it is removed from the cold water and dried off
it becomes not only warmer than the other but hot, red and inflamed
(after-action of the life force). "
"The heavy, stuporous
sleep caused by opium (initial action) is followed the next night by greater
insomnia (counter action)."
"And thus, after each
initial action of a potence that in large dosage strongly modifies the
condition of the healthy body, our life force always and everywhere brings to
pass, in the after action,
the exact opposite state (when, as stated, there really is such)."
Strong medicines in large doses tend to cause opposing counter actions
from the life force. Sooner or later the vital force will oppose any medicine
in a large dose (including homoeopathic) with antagonistic counter actions.
In Homoeopathy the vital force is exposed to a very small dose of a
highly potentized substance that elicits a pure curative effects from the Lebenskraft
without any over reactions.
Phase 4: Curative Action
Homoeopathic cures take place because of the unusually small dose of a
high potency of a similar remedy (aphorism 68 with reference to 64, point 2).
To this subtle medicinal disease the life force needs to use no more secondary
effect than necessary to remove the new similar artificial disease and return
the organism to complete recovery. There is no state in nature that is exactly
the opposite of a simillimum in the correct potency and a minimum dose.
Due to the extraordinary high potency and small amount of the remedy the
primary action gently overtunes the natural disease without any aggravation
(primary action- 63).
After this the life principle seeks to assert its superiority by
removing the remedy mistuning from without by returning to full health and
vitality within (counter action - curative action - 64B).
"If there is no state in
nature exactly opposite to the initial action, the life force appears to strive
to assert its superiority by extinguishing the alteration produced in itself
from without (by the medicine), in place of which it reinstates its norm
(after-action, curative-action)."
This healing process ideally takes place with no aggravations, no
crisis, and no overly noticeable reactions other than the rapid restoration of
health and vitality (148). That is the goal of the Similia Minimus of the 6th
Organon.
High potency centesimals made on machines with many dilutions with
strong succussions produce aggravations at the start of treatment that limit
the curative secondary effect of the vital force.
In the LM method the gentle primary effect of the remedy replaces the
natural disease without aggravation at the start of treatment and produces a
long enduring gentle curative effect in the life force that removes the remedy
disease from without and returns to full and health vitality within.
With the LM potency there is no need for a crisis-like aggravation to
cure natural diseases. The proper LM simillimum in the minimal dose produces rapid
transformations to the state of health and the restoration of vitality without
any noticeable excessive reactions.
The 6th Organon demonstrate the foolishness of those who say
the vital force removes no mistuning and plays no active role in healing. Like
the mechanists of the old school they think of cure only in terms of a
medicinal power rather then a combination of the remedy action and the curative
effect of the Lebenskraft, the Vigor Vita.
H. spoke of the essential role of life force, in the Preface to the
Introduction of the 6th Organon in 1842.
"Homoeopathy is aware
that a cure can only succeed through the COUNTER-ACTION of the LIFE FORCE
against the CORRECTLY CHOSEN MEDICINE. The stronger the life force that still
prevails in the patient, the more certain and faster the cure that takes
place".
H. confirmed Paris,
184-." [capitals DL]
The correct dose of the LM potency in medicinal solution produces a
non-aggressive primary action, no aggravations, and a long enduring gentle
curative effect by the life principle.
Even during the curative response the remedy may still be repeated at
suitable intervals when it is necessary to speed the cure. The curative
reaction of the vital force is not disrupted by the repetition of the minimal
size dose of the medicinal solution of the remedy as is witnessed by the
repetition of the dry dose.
The cycle of healing with the LM remedy is - small liquid dose - no
aggravation - enduring gentle secondary effect - removal of the remedial
disease - cessation of remedy duration - the complete return of health and full
vitality.
This demonstrates the important role that H. gave to the Lebenskraft in
the 6th Organon. The goal of the LM strategy is a smooth,
continuous, graduated ascent to health and vitality through
30 microtonal potencies without aggravations.
Actions of the Centesimal Remedies
H. wrote in the 5th Organon (1833) that the C potency tends
to produces aggravations within one to two weeks after the administration of a
C potency in chronic diseases.
In 1833 H. still thought that he had to compel the vital force to
increase its energy through crisis-like aggravation to produce a enduring
curative effect over time. This phenomenon is so common with the dry C pellets
that many homoeopaths still think they must aggravate to compel the vital force
to cure.
H. changed his opinion about the need for aggravation when he discovered
the LM potency and the split-dose of the medicinal solution in the 1840s.
The remedial powers of the centesimal scale reaches its peak very
quickly, promotes crisis, and then brings on a longer duration of secondary
action. The Kentian high potency system has become the modern potency standard
with great jumps of potency levels between 30c - 200c - 1M - 10M - 50M - CM,
etc.
This trend was established by H. as he quite commonly used the 30c, 200c
and experimented with the 1M. These large jumps in potency cause a quick
vertical arc of the potency scale in the upward direction.
Even in medicinal solution the 200c and 1M tend to aggravate toward the
beginning of the treatment rather than the end. This is due to the 100 to 1
dilution ratio and strong succussions.
The nature of the centesimal potencies is quick in their onset as they
reach aggravation at the beginning of the treatment when the pathology is at
its maximum and the vitality the weakest.
This tendency is still witnessed (although in a modified form) in the Cs
in medicinal solutions. The power of the C potency is most similar to rapid onset, quick crisis, and the aggressive
power of
the Cs is similar to accidents, trauma, crisis, strong acute diseases,
virulent acute miasms, crisis or acerbations of the chronic states and miasms,
the functional states of the chronic diseases, and chronic states that start
with strong crisis and then progress over a longer duration.
The large increases in potency degrees of the centesimal potencies
enhance the aggressive nature of the 1/100 dilution ratio and the centesimal
potency system. The medicinal solution moderates
the aggressive tendencies of the Cs but they still tend to aggravate
more quickly, more forcefully, and for longer duration than the correctly given
LM potencies.
Actions of the LM Potencies
Chronic diseases often have an insidious onset, slowly increasing
pathology, and reach crisis after a longer period of years. The LM potency is
subtle in its onset, uses a series of slowly increasing potencies, and they
reach aggravation at the end of the treatment.
The LM potency scale is homoeopathic to many chronic diseases and miasms.
In the 6th Organon (1843) H. wrote that the LM scale produces
aggravations at the end of the treatment when the
patient is completely well if the dose is controlled.
By the publication of the 6th Organon H. no longer believed
it was necessary to compel the vital force to cure through aggravations. There
are no aggravations with the LM potency if the remedy
is slowed down as the patient improves and stopped at the correct time.
This effect is enhanced with the C's in medicinal solution but their
nature still tends toward a quicker aggravation due to their 1 to 100 dilution
ratio.
Partial simillimums tend to change the natural symptom patterns too
quickly calling for a new more perfect remedy. For this reason, the first
prescription is a very important moment in every case.
If the remedy is a true simillimum the patient can be exposed to longer
series of LM potencies 0/1, 0/2, 0/3 to 0/30 until cure is completed over a
longer period of time. The LM potencies are a gradually increasing microtonal
scale of 30 potency degrees that are very similar to the slowly increasing
symptoms of degenerative disease and miasms. This is why they are so well
suited to chronic degenerative diseases and miasms.
The LMs tend to aggravate at the end of treatment when the pathology is
healed and vitality restored. This is a sign that the remedy is no longer
needed. If the remedy is slowed down as the patient improves, there will be no
aggravation at the end of treatment.
The C potencies have a rapid onset and reach aggravation at the
beginning of treatment when the patient is the most ill and the weakest. This
is not the best situation. This is another reason why the LMs are suitable for
many inherited and acquired chronic diseases and miasms.
The properly adjusted LM also works well on serious trauma, virulent
acute disorders, and crisis. Here the higher opening potencies (0/3-0/6) are
sometimes of use although most cases resolve on
LM 0/1 -3.
We have discussed some of the difference between the remedial powers of
the C and LM potency that makes them complementary opposites. Once the
homoeopaths understand the inner nature
of the Cs and LMs they will understand how to use them at the correct
times.
The Paris casebooks show that Hahnemann often used his centesimal
potencies for crisis and acute diseases and switched to the LM potencies for
constitutional treatment and miasms. This is not an absolute rule but a
tendency one sees throughout the cases of his last three years (1840-1843).
Part 5: Administering the LM Potencies
The 3c is called the mother of all potencies because it is the root of
the centesimal scale and LM potency scale. The LM base potency is made from the
3c potency. H.'s low potencies were the
6c, 12, 24, 30, and his high potencies reached 50c to 200c and the LM 0/1
to 0/30.
In some ways, the LM potencies possess many of the positive qualities of
both low and high potencies in balance.
The lower degrees of the LM potency are deeper acting then the 6c to 30c
but they are also more gentle than 200c or 1M on the constitution. They reach a
depth of cure without producing the overly strong primary actions and rapid
aggravations like the high Cs. They have the stability and consistency of the
low potency C's but the power to cure deep chronic diseases and miasms like the
high potencies.
One can tell from H.'s Paris journals that the Founder considered the LM
0/1 a higher potency than 30c as he sometimes started people with a 30c for the
acute and then switched to the LM potency for the chronic conditions.
Also if the lower potencies up to 30c were insufficient, he would then
switch to the LM scale and work upward. In some cases, he began with an
anti-psoric in 30c and then moved over to the LMs.
He also stated in the Organon that the 50,000 to 1 dilution ratio is
more powerful than the 100/1 ratio even at the lowest degrees. One reason is
that many succussions can be used without "forcing" any excess energy
into the pharmaceutical solution.
The LMs are not a "low potency" remedy that can be given daily
or every other day for weeks in some mechanical fashion. They aggravate just
like all other homoeopathic remedies if misused.
I know this personally because I aggravated a number of cases in the
beginning of my LM career. I quickly found out that the LM 0/1 would aggravate
certain sensitive patients and those with organic pathology.
In general, aggravations caused by LMs are of a shorter duration than
the high centesimal potencies. This is another reason they are safer then the
ultra high potency centesimals in many conditions.
The LM potency has the best qualities of the high and low potency
without the aggressive primary actions of the Cs.
If the patient will over react to the action of potencies higher then
30c it is best to use the lower potency Cs like 6c, 12c, 24c, 30c. I tend to
use the lower centesimal potencies in medicinal solution and the split-dose
where I fear aggravations, pathology, and crisis. Then I work my way up to the
30c and change to the LM 0/1 and go through the LM scale.
These people do not do very well on 200c, 1M, etc. In fact, many of them
are incurable by the centesimal potency system alone. Hahnemann used this
method also, although I did not confirm this fact until I studied his casebooks
many years later.
It is a false claim to say that the LMs cannot aggravate so they can be
given daily or every other day for weeks, months and years. Some suggest giving
potencies like LM 0/6, LM18, or some other odd potency daily rather than using
the complete graduated potency scale 0/1 to 0/30 in an artistic manner.
The Paris casebooks show that Hahnemann never gave his remedies in such
a mechanistic manner!
The healing artist takes into account the constitutional sensitivity or
the nature of the disease so they individualize their dose and potency properly.
Mechanical methods are prone to over medication.
Some use the LM potency but they do not understand how to apply the
appropriate case management strategies contained in the 6th Organon
and Paris casebooks in the clinic.
Only When Necessary
In the footnote to aphorism 247 Hahnemann discusses what he said in the
5th Organon updated with the new LM posology methods of the 6th edition. When
he introduces the concept of the daily dose he says that the LM potency may be
taken daily "when necessary".
He also suggested starting the case with the "lowest degrees",
which his Paris casebooks show to be 0/1 to 0/3, and more rarely, 0/4, 0/5,
0/6, 0/7. This is the first octave of LM potencies with the
LM 0/8 starting the next range.
When the daily dose is "not necessary" it will rapidly produce
an over medicated state in which there will be aggravations or accessory
symptoms that change the natural symptom pattern.
H. rarely used the daily dose for very long and always interspersed his
doses with a period of placebo and a period of waiting and watching. The idea
that H. gave the daily dose of the LMs for months or years is a complete myth
as proven by his writings and Paris case journals.
The LM potency will cause aggravations and accessory symptoms just like
every other homoeopathic remedy.
The Paris casebooks show that Hahnemann constantly alternated placebos
with the remedy to control the power of the LM remedies. In his journals he
never gave the alternate day dose for very long without a period of giving
placebos and waiting and watching.
The 6th Organon offers a guidebook on how to use the LM
potency scale safely and effectively through opening in the lowest degrees
(0/1., 0/2., 0/3, etc.) and then ascending through the potency range (0/30).
H.'s opening potencies were 0/1 to 0/7. In most cases he started with LM
0/1., 0/2., 0/3 in his last years. LMs must be treated with the same respect as
all high potencies like 60c, 90c, 100c and 200c. The mechanical repetition of
the LM potency will lead to over medication just like any other homoeopathic
medicine.
There is quite a bit of misunderstanding on this point. Over medication
always causes side effects, changes the natural symptom pattern, and slows down
the cure.
There are many times when a low potency like 30c can only palliate yet
the 200c causes unproductive aggravations that weaken the vitality. This is
because the pathology is too deep for the low potency (6c-30c), and the high
potencies (200c-1M) only cause aggravations without amelioration and loss of
vitality.
In such cases, the LM potency will cure when the centesimal potency will
only palliate or cause harm. This is an area where the LMs act more gently and
safely than high potency Cs if carefully adjusted. The LM potency is also
useful in the elderly where the high potency C's may be counter productive but
cure is still possible.
Part 6: Confessions of an Aspiring Homeopath
I studied in the school of "hard knocks" but I have tried to
learn by my mistakes. I started as a 4th Organon Kentian homoeopath
and I still study Kent as he is one of my favorite teachers.
It took me ten years before I seriously tested H.'s Similia Minimus
found in the Organon. The first time I read the Organon I began to doubt the
Kentian teachings that the "size of the dose has no effect on remedial
actions".
For this reason, I stopped giving a random number of pills under the
illusion that the size of the dose makes no differences. Now I was using only a
few carefully chosen little pills as a dose.
To my surprise I did see less aggravations, especially when using high
potencies like the 200c, 1M and 10M.
At this time, many homoeopaths were just throwing a random number of
pills in the mouth of the patient as a dose. Then the pharmacies started to
make "single dose packs" which contain a large number of pills.
When I read how small H.'s doses were in the 5th Organon I
thought that the dose must be "too small". One pill looks so small in
that great big bottle so I used more. The true power of the Minimus had not yet
dawned in my mind because I was still trying to give the largest dose instead
of the minimal.
At last, I decided to test the methods of the 5th edition
(1833), the 1837 Paris edition of the Chronic Diseases, and the 6th edition
(1842) in that order in a long clinical trial in India.
Yes, I finally tried 1 tiny little poppy seed size pill to make a 7
tablespoon medicinal solution. Then I thought, "If I am not going to give
a single dose and wait and watch for a relapse, then what am
I going to do?" It is a very common fault to read the 6th
Organon without paying much attention to the fine print in the footnotes.
In the main text H. says the LMs can be given daily or on alternate days
but the fine print in the footnotes says "when necessary." So first I
gave the daily and alternate day dose when it was "not necessary" in
a mechanical fashion causing unneeded aggravations in a certain percentage of
cases.
I could tell in the first months that the LM potency was a very deep
acting potency which possesses a unique quality when given in its proper small
dose. I also knew it was easy to over medicate the patient if the LMs are given
in a mechanical fashion every day or every other day.
Then I read the first sentence of aphorism 246 of the 6th
Organon more closely.
"During treatment, every
noticeably progressing and conspicuously increasing improvement is a state
which, as long as it persists, generally excludes any repetition of the
medicine being used because all the good being produced by the medicine is still
hastening towards completion."
This aphorism is very similar to aphorism 245 of the 5th
Organon (1833) Dudgeon edition.
"Every perceptibly
progressive and striking increasing amelioration in a transient (acute) or
persistent (chronic) disease, is a condition, which as long as it lasts,
completely precludes every repetition of the administration of any medicine
whatsoever, because all the good the medicine taken continues to effect is now
HASTENING toward completion"
Part 7: Aphorism 246 of the 6th Organon
Aphorism 245 and 246 of the 5th edition are combined and
rewritten in the final 6th edition making one very long paragraph.
H. first says that any noticeably progressing and strikingly increasing
improvement during treatment excludes the repetition of the remedy because the
cure is already hastening to take place.
This means that any time a single dose, or a series of doses, causes a
strikingly progressive improvement any repetition is counter indicated for the
time being. This is because the vital force is moving toward the cure at a
maximum rate and any more doses will only slow down the cure.
Then the Founder takes up the subject when a single dose only causes a
"slow, continuous improvement" that may take over 50, 60, or 100 days
to complete the cure. In these cases the split-dose of the medicinal solution
may speed the cure to 1/2, 1/4, or less the time it takes the single static dry
dose.
This goal may be accomplished under five conditions.
The remedy must be a true
homoeopathic simillimum.
The remedy should be
administered in medicinal solution.
It must be administered in the
smallest of doses.
The medicinal solution should
be repeated at suitable intervals.
Each dose should be succussed
prior to administering the dose.
This is the basis of H.'s advanced posology that teaches when to wait
and watch as well as when to act according to circumstances. This is what H.
called the middle path approach to posology.
Homoeopathy is a system of flexible response in which the methods of
adjusting the dose are central to case management.
In the 1840s Hahnemann administered 30c to 6c in their descending order
starting from the 30th as he suggested in the Chronic Diseases
(1828). At the same time, he was raising his high potency centesimals like the
198c, 199c and 200c and the LM potencies (0/1- 0/30) starting at the lowest
degrees (0/1-0/7).
H. wrote that the ratio of individual sensitivity varies on a scale of 1
to 1000 (aph. 281). Doses that will not affect a number 1 sensitivity will cause
prolonged aggravations in the number 1000 sensitivity. For this reason, the
Founder used the medicinal solution and the methods of adjusting the potency
and size of the dose.
I quickly found that the LM 0/1 was actually too high a potency for
oversensitive patients, even if diluted in 2 or 3 dilution glasses. Such
remedies could not be repeated in many sensitive constitutions.
In some cases I switched to the 6c -30c range and the patients did much
better. When I worked them up to the 30c, I would then switch them to LM 0/1
rather than give them a 200c. I learned that such constitutions do not tolerate
the large jump in potency offered by 30c, 200c,.1M, 10M, 50M, etc..
In those cases that were too sensitive to tolerate the LM 0/1, I began
with low potency C's and then worked them up to the 30c and finally the LM 0/1.
This works well with heavy organic pathology, hypersensitivity,
allergies, old chronic diseases, one-sided states, and weakened vitality. I
have done this in many cases and it works very well.
When I began to study the microfiches of the Paris casebooks I noticed
immediately that Hahnemann used his lower potencies (30c-6c) on certain case.
He did not give everyone high potency Cs and LMs. I also noticed that he
lowered the potency scale from 30c to 24c, etc., in the 1840s just like he did
in 1828. At the same time, he raised his high potency Cs (198c, 199c, 200c) and
LM potencies (0/1-0/30).
The LMs act smoothly for their remedial powers considering their high
potency actions. For this reason, the LMs are far more suitable than the 200c
and 1M for a good number of patients.
The large gaps between the 30c, 200c, 1M and 10M Centesimal are too
large for many constitutions and chronic conditions. This Kentian system only
offers 7 potencies while there are 30 different micro tonal LM potencies.
These individuals usually do very well on the LMs when they are given
properly. If they take 200c or 1M (esp. the dry dose) it causes unproductive
aggravations and accessory symptoms.
These are some of the differences. The LMs are safe and effective when
the potency, succussions, and dose are individualized and the patient is not
over-medicated.
This microtonal series of 30 graduated LM potencies is much more similar
to the development of degenerative chronic diseases and miasms then the radical
jumps of the centesimals. For this reason it is naturally suited to slow
developing, long lasting chronic diseases and miasms.
It has only been in the last few years that I have the advantage of
reading the microfiches of H.'s Paris Casebooks. This allowed me to personally
review the records of his cases from the LM period (1840-1843).
By carefully reading the 6th Organon and the Paris casebooks
much more information has come to light. I only wish I had access to all this
lost information when I was young.
This situation is finally starting to change as homoeopaths experienced
in the 4th Organon method take up experiments with the revisions
introduced in 5th (1833) and 6th editions (1842).
Today's students are better educated and have more literature then we
did back in 1970. Those who are well trained in the classical methods of the 4th
Organon and the single dose wait and watch method are in a good position to
test the Paris methods of the 1840s. Why?
The method of the Organon is an artistic method that must be
individualized to the patient. There are no preconceived schedules that can
guide one. The daily dose or alternate day dose may be correct for one person
while one dose a week, month or year is sufficient in another.
Any time one gives too many doses one sees the side-effects of over
medication. What a homoeopath learns is when to wait and watch as well as when
to act to speed the cure. Much of modern posology is still 167 years behind the
times but "the times they are a changing".
Part 8: Review of the C and LM Pharmacy
The following is a review of the C and LM pharmacy by potency actions,
rather than comparison of the amount of original substance left in the
dilution.
The Low Potencies 30c, 24c,
18c., 12c, 6c., 3c. The 30c is the median potency between the low and high
potency systems and has some of the qualities of both.
The High Potencies.
A. The high potency Centesimals 200c
and 1M (opening potencies), and the higher centesimal potencies 10M, 50M, CM,
etc. (rarely used for opening a case).
B. The 50 Millesimals, the opening potencies, LM 0/1,
0/2, 0/3, 0/4,0/5, 0/6, 0/7. The middle range (rarely used for opening a case)
LM 0/8, 0/9, 0/10 and the higher LM potencies, 0/11 to 0/30.
One of the first times H. tested the LM potency in 1840 he gave the
0/10! This caused a strong aggravation in the gentleman. He then gave the
patient a placebo and waited and watched. After the aggravation had subsided,
H. lowered the potency degree to avoid further aggravations.
In his last years H. tended to begin cases with LM 0/1, 0/2, 0/3 but
occasionally opened a case with 0/4., 0/5., 0/6, 0/7. The medicinal solution is
suitable for both the split-dose, and when needed, the split-dose given at
suitable intervals to speed the cure.
[David Little]
For this reason the mineral constituents inherent in a plant or animal
remedy deeply affect the nature of the provings and clinical confirmations.
Farrington confirms this in his description of the animal remedies.
"Medicines derived from
the animal kingdom act energetically and rapidly. They vary in intensity from
the fatal snakebite to coral, sponges, etc. which are more or less modified by
their mineral constituents".* Comparative Materia Medica, in Lachesis and
other Allied Remedies, starting page 317.
The animal remedies in general are energetic and rapid in their actions.
The most violent are the animal poison remedies taken from the Opidians. On the
opposite end of the spectrum there is the animal remedy, Calc. usually listed
with the mineral remedies. This remedy is known for its deep slow action and
its cold, torpid, slow functions and stagnations rather than energy or violence
which is represented by its acute complementary, Belladonna, a member of
Solanaceae family. A snake moves quickly across the land while an oyster stays
in the same place on the bottom of the sea. The high calcium content in the
oyster shell is the responsible for the mineral symptoms observed in this
mollusk. Nevertheless, one can not completely understand the nature of Calc.
unless one studies the animal's marine habitat and life cycles.
The first homoeopathic materia medica was Hahnemann's Materia Medica
Pura, which appeared in six parts from 1811 to 1821. This grand work was based
on the provings of the First Provers Union that formed around Hahnemann in
Leipsic. The 'Pura' contains 63 remedies which can be subdivided into 15
minerals, 46 plants, and 2 animal remedies. Even during these early years the
Founder was studying the nature of what he called 'miasmic animalcule' and
their relationships to acute and chronic diseases.
Hahnemann experienced great success in the treatment of acute diseases,
but as early as 1816 he noticed the general constitutional health of his
patients was slowly declining regardless of his treatment.
Of these chronic cases he lamented "their beginning was promising,
the continuation less favorable, the outcome hopeless." As the Founder
pondered the nature of this continual deterioration, he began to search for the
underlying cause of these chronic maladies. For 12 years Hahnemann quietly
investigated the nature of the chronic diseases that were resisting his
homoeopathic treatment.
The Chronic Diseases
The outcome of Hahnemann's research was published in 1828 in the first
edition of “The Chronic Diseases”, their Peculiar Nature and their Homeopathic
Cure. This work made public for the first time Hahnemann's doctrine of the
Psora and the chronic miasms as well as the anti miasmic remedies. The miasm
theory was then integrated into the 4th edition of Organon in 1829 which is the
philosophical counterpart of the 1st Chronic Diseases. These publications led
to the first major schism in the homeopathic school. With the introduction of
the Psora theory and the 30c potency, Hahnemann went too far for some of his
more conservative followers. They were more secure with the homoeopathy that
Hahnemann taught in his early years and could not adapt to the new territory
into which it was expanding.
As Hahnemann investigated these degenerative disorders he found that
certain remedies covered the complete syndrome underlying chronic disease
whereas others were only suitable for various injuries, traumas, crises, acute
diseases and miasms, and the acute-acerbations of a chronic miasms. This led to
the classification of homeopathic remedies into the two grand categories,
psoric or anti miasmic remedies, and the apsoric or non miasmic medicines. In
the “Chronic Diseases” Hahnemann introduced his new miasmic remedies because
they had potential to remove the fundamental causes of chronic diseases rather
then treating one or another of its symptom complexes.
A deep understanding of the pathology and symptoms of the miasms is
necessary to apply Hahnemann's advanced methods. Many modern homoeopaths do not
understand how to use the miasm theory
in a practical manner. Without this knowledge the homoeopath is
practicing in the same manner as Hahnemann did in the early period (1805-1816).
It was through the miasm theory that the principles of constitution, heredity,
susceptibility, infection, suppression, primary, latent and secondary states,
layers and obstacles to the cure were developed. Knowledge in these areas is
essential to being a full homoeopathician.
The Antipsoric Medicines
Hahnemann wished to include a repertory of the anti-miasmic remedies in
the “Chronic Diseases”. Unfortunately, he was unable to accomplish this goal.
Baron von Boenninghausen came to the aid of the Hofrath by publishing a
“Repertory of Anti-Psorics” (1832), The second edition was published in 1833
with a preface by Samuel Hahnemann. In this work the Baron introduced the
gradation of remedies in numerical values and set the standard for all future
repertories. This miasmic repertory specialized in only those chronic remedies
which were fully antipsoric, antisycotic and antisyphilitic.
This work was soon followed by Boenninghausen's, “Repertory of Medicines
Which Are Not Antipsoric” in 1835. The non miasmic repertory was composed of
remedies which were for traumas, acute diseases and disorders as well as acute
intercurrents while the miasmic repertory was for chronic degenerative
diseases. Since Hahnemann's time no one has followed up on his plan to produce
a specialized repertory for the chronic miasms. Boenninghausen then
complemented these twin repertories with “The Therapeutic Pocketbook” in 1845.
This completed the trinity of the Baron's repertories.
Of the 48 anti miasmic remedies in the “Chronic Diseases” (1828), 33 are
minerals, 13 plants, and 3 animal remedies. The “Materia Medica Pura” contained
63 remedies of which only 15 are minerals,
46 plants, and 2 animal remedies. So we can see that the mineral
remedies are at the core of the treatment of chronic miasms and their inherited
diathetic constitutions. The relationship of the minerals remedies to the
miasms and the other remedies in the three kingdoms was stressed by Hahnemann.
Vide the Chronic Diseases, the Theoretical Part, page 244.
"As a rule it was developed from their pure symptoms, that most of
the earths, alkalies and acids, as well as the neutral salts composed of them,
together with several of the metals, cannot be dispensed with in curing the
almost innumerable symptoms of Psora. The similarity in nature of the leading
antipsoric, Sulphur to Phosphorus and other combustible substances from the
vegetable and mineral kingdoms led to the use of the latter, and some animal
substances naturally followed them by analogy, in agreement with
experience."
Hahnemann was the first to study the similarity of the minerals to
miasmic states as well as their complementary relationships to the remedies of
the three kingdoms. This is witnessed in the three cardinal antipsorics,
Sulphur (mineral), Calcarea (Mollusk) and Lycopodium (Fern Ally) which are
complementaries. In the “Principles and Art of Cure by Homoeopathy” Herbert
Roberts M.D. notes the following when discussing the carbon family remedies.
"In Boenninghausen's list [of antipsorics published in 1832] we
find Am-c. Bar-c. Calc. Carb-a. Carb-v. Graph. Kali-c. Mag-c. Nat-c. Sep. all
these have the characteristic carbon influence, even though associated with
another element. It may seem strange to the casual student of materia medica to
include Sepia in this list, but to the homoeopathician Sepia is the animal carbon."
The Founder mentioned the importance of 'analogy' and 'experience' in
studying the relationships of remedies of the three kingdoms. The relationship
of the carbons to Sepia is one such observation.
If homoeopaths work by analogy and experience the relationships within
homogenous families and the greater materia medica can be uncovered. This is
how the range of the provings is expanded and
new potential symptoms and clinical applications may be discovered.
Roberts points out that of the 33 minerals on the antipsoric list 30 are
within the atomic weights of the elements contained in the human organism. The
nutritional remedies act predominantly on the psoric and pseudo-psora TB miasm.
The only remedies in the anti psoric list that have an atomic weight heavier
then the body's constituents are Baryta, Platinum and Aurum. These remedies
have proven themselves to be more commonly used for the effects of the venereal
miasms with or without psora.
Hahnemann set the standard for the anti-venereal powers of the heavy
elements by declaring Mercury as the cardinal remedy for the syphilitic miasm.
Remedies toxic to the human body like Arg-met.
Aur-met. Cadm-met. Osm-met. Irid-met. Mercury, Nit-ac. Plat-met. Plb-met.
and Radium are known for deep destructive processes that mimic venereal
diseases as well as many chronic degenerative disorders. Nevertheless, these
trends only represent tendencies as many of the nutritional minerals have
multi-miasmic actions as do the heavier elements.
The list of psoric symptoms in the “Chronic Diseases” (1828) is the
miasm theory in a seed state. In the introduction to Hempel’s translation of
the “Organon”, Hering confirms that Hahnemann introduced a new miasm called
pseudo-psora. The Founder divided the venereal diseases into sycosis and
syphilis early in his career. Later he also separated the symptoms of psora
from those of pseudopsora. In the first symptoms list in the “Chronic Diseases”
(1828) Hahnemann unknowingly mixed the symptoms of Psora with the TB miasma,
Pseudopsora. The Hofrath also included a few sycotic symptoms in the psora
list.
As H. gained experience he noticed that he was observing two distinct
non venereal miasms and began to reclassify their symptoms. He shared this
information with Hering who was in America at the time. The Founder also told
Boenninghausen that he was doing a detailed study of sycosis and would share
his new symptoms list when finished. Unfortunately, Hahnemann was unable to
finish this work before he left for his Heavenly Abode in 1843. We have yet to
uncover his original miasmic notes although they may still exist.
The following therapeutic hints are offered as a commentary on the
materia medica. The mineral family symptoms included are those observed by the
author in the clinic and confirmed in materia medica studies. The brackets ( )
contain examples of mineral families or remedies known for the symptoms
mentioned. I have not proposed any radical new concepts nor tried to develop
the themes beyond my practical experience. There are, however, many interesting
analogies and correspondences to be drawn between the mineral characteristics
and the symptoms of the materia medica. Such insights often add greater
understanding but they should not replace provings and clinical confirmations.
Perhaps as our knowledge of the mineral world expands we can comment on this
subject.
Therapeutic Hints
The minerals have a deep action on the metabolism and organic structures
of the human organism. The elemental remedies have the potential to produce
every disease known to the orthodox pathologist but each in their own
characteristic way. For this reason the homoeopath studies each elemental
family and their known relationships. In this quest we are assisted by the
periodic table
of the elements and knowledge of chemistry.
Minerals and Constitutions
Many mineral remedies are similar to well known constitutional types.
James Kent once remarked on how a homoeopath begins to recognize certain
constitutional remedies by observation of their mind/body make up. This
collection of essential constitutional signs is then confirmed by the
characteristic symptoms.
"A great deal is
presented that can be seen by looking at the patient, so we say this looks like
a Nat Mur. patient. Experienced physicians learn to classify patients by the
appearance."
The physical constitution and mental temperament of many polychrest
minerals (Nat-m. Calc. Ferr-met. Phos. Ars.) have well recorded constitutional
portraits. With experience the homoeopath
recognizes many such objective signs on first sight. Each mineral type
is predisposed toward certain diathetic constitutions and psychological traits.
The mineral remedies also have a close relationship
to the Hippocratic natural temperaments and the Mappa Mundi. Nit-ac.
suited to the yellowish, brown, thin, dry, irritable, choleric temperaments
that are angered easily and hold grudges. Calc. suited
to the white, cold, sweaty, slow, flabby, leucophlegmatic temperament.
Ferrum is suited to the reddish, pseudo plethoric sanguine temperament that
appears vital but underneath is pale, restless, and weak. Ars. suited to the
blue-black, nervous, fastidious, nervous melancholic temperament. There are
many more remedies, symptoms and temperaments but this should offer the reader
the basic idea.
Minerals and Miasms
The minerals have a deep action on the rational spirit, intellect,
intelligence, and memory (Geist). They are known for gradual onsets, long
progressive actions, and deep pathologies. The minerals known for their
multi-miasmic and the ability to treat several layers without changes of
remedies. The nutritional mineral remedies have slow onsets, the heavy elements
are insidious and more progressive, and the poisons violent and destructive.
The heavier the atomic weight the more rapidly destructive the element is on
the intellect and intelligence. The nutritional minerals tend to treat psora
and the pseudo psora while the heavier metals are useful in removing the
venereal miasms. These categories, however, are not exclusive titles as the
minerals have multi miasmic powers.
The mineral remedies affect the organic structures of the human organism
corroding the neuro-endocrine system, organs, tissues and fluids. The mineral
complexion is discolored with various hues
(yellow, white, red, blue, brown, gray, etc.) showing deep seated
dyscrasias leading to cachexia (a mixture of sickly colors showing multi
miasmic pathology). The plants cause similar colors but are acute and brighter
in hue while the animal remedies reflect violent colors related to animal
poisons, toxins and venoms. The minerals corrupt the spirit, emotional
disposition, brain, nerves, organs, glands, blood, nutrition, digestion,
tissues, fluids and bones in a chronically progressive manner. The pains of the
minerals are miasmic, deep, progressive and increase over time until they
become unbearable. The psoric and pseudo-psoric remedies tend to be < in the
day while the venereal remedies are < at night.
Slow Decline in Spirit, Intellect and Intelligence
The minerals have a great power on the rational spirit, intellect and
intelligence (Geist). Their concentration progressively becomes more difficult,
their memory declines, and they feel dullness with prostration of mind (Argentums,
Ammoniums, Aurums, Barytas, Calcareas, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums, Phosphates,
Platina, Silicas, Zinc, etc.). The minerals often begin with much activity but
they end in exhaustion (Acids, Alumina, Arsenicum, Aurum, Ferrum, Murates,
Nitrates, Phosphates, and the Sulphates). When the minerals become aware of
their slow decline they try to hide it from others by trying harder to prove
themselves. This usually ends in total exhaustion and failure, and in some
cases, a decline into imbecility (Acids, Argentums, Arsenicum, Bartyas,
Calcareas, Carbons, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums, Phosphates, Silicas, and
Sulphates).
Need for Organization and Structure - Conflict between Stability and
Freedom
The mineral temperament tends to need stability, solid bonds, good partnerships
and desires organization and structure (S Block-Natrums, Kalis, Magnesiums,
Calcareas) or they destroy organizations
and structures to prove their independence (P Block-Fluorides, Murates,
Nitrates, Iodums, Phosphates, Sulphates). The combination of the S and P block
elements makes up a good number of polychrest remedies with well known
constitutions and temperamental portraits (Calc-c, Calc-f. Calc-m, Calc-i.
Calc-p. Hep, Kali-b. Kali-p. Kali-i , Kali-s. Nat-c. Nat-m. Nat-p,
Nat-s, Mag-c. Mag-m. Mag-p.
Mag-s. etc..) Some of these remedies reflect being caught between the need for
solid bonds and independence. In the beginning they desire fulfilling
relationships and good partners, but as the disappointments mount, they become
more resentful and need to prove that they can be independent. Some wish to
have it both ways so they stay in dysfunctional relationships, although they
wish for independence, and do not make changes rapidly.
Restlessness, Driven, Exhausted
The mineral remedies deeply affect the emotional disposition (Gemuet)
with irritability and anxiety mixed with fear and tendency toward sleeplessness
with anxious dreams. The mineral
temperament is restless, experiences deep anxieties, and gradually grows
exhausted (Argentums, Arsenicums, Calcareas, Cuprums, Ferrums, Iodum, Kalis,
Mercuries, Plumbum, Silicates, Sulphates, etc.). Their anxiety < in the
evening sometimes driving them from the bed at night (Argentums, Arsenicums,
Bismuth, Carbons, Causticum, Ferrum, Magnesium, Natrums). This restlessness may
be due to emotional as well as physical pains. In the functional state their
inner drive gives them strength but as they become more neurotic it transforms
into a restless, driven, obsessive compulsive personality. This constant psychological
strain leads toward exhaustion and eventual collapse.
Repressed Emotions and Fixed Personalities
Although the mineral temperament is quite intellectual they are affected
deeply by emotions which are repressed by the rational mind only to reappear as
compensation like hardness (Ammoniums, Arsenicums, Cuprums, Kalis, Natrums,
Nitrates) or mildness (Alumina, Arsenicums, Aurum, Borax, Calcareas, Kalis,
Natrums, Nitrates, Phosphates, Platina, Plumbum, Silica, Stannum, Sulphur,
Zinc). The minerals are restless and driven and find it difficult to adapt
psychologically to new circumstances or make personal changes. The presence of
their shadowy emotions is apparent to others but they think they are still in
control of the situation. If this control is lost they may become destructive
and violent (Ammoniums, Aurums, Calcareas, Carbons, Iodum, Kalis, Natrums,
Nitrates, Platina, Sulphates, Zinc, etc.).
Need for Recognition, Respect and Appreciation
The minerals like to be seen as prominent members of their peer group or
family (Argentums, Arsenicums, Ferrum, Kalis, Paladium, Platina, Sulphates)
although they have a difficult time in the office (Graphites, Mercuries,
Natrums, Nitrates, Sulphates) and the home (Arsenicums, Calcareas, Kalis,
Nitrates). If they do not acquire their goals in life they suffer as they wish
to be looked up to by others (precious metals-Argentums, Aurum, Palladium,
Platina) and can be very ego centered (Aurums, Causticum, Ferrum, Palladium,
Platina, Silicates, Sulphates). A mineral temperament is confident when
healthy, offended when criticized, resentful when hurt, and destructive when
unforgiving.
Trouble Resolving Conflicts and Feeling Safe
The mineral temperament has a long memory for those with whom they find
fault and have trouble forgiving and forgetting past offenses (Acids,
Ammoniums, Aurums, Calcareas, Manganese, Natrums, Nitrates,). If they do not
get what they think is right they feel betrayed and have a hard time resolving
conflicts. They worry and fear misfortune especially when they think their
security is threatened and become paranoid (D Block-transition elements,
Manganese, Ferrum, Cobalt, Nickel, Cuprum, Zinc, Paladium, Platina, Argentum,
Aurum, Mercury, etc..). The mineral temperament has delusions that criminals,
suspect individuals, and bad people are about (Alumina, Ammoniums, Carbons,
Causticum, Ferrums, Mercuries, Natrums, Nitrates, Silicates, Strontium, and
Sulphates). They may project their fear and aversions on to certain persons,
the opposite or same sex, or different ethnic groups and religions.
Discontented and Dissatisfied with Self and Others
The minerals become deeply discontented, displeased and dissatisfied if
they perceive themselves as failures, disrespected, or miss attaining their
goals. (Ammoniums, Antimonies, Calcareas, Cuprum, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums,
Palladium, Platina, Silica, Stannum, Sulphates). They tend to dominate domestic
affairs which is carried out by either control (Arsenicum, Ferrums, Kalis, and
Natrums) or being over liberal with themselves (Fluorides, Phosphorus,
Nitrates, and Sulphates). They are prone to holding others to their own
standards and tend to be critical in their opinions (Alumina, Ammoniums,
Arsenicum, Aurum, Bartyas, Bromium, Calcareas, Graphites, Kalis, Mercuries, Phosphates,
Platina, and Sulphates). If they can't control their environment they become
irritable, morose, cross, fretful, ill humor, peevish and quarrelsome causing
them to scold and lecture.
Withdrawal and Abandonment
If the minerals do not get their way they have a tendency not to talk
about the situation and would rather be alone (Acids, Bartyas, Carbons,
Ferrums, Magnesiums, Natrums, Palladium, Phosphates, Selenium, Stannum,
Sulphates). If they do not get what they desire they have delusions of being deserted,
betrayed, abandoned, and forsaken (Argentums, Aurum, Carbons, Barytas, Kalis,
Magnesiums, Natrums, Platina). The mineral temperament has a tendency to
withdrawal into their own 'element'. They will fill their time with work or
distractions to stay away from those they consider a problem especially their
family (Ammoniums, Aurums, Calcareas, Fluoric Acid, Iodums, Kalis, Mercuries,
Natrums, Phosphates, Platina, Plumbum). They have aversions to certain persons
they have never seen or those who have offended them in the past. (Ammoniums,
Aurum, Calcarea, Causticum, Natrums, Nitrates, Selenium, Stannum). The constant
decline of the spirit and emotional disposition coincides with withdrawal from
reality and the abandonment of all healthy relationships. Their ultimate
withdrawal is suicide and the abandonment of life itself.
The Stages of Life
1st The minerals have a great effect on babies, youths and
adolescents (times of great growth) as well as the middle age when the miasms
begin to become more pathological. They must be used carefully during old age
due to their deep actions and potential for unproductive aggravations. When the
individual is in a functional state, the mineral temperaments provide support
to others, and are stable personalities in the community and home. They have
brilliant intellects and strong emotions and are often leaders among their
peers. They work hard yet know how to enjoy themselves and are often
successful. They have pride in their accomplishments and wish to be appreciated
by people.
2nd When the mineral
temperament is placed under continual strain they become more controlled,
resistive to changes, and have trouble adapting to stress. The second stage is
full of struggle, strife, and contradictions as they fight to regain their former
identity. The more they attempt to control their circumstances, the more they
become anxious, frustrated and angry. As they become less successful in
enforcing control their outbursts become more violent.
3rd when the mineral temperament realizes that their
intellect is degenerating causing loss of emotional control. This makes them
feel less confident and more fearful, paranoid and depressed. This leads toward
dark forebodings, feelings of failure, loss, gloom and melancholia (Alumina,
Arsenicums, Ammoniums, Bromium, Calcareas, Carbons, Ferrums, Iridium, Kalis,
Manganese, Mercuries, Murates, Natrums, Nitrates, Platina, Plumbum, Selenium,
Stannums, Sulphates, and Zincs).
4th the exhaustion, melancholia and delusions make them feel doomed
(Arsenicum, Aurum, Kalis, Natrums, Platina, Sulphates). As their intellect
continues to decline they feel they are losing their hold
on life which makes them think of suicide (Alumina, Antimonies, Aurums,
Calcareas, Mercuries, Natrums, Sulphates, Zinc). When they lose control of
their repressed subconscious material they may become truly insane (Antimonies,
Arsenicums, Aurums, Bartyas, Calcareas, Cuprums, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums,
Phosphates, Platina, Sulphates, etc.).
The decline of the intellect (Geist) and the emotional disposition
(Gemuet) are progressive and slowly increasing undermining the very organic
structure of the brain and psyche. Hahnemann noted the difference between a
miasmic mental illness and a psychological disorder in the Organon. A miasmic
mental illness becomes < psychological treatment while the emotional
disorders > emotional treatment. Severe crisis must be treated with acute
intercurrents until ameliorated and then followed by remedies for the fundamental
causes associated with the chronic miasms.
The above represent some of the main symptoms I have noticed running
through a great number of cases for which the mineral remedies were suited. Due
to their essential role in building organic tissue, the mineral remedies are
closely related to inherited constitutions, temperaments, miasms, and
predispositions. They are useful in deeply complex miasmic diseases confounded
by suppression and drug toxicity. The relationship of the minerals to
complementary remedies within the plant, mineral and animal kingdoms is an
essential study. The homoeopath often finds that a family of homogeneous
remedies suits most of the circumstance and symptoms which arise during the
course of treating a long lasting chronic disease. This includes the acute
intercurrents, the anti-miasmic genus remedies, the chronic intercurrents, and
the constitutional remedies found among the three kingdoms. The homoeopathician
must learn when and how to apply all these remedies.
Part 2
[David Little] 1996-2007, all rights reserved.
The Remedies of the Mineral World
Since the earliest days of homoeopathy the relationships of remedies has
been investigated very closely. These relationships include homogenous remedies
of the same family as well as complementary relationships to other minerals,
plants and animals. In order to carry out this research the homoeopath begins
by studying the nature of the three kingdoms and their remedies. The minerals
are the foundation of the structure of the earth and all organic living things
on Gaia. For this reason the mineral constituents inherent in a plant or animal
remedy deeply affect the nature of the provings and clinical confirmations.
Farrington confirms this in his description of the animal remedies.
"Medicines derived from
the animal kingdom act energetically and rapidly. They vary in intensity from
the fatal snakebite to coral, sponges, etc. which are more or less modified by
their mineral constituents".*
*Comparative Materia Medica,
in Lachesis and other Allied Remedies, starting page 317.
The animal remedies in general are energetic and rapid in their actions.
The most violent are the animal poison remedies taken from the Opidians. On the
opposite end of the spectrum there is the animal remedy, Calc. which is usually
listed with the mineral remedies. This remedy is known for its deep slow action
and its cold, torpid, slow functions and stagnations rather than energy or
violence which is represented by its acute complementary, Bell. a member of Solanaceae
family. A snake moves quickly across the land while an oyster stays in the same
place on the bottom of the sea. The high calcium content in the oyster shell is
the responsible for the mineral symptoms observed in this mollusk.
Nevertheless, one can not completely understand the nature of Calc. unless one
studies the animal's marine habitat and life cycles.
The first homoeopathic materia medica was Hahnemann's Materia Medica
Pura, which appeared in six parts from 1811 to 1821. This grand work was based
on the provings of the First Provers Union that formed around Hahnemann in
Leipsic. The 'Pura' contains 63 remedies which can be subdivided into 15
minerals, 46 plants, and 2 animal remedies. Even during these early years the
Founder was studying the nature of what he called 'miasmic animalcule' and
their relationships to acute and chronic diseases.
Hahnemann experienced great success in the treatment of acute diseases,
but as early as 1816 he noticed the general constitutional health of his
patients was slowly declining regardless of his treatment. Of these chronic
cases he lamented "their beginning was promising, the continuation less
favorable, the outcome hopeless." As the Founder pondered the nature of
this continual deterioration, he began to search for the underlying cause of
these chronic maladies. For 12 years Hahnemann quietly investigated the nature
of the chronic diseases that were resisting his homoeopathic treatment.
The Chronic Diseases
The outcome of Hahnemann's research was published in 1828 in the first
edition of The Chronic Diseases, their Peculiar Nature and their Homeopathic
Cure. This work made public for the first time Hahnemann's doctrine of the
Psora and the chronic miasms as well as the anti miasmic remedies. The miasm
theory was then integrated into the 4th edition of Organon in 1829 which is the
philosophical counterpart of the 1st Chronic Diseases. These publications led
to the first major schism in the homeopathic school. With the introduction of
the Psora theory and the 30c potency, Hahnemann went too far for some of his
more conservative followers. They were more secure with the homoeopathy that
Hahnemann taught in his early years and could not adapt to the new territory
into which it was expanding.
As Hahnemann investigated these degenerative disorders he found that
certain remedies covered the complete syndrome underlying chronic disease
whereas others were only suitable for various injuries, traumas, crises, acute
diseases and miasms, and the acute-acerbations of a chronic miasms. This led to
the classification of homeopathic remedies into the two grand categories,
psoric or anti miasmic remedies, and the apsoric or non miasmic medicines. In
the Chronic Disease Hahnemann introduced his new miasmic remedies because they
had potential to remove the fundamental causes of chronic diseases rather then
treating one or another of its symptom complexes.
A deep understanding of the pathology and symptoms of the miasms is
necessary to apply Hahnemann's advanced methods. Many modern homoeopaths do not
understand how to use the miasm theory in a practical manner. Without this
knowledge the homoeopath is practicing in the same manner as Hahnemann did in
the early period (1805-1816). It was through the miasm theory that the
principles of constitution, heredity, susceptibility, infection, suppression,
primary, latent and secondary states, layers and obstacles to the cure were
developed. Knowledge in these areas is essential to being a full
homoeopathician.
The Antipsoric Medicines
Hahnemann wished to include a repertory of the anti-miasmic remedies in
the Chronic Diseases. Unfortunately, he was unable to accomplish this goal.
Baron von Boenninghausen came to the aid of H. by publishing a “Repertory of
Anti-Psorics” (1832), The second edition was published in 1833 with a preface
by Samuel Hahnemann. In this work the Baron introduced the gradation of
remedies in numerical values and set the standard for all future repertories.
This miasmic repertory specialized in only those chronic remedies which were
fully antipsoric, antisycotic and antisyphilitic.
This work was soon followed by Boenninghausen's, “Repertory of Medicines
Which Are Not Antipsoric” in 1835. The non miasmic repertory was composed of
remedies which were for traumas, acute diseases and disorders as well as acute
intercurrents while the miasmic repertory was for chronic degenerative
diseases. Since Hahnemann's time no one has followed up on his plan to produce
a specialized repertory for the chronic miasms. Boenninghausen then complemented
these twin repertories with “The Therapeutic Pocketbook” in 1845. This
completed the trinity of the Baron's repertories.
Of the 48 anti miasmic remedies in the Chronic Diseases (1828), 33 are
minerals, 13 plants, and 3 animal remedies. The Materia Medica Pura contained
63 remedies of which only 15 are minerals, 46 plants, and 2 animal remedies. So
we can see that the mineral remedies are at the core of the treatment of
chronic miasms and their inherited diathetic constitutions. The relationship of
the minerals remedies to the miasms and the other remedies in the three
kingdoms was stressed by Hahnemann. Vide the Chronic Diseases, the Theoretical
Part, page 244.
"As a rule it was
developed from their pure symptoms, that most of the earths, alkalies and
acids, as well as the neutral salts composed of them, together with several of
the metals, cannot be dispensed with in curing the almost innumerable symptoms
of Psora. The similarity in nature of the leading antipsoric, Sulphur to
Phosphorus and other combustible substances from the vegetable and mineral
kingdoms led to the use of the latter, and some animal substances naturally
followed them by analogy, in agreement with experience."
Hahnemann was the first to study the similarity of the minerals to miasmic
states as well as their complementary relationships to the remedies of the
three kingdoms. This is witnessed in the three cardinal antipsorics, Sulphur
(mineral), Calcarea (Mollusk) and Lycopodium (Fern Ally) which are
complementaries. In the Principles and Art of Cure by Homoeopathy Herbert
Roberts M.D. notes the following when discussing the carbon family remedies.
"In Boenninghausen's list
[of antipsorics published in 1832] we find Am-c. Bar-c. Calc. Carb-a. Carb-v.
Graph. Kali-c. Mag-c. Nat-c. Sep.; all these have the characteristic carbon
influence, even though associated with another element. It may seem strange to
the casual student of materia medica to include Sepia in this list, but to the
homoeopathician Sepia is the animal carbon."
H. mentioned the importance of 'analogy' and 'experience' in studying
the relationships of remedies of the three kingdoms. The relationship of the
carbons to Sepia is one such observation. If homoeopaths work by analogy and
experience the relationships within homogenous families and the greater materia
medica can be uncovered. This is how the range of the provings is expanded and
new potential symptoms and clinical applications may be discovered.
Roberts points out that of the 33 minerals on the antipsoric list 30 are
within the atomic weights of the elements contained in the human organism. The
nutritional remedies act predominantly on the psoric and pseudo-psora TB miasm.
The only remedies in the anti psoric list that have an atomic weight heavier
then the body's constituents are Baryta, Platinum and Aurum. These remedies
have proven themselves to be more commonly used for the effects of the venereal
miasms with or without psora.
Hahnemann set the standard for the anti-venereal powers of the heavy elements
by declaring Mercury as the cardinal remedy for the syphilitic miasm. Remedies
toxic to the human body like Argentum, Aurum, Cadmium, Osmium, Iridium,
Mercury, Nitric Acid, Platina,, Plumbum, and Radium are known for deep
destructive processes that mimic venereal diseases as well as many chronic
degenerative disorders. Nevertheless, these trends only represent tendencies as
many of the nutritional minerals have multi-miasmic actions as do the heavier
elements.
The list of psoric symptoms in the Chronic Diseases (1828) is the miasm
theory in a seed state. In the introduction to Hempel’s translation of the
Organon, Hering confirms that Hahnemann introduced a new miasm called
pseudo-psora. The Founder divided the venereal diseases into sycosis and syphilis
early in his career. Later he also separated the symptoms of psora from those
of pseudopsora. In the first symptoms list in the Chronic Diseases (1828)
Hahnemann unknowingly mixed the symptoms of Psora with the TB miasma,
Pseudopsora. The Hofrath also included a few sycotic symptoms in the psora
list.
As H. gained experience he noticed that he was observing two distinct
non venereal miasms and began to reclassify their symptoms. He shared this
information with Hering who was in America
at the time. The Founder also told Boenninghausen that he was doing a
detailed study of sycosis and would share his new symptoms list when finished.
Unfortunately, Hahnemann was unable
to finish this work before he left for his Heavenly Abode in 1843. We
have yet to uncover his original miasmic notes although they may still exist.
The following therapeutic hints are offered as a commentary on the
materia medica. The mineral family symptoms included are those observed by the
author in the clinic and confirmed in materia medica studies. The brackets ( )
contain examples of mineral families or remedies known for the symptoms
mentioned. I have not proposed any radical new concepts nor tried to develop
the themes beyond my practical experience. There are, however, many interesting
analogies and correspondences to be drawn between the mineral characteristics
and the symptoms of the materia medica.
Such insights often add greater understanding but they should not
replace provings and clinical confirmations. Perhaps as our knowledge of the
mineral world expands we can comment on this subject.
Therapeutic Hints
The minerals have a deep action on the metabolism and organic structures
of the human organism. The elemental remedies have the potential to produce
every disease known to the orthodox pathologist but each in their own
characteristic way. For this reason the homoeopath studies each elemental
family and their known relationships. In this quest we are assisted by the
periodic table of the elements and knowledge of chemistry.
Minerals and Constitutions
Many mineral remedies are similar to well known constitutional types.
James Kent once remarked on how a homoeopath begins to recognize certain
constitutional remedies by observation of their mind/body make up. This
collection of essential constitutional signs is then confirmed by the
characteristic symptoms.
"A great deal is
presented that can be seen by looking at the patient, so we say this looks like
a Nat Mur. patient. Experienced physicians learn to classify patients by the
appearance."
The physical constitution and mental temperament of many polychrest
minerals (Nat-m. Calc. Ferr-met. Phos. Ars. etc.) have well recorded
constitutional portraits. With experience the homoeopath recognizes many such
objective signs on first sight. Each mineral type is predisposed toward certain
diathetic constitutions and psychological traits. The mineral remedies also
have a close relationship to the Hippocratic natural temperaments and the Mappa
Mundi. Nit-ac. suited to the yellowish, brown, thin, dry, irritable, choleric
temperaments that are angered easily and hold grudges. Calc. suited to the
white, cold, sweaty, slow, flabby, leucophlegmatic temperament. Ferr-met.
suited to the reddish, pseudo plethoric sanguine temperament that appears vital
but underneath is pale, restless, and weak. Ars. suited to the blue-black,
nervous, fastidious, nervous melancholic temperament. There are many more
remedies, symptoms and temperaments but this should offer the reader the basic
idea.
Minerals and Miasms
The minerals have a deep action on the rational spirit, intellect,
intelligence, and memory (Geist). They are known for gradual onsets, long
progressive actions, and deep pathologies. The minerals are
known for their multi-miasmic and the ability to treat several layers
without changes of remedies. The nutritional mineral remedies have slow onsets,
the heavy elements are insidious and more progressive, and the poisons are
violent and destructive. The heavier the atomic weight the more rapidly destructive
the element is on the intellect and intelligence. The nutritional minerals tend
to treat psora and the pseudo psora while the heavier metals are useful in
removing the venereal miasms. These categories, however, are not exclusive
titles as the minerals have multi miasmic powers.
The mineral remedies affect the organic structures of the human organism
corroding the neuro-endocrine system, organs, tissues and fluids. The mineral
complexion is discolored with various hues
(yellow, white, red, blue, brown, gray, etc.) showing deep seated
dyscrasias leading to cachexia (a mixture of sickly colors showing multi
miasmic pathology). The plants cause similar colors but are acute and brighter
in hue while the animal remedies reflect violent colors related to animal
poisons, toxins and venoms. The minerals corrupt the spirit, emotional
disposition, brain, nerves, organs, glands, blood, nutrition, digestion,
tissues, fluids and bones in a chronically progressive manner. The pains of the
minerals are miasmic, deep, progressive and increase over time until they
become unbearable. The psoric and pseudo-psoric remedies tend to be worse <
in the day while the venereal remedies are worse < at night.
Slow Decline in Spirit, Intellect and Intelligence
The minerals have a great power on the rational spirit, intellect and
intelligence (Geist). Their concentration progressively becomes more difficult,
their memory declines, and they feel dullness with prostration of mind
(Argentums, Ammoniums, Aurums, Bartyas, Calcareas, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums,
Phosphates, Platina, Silicas, Zinc, etc.). The minerals often begin with much
activity but they end in exhaustion (Acids, Alum. Ars. Aur-met. Ferr-met.
Murates, Nitrates, Phosphates, and the Sulphates). When the minerals become aware
of their slow decline they try to hide it from others by trying harder to prove
themselves. This usually ends in total exhaustion and failure, and in some
cases, a decline into imbecility (Acids, Argentums, Arsenicum, Bartyas,
Calcareas, Carbons, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums, Phosphates, Silicas, and
Sulphates).
Need for Organization and Structure - Conflict between Stability and
Freedom
The mineral temperament tends to need stability, solid bonds, good partnerships
and desires organization and structure (S Block-Natrums, Kalis, Magnesiums,
Calcareas) or they destroy organizations and structures to prove their
independence (P Block- Fluorides, Murates, Nitrates, Iodums, Phosphates,
Sulphates). The combination of the S and P block elements makes up a good
number of polychrest remedies with well known constitutions and temperamental
portraits (Calc. Calc-f. Calc-m. Calc-i. Calc-p. Hep. Kali-b. Kali-p.
Kali-i. Kali-s. Nat-c. Nat-m. Nat-p. Nat-s. Mag-c. Mag-m. Mag-p. Mag-s.) Some of these remedies
reflect being caught between the need for solid bonds and independence. In the
beginning they desire fulfilling relationships and good partners, but as the
disappointments mount, they become more resentful and need to prove that they
can be independent. Some wish to have it both ways so they stay in
dysfunctional relationships, although they wish for independence, and do not
make changes rapidly.
Restlessness, Driven, Exhausted
The mineral remedies deeply affect the emotional disposition (Gemuet)
with irritability and anxiety mixed with fear and tendency toward sleeplessness
with anxious dreams. The mineral temperament is restless, experiences deep
anxieties, and gradually grows exhausted (Argentums, Arsenicums, Calcareas,
Cuprums, Ferrums, Iodum, Kalis, Mercuries, Plumbum, Silicates, Sulphates,
etc.).
Their anxiety is < in the evening sometimes driving them from the bed
at night (Argentums, Arsenicums, Bismuth, Carbons, Causticum, Ferrum,
Magnesium, Natrums). This restlessness may be
due to emotional as well as physical pains. In the functional state
their inner drive gives them strength but as they become more neurotic it
transforms into a restless, driven, obsessive compulsive personality. This
constant psychological strain leads toward exhaustion and eventual collapse.
Repressed Emotions and Fixed Personalities
Although the mineral temperament is quite intellectual they are affected
deeply by emotions which are repressed by the rational mind only to reappear as
compensation like hardness (Ammoniums, Arsenicums, Cuprums, Kalis, Natrums,
Nitrates) or mildness (Alumina, Arsenicums, Aurum, Borax, Calcareas, Kalis,
Natrums, Nitrates, Phosphates, Platina, Plumbum, Silica, Stannum, Sulphur,
Zinc). The minerals are restless and driven and find it difficult to adapt
psychologically to new circumstances or make personal changes. The presence of
their shadowy emotions is apparent to others but they think they are still in
control of the situation. If this control is lost they may become destructive
and violent (Ammoniums, Aurums, Calcareas, Carbons, Iodum, Kalis, Natrums,
Nitrates, Platina, Sulphates, Zinc, etc.).
Need for Recognition, Respect and Appreciation
The minerals like to be seen as prominent members of their peer group or
family (Argentums, Arsenicums, Ferrum, Kalis, Paladium, Platina, Sulphates)
although they have a difficult time in the office (Graphites, Mercuries,
Natrums, Nitrates, Sulphates) and the home (Arsenicums, Calcareas, Kalis,
Nitrates). If they do not acquire their goals in life they suffer as they wish
to be looked up to by others (precious metals-Argentums, Aurum, Palladium,
Platina) and can be very ego centered (Aurums, Causticum, Ferrum, Palladium,
Platina, Silicates, Sulphates). A mineral temperament is confident when
healthy, offended when criticized, resentful when hurt, and destructive when
unforgiving.
Trouble Resolving Conflicts and Feeling Safe
The mineral temperament has a long memory for those with whom they find
fault and have trouble forgiving and forgetting past offenses (Acids,
Ammoniums, Aurums, Calcareas, Manganese, Natrums, Nitrates,). If they do not
get what they think is right they feel betrayed and have a hard time resolving
conflicts. They worry and fear misfortune especially when they think their
security is threatened and become paranoid (D Block-transition elements,
Manganese, Ferrum, Cobalt, Nickel, Cuprum, Zinc, Paladium, Platina, Argentum,
Aurum, Mercury, etc..). The mineral temperament has delusions that criminals,
suspect individuals, and bad people are about (Alumina, Ammoniums, Carbons,
Causticum, Ferrums, Mercuries, Natrums, Nitrates, Silicates, Strontium, and
Sulphates). They may project their fear and aversions on to certain persons,
the opposite or same sex, or different ethnic groups and religions.
Discontented and Dissatisfied with Self and Others
The minerals become deeply discontented, displeased and dissatisfied if
they perceive themselves as failures, disrespected, or miss attaining their
goals. (Ammoniums, Antimonies, Calcareas, Cuprum, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums,
Palladium, Platina, Silica, Stannum, Sulphates). They tend to dominate domestic
affairs which is carried out by either control (Arsenicum, Ferrums, Kalis, and
Natrums) or being over liberal with themselves (Fluorides, Phosphorus,
Nitrates, and Sulphates). They are prone to holding others to their own
standards and tend to be critical in their opinions (Alumina, Ammoniums,
Arsenicum, Aurum, Bartyas, Bromium, Calcareas, Graphites, Kalis, Mercuries,
Phosphates, Platina, and Sulphates). If they can't control their environment
they become irritable, morose, cross, fretful, ill humor, peevish and
quarrelsome causing them to scold and lecture.
Withdrawal and Abandonment
If the minerals do not get their way they have a tendency not to talk
about the situation and would rather be alone (Acids, Bartyas, Carbons,
Ferrums, Magnesiums, Natrums, Palladium, Phosphates, Selenium, Stannum,
Sulphates). If they do not get what they desire they have delusions of being
deserted, betrayed, abandoned, and forsaken (Argentums, Aurum, Carbons,
Bartiums, Kaliums, Magnesiums, Natriums, Platina). The mineral temperament has
a tendency to withdrawal into their own 'element'. They will fill their time
with work or distractions to stay away from those they consider a problem
especially their family (Ammoniums, Aurums, Calciums, Fluoric acid, Iodums,
Kaliums, Mercuries, Natriums, Phosphates, Platina, Plumbum). They have
aversions to certain persons they have never seen or those who have offended
them in the past. (Ammoniums, Aurum, Calcarea, Causticum, Natrums, Nitrates,
Selenium, Stannum). The constant decline of the spirit and emotional
disposition coincides with withdrawal from reality and the abandonment of all
healthy relationships. Their ultimate withdrawal is suicide and the abandonment
of life itself.
The Stages of Life
The minerals have a great effect on babies, youths and adolescents
(times of great growth) as well as the middle age when the miasms begin to
become more pathological. They must be used carefully during old age due to
their deep actions and potential for unproductive aggravations. When the
individual is in a functional state, the mineral temperaments provide support
to others, and are stable personalities in the community and home. They have
brilliant intellects and strong emotions and are often leaders among their
peers. They work hard yet know how to enjoy themselves and are often
successful. They have pride in their accomplishments and wish to be appreciated
by people.
1st When the mineral temperament is placed under continual
strain they become more controlled, resistive to changes, and have trouble
adapting to stress.
2nd full of struggle, strife, and contradictions as they
fight to regain their former identity. The more they attempt to control their
circumstances, the more they become anxious, frustrated and angry.
As they become less successful in enforcing control their outbursts
become more violent..
3rd begins when the mineral temperament realizes that their intellect
is degenerating causing loss of emotional control. This makes them feel less
confident and more fearful, paranoid and depressed.
This leads toward dark forebodings, feelings of failure, loss, gloom and
melancholia (Alumina, Arsenicums, Ammoniums, Bromium, Calcareas, Carbons,
Ferrums, Iridium, Kalis, Manganese, Mercuries, Murates, Natrums, Nitrates,
Platina, Plumbum, Selenium, Stannums, Sulphates, and Zincs).
4th proceeds the exhaustion, melancholia and delusions make
them feel doomed (Arsenicum, Aurum, Kalis, Natrums, Platina, Sulphates). As
their intellect continues to decline they feel they are losing their hold on
life which makes them think of suicide (Alumina, Antimonies, Aurums, Calcareas,
Mercuries, Natrums, Sulphates, Zinc). When they lose control of their repressed
subconscious material they may become truly insane (Antimonies, Arsenicums,
Aurums, Bartyas, Calcareas, Cuprums, Kalis, Mercuries, Natrums, Phosphates,
Platina, Sulphates, etc.).
The decline of the intellect (Geist) and the emotional disposition
(Gemuet) are progressive and slowly increasing undermining the very organic
structure of the brain and psyche. Hahnemann noted the difference between a
miasmic mental illness and a psychological disorder in the Organon. A miasmic
mental illness becomes worse < by psychological treatment while the
emotional disorders are ameliorated (¤ 224). Severe crisis must be treated with
acute intercurrents until ameliorated and then followed by remedies for the
fundamental causes associated with the chronic miasms.
The above represent some of the main symptoms I have noticed running
through a great number of cases for which the mineral remedies were suited. Due
to their essential role in building organic tissue, the mineral remedies are
closely related to inherited constitutions, temperaments, miasms, and
predispositions. They are useful in deeply complex miasmic diseases confounded
by suppression and drug toxicity. The relationship of the minerals to
complementary remedies within the plant, mineral and animal kingdoms is an
essential study. The homoeopath often finds that a family of homogeneous
remedies suits most of the circumstance and symptoms which arise during the
course of treating a long lasting chronic disease. This includes the acute
intercurrents, the anti-miasmic genus remedies, the chronic intercurrents, and
the constitutional remedies found among the three kingdoms. The homoeopathician
must learn when and how to apply all these remedies.
Part 3
Part 4 will highlight the character and symptoms of the zoological
remedies.
[David Little] 1996-2007, all rights reserved.
Remedies of the Plant World
Of Hahnemann's 112 remedies 48 are clearly antimiasmic remedies while
the other 64 are apsoric (= non-miasmic in nature). Of the 28 new remedies introduced
by Hahnemann from 1828-1839 there
are 23 minerals and 5 plants. Hahnemann's mineral remedies in the
“hronic Diseases”(1828): Alum. Am-c. Am-m. Ant-c. Ars. Aur-met. Aur-m. Bar-c.
Borx. Calc. Caust. Cupr-met. Graph. Hep.
Calc-i. Kali-c. Mag-c. Mag-m. Mang-met. Mur-ac. Nat-c. Nat-m. Nit-ac. Nitricums Phos.
Ph-ac. Plat-met. Sil. Stann-met. Sulph. Sul-ac. Zinc-met.
The antipsoric plants in the “Chronic Diseases”: Agar. Anac. Carb-v.
Clem. Coloc. Con. Dig. Dulc. Euphorb. Guaj. Lyc. Mez. and Sars. Thuja is listed
as sycotic.
Animal remedies: Sep. Carb-a. and Calc.
In the beginning (1828) most of the chronic symptoms were listed as
psoric, but by 1843, the miasms were separated into four groups, psora,
pseudopsora, sycosis and syphilis. Unfortunately, Hahnemann's final notes on
the miasms have not been recovered but we know of their existence through
Hering and Boenninghausen. Since that time generations of homoeopaths have
corrected mistakes and contributed to new knowledge of homoeopathic philosophy
and pathology.
Chronic Diseases
The mineral remedies are at the forefront of anti-miasmic and
constitutional treatment yet the plant group also contains many deep antipsoric
and constitutional remedies grouped around the multi-miasmic, Lycopodium. Vide
Clarke's Dictionary, Volume 2, on page 329.
"Lycopodium is one of the
pivotal remedies of the materia medica, and an intimate acquaintance with its
properties and relations is essential to a proper understanding of the materia
medica as a whole. The spores from which the attenuation are made have been
called "vegetable sulphur' (probably on account of their use for producing
stage-lighting at theaters)*, and Lyc. ranks with Sulph. and Calc. in the
central trio around which all the rest of the materia medica can be grouped.
Lyc. stands between the mosses and the ferns, and in past eras occupied a most
important place in the world's vegetation as fossil show".
The trio of cardinal antipsorics, Sulph. Calc. and Lyc. represent the
mineral, animal and plants worlds. All of these remedies are very primitive in
nature and have deep multi-miasmic powers. The early land plants of the
Devonian period c.395 million years ago include the Lichens (Sticta), Fern
Allies (Lyc. and Equis.), Ferns (Filix mas) and the Gymnosperms (Coniferales
-Thuja, Sabina, Pinis). Lycopodium is the pivotal remedy of the Lichens, Fern
Allies and Ferns while Thuja is the central remedy of the gymnosperms. The most
proven remedies of this primitive group have strong antisycotic powers although
Sticta is useful in TB miasma combined with arthritic diathesis. Lycopodium is
made from 'spores' while gymnosperms mean "naked seeds". Is it any
wonder that Lycopodium, Thuja and Sabina have antisycotic powers? The quadra-
miasmic powers of Lycopodium are demonstrated in the psora, sycosis,
pseudopsora and syphilitic miasms. We will study these great divisions of
plants in detail later.
The categories of acute and chronic remedies are relative in nature. For
example, Ars. is a deep chronic poisonous mineral but it can be used as an
acute intercurrent such as in a case of food poisoning. When Ars. is
administered by the fundamental causes and the 7 constitutional factors (aph.
5), as well as the totality of the symptoms (aph. 6), it acts as a
constitutional remedy. When Ars. is administered in an acute disorder by the
exciting cause, and active crisis symptoms, it acts like an acute intercurrent
(“Chronic Diseases”, Theoretical Part, page 224). This is part of the case
management strategies associated with Hahnemann's gestalt therapy. Ars. covers
both acute and chronic states depending on how it is used. The same is true of
many constitutional plants.
Some of the apsoric remedies do not have this grand sphere of influence
and are more suitable for acute conditions and crises.
The Apsoric Remedies
The title of apsoric has a special meaning in Hahnemannian Homoeopathy.
Which remedies was Hahnemann speaking of when he referred to the non-miasmic
apsoric remedies? Here is the list of apsorics in the order of the introduction
to Hahnemann's practice; Acon, Arn. Bell. Camph. Caps. Cham. Chin. Coc-i. Dros.
Hell. Hyos. Ign. Ip. Led. Nux-v. Op. Puls. Rheum, Stram. Valer. Verat. Cann-s.
Cina, Dulc. Mosch. Bry. Rhus-t. Asar. Olnd. Squil. Chel. Ruta, Samb. Spig.
Staph. Tarax. Ang. Cic-v. Coloc. Spong. Verb. Auript, Ambra, Petros. Euphorb.
Of the 45 remedies listed there are no minerals, 43 plants and 2 animal
remedies.
These remedies are called apsorics because they are not similar to all
three phases of the chronic miasms (primary, latent and secondary stages). They
only reflect one aspect or another of the chronic syndromes. Some of these
remedies have proven themselves to be anti-miasmic over the years. For example,
Ambra. Staph. Puls. and Nux-v. have proven to be constitutional remedies with
antimiasmic powers. A careful review of the apsoric list closely shows many
remedies known for acute disorders, exposures, physical and mental traumas,
crisis, acute miasms, as well as an acute-like acceleration of chronic miasms
and pathological crises. These remedies are acute crises remedies and acute
intercurrent remedies.
What is the fundamental difference between the two basic categories of
remedies in the materia medica? The answer can be found in the nature of acute and
chronic diseases and the theory of time and progression. The anti-miasmic
plants reflect the same cycles observed in the chronic mineral and animal
remedies. The apsoric acute, trauma and crisis remedies demonstrate cycles
similar to trauma, acute disorders, acute miasms and the flare up of chronic
miasms. The anti-miasmic plants (Lycopodium) have a close relationship with
minerals (Sulphur) and animal remedies that are affected strongly by their
mineral constituents (Calcarea). Another simple example of a three-kingdom
remedy family is the apsoric Ignatia (plant-Loganiaceae) which is an acute
reflex of chronic Natrum Muriaticum (sodium-mineral) which is complemented by
Sepia (Marine animal-Mollusca). This trio has been witnessed in countless
cases.
Major Plant Families and Species
The lower orders of plants like the Fungi, Fern allies and Gymnosperms
contain many deep acting anti-miasmic plants. This includes Fungi (Agar. Bov.
Sec. Ust. the Lichen Sticta, the Fern Ally Lycopodium. and Gymnosperms like Thuja
and Sabina). The families of Monocotyledons of the Angiosperm division includes
the Iridaceae (Croc. Iris). Liliaceae (Helon. Lit-t. Verat-a.). Palmaceae
(Sabal.). Araceae (Arum-t. Calad.). Gramineae (Arund. Aven-s.). the
Dioscoreaceae (Dioscorea). Zingiberaceae (Zing.). Aloaceae (Aloe). Colchicaceae
(Colch.).
The greatest numbers of remedies are found within the more recent
evolutionary families of the Dicocotyledons. Some of the most important plant
families are the Compositae (60 - Arn. Bell-p. Calen. Cham. Card-m. Tarax.
Cina. Wye). Papilionoideae (47 – Bapt. Chrysar. Indg. Lath. Meli. Phys.
Trif-p). Ranunculaceae (45 - Aco. Cimic. Clem. Hell. Hydr. Puls. Ran-b.
Staph.). Umbelliferae (34 - Aeth. Asaf. Cic. Con. Ery-a. Hydro. Peteros. Sumb..
Ziz.). Solanaceae (29 - Bell. Caps. Dat. Dulc.. Hyos. Lycops. Stram. Tab.).
Euphrobiaceae (28 - Euph. Hura. Jatr. Manc. Still.). Rubiaceae (16 - Chin.
Coff. Ip.). Rutaceae (16 - Ang. Jab. Piloc. Ptel. Ruta.). the Anacardiaceae (14
- Anac. Rhus-a. Rhus-t. Rhus-v.). Loganiaceae (13 -Gel. Ign. Nux-v. Spig.
Stry.). Lauraceae (7 - Camph. Cinnm. Sass.). Cactaceae
(6 - Anh. Cact. Cere-s. Opun-v.). Phytolaccaceae (3 -Phyt.).
Myristicaceae (3 - Myris. Nux-m.). Urticaceae (4 - Urt-u.). Many of the major
plant families revolve around the well known polychrests like satellites. If
you recognize the polychrests by families it is easier to learn the rest of the
remedies in the group. A complete list of the botanical orders and families
with remedies will be supplied throughout our course as we study the genus
families.
Therapeutic Hints
The study of the symptoms of the Plant Kingdom is a deep subject. The
apsoric plants are suitable for acute crisis and intercurrent remedies during
the disruption of the chronic treatment by strong exciting causes and crises.
The antipsoric (miasmic) plants demonstrate chronic symptoms similar to their
mineral complements, e.g. Lyc. and Sul.. Many of the plant remedies are well
known for their role in cases where the organic pathology becomes the active
layer and appears as a regional affection. The biochemical qualities of plants
differ from the inorganic minerals in that the botanical world represents
carbon-based organisms. This structure is founded on protoplasm (CHON) which
reflects the cellular organization as witnessed in the human organism. This is
why the plant remedies have special affinities with specific systems, regions,
organs, and tissue. Many so-called constitutional homoeopaths have overlooked
this essential aspect of the materia medica.
Certain plant remedies are well known for their specific actions on the
mind (intellect, emotions), physiological systems (nervous, circulation,
glandular, lymphatic), regions (head, throat, abdomen, rectum, left, right),
vital organs (heart, lungs, liver, spleen, kidneys), humours (bilious, phlegm,
blood, atrabile), tissues (skin, mucus membranes, bones), and stages of life
(children, adolescence, menopause, old age). This become more apparent as one
studies the individual plant families. For example, the Compositae family (60
remedies) includes the traumatic group (Arn. Bell-p. Calen. Mill.), the bilious
group (Cham. Card-m. Tarax.), the spasmodic and anthelmintica group (Absin.
Cina. Art-v.), and the allergenic respiratory group (Ambo. Solid. Wye.) Such
remedy relationships are an integral aspect of complete case management
strategies.
Over the years I have noticed a number of conditions, signs and symptoms
which are somewhat characteristic of the plant family. The following
therapeutic hints are somewhat indicative of the plant remedies although each
genus is modified by its own unique traits. The plant kingdom has a powerful
effect on the emotional disposition causing never ending alternations of moods,
feelings, sensations, disorders, and mistunements. The plants initially mistune
the emotional disposition (Gemuet) in the same way that the minerals target the
intellect (Geist), and the animal remedies the instinctual level (vital force).
Through the disruption of the emotional disposition the individual loses
control over the rational spirit leading to hysterical-like states.
Plants and Constitutions
The plant remedies of the materia medica reflect many clear
constitutional pictures. Hahnemann stressed the importance of the emotional
disposition and mind in case taking in the Organon (aph 5).
We know from his casebooks that he occasionally noted the Hippocratic
diathetic constitution and temperament of his clients as well. The first
complete temperamental portrait may be found in Hahnemann's lecture on
Pulsatilla in the Materia Medica Pura, page 345.
"The homeopathic
employment of this, as of all other medicines, is most suitable when not only
the corporeal affections of the medicine correspond in similarity to the
corporeal symptoms of the diseases, but also when the MENTAL AND EMOTIONAL
ALTERATIONS peculiar to the drug encounter similar states in the disease to be
cured, or at least in the TEMPERAMENT OF THE SUBJECT UNDER TREATMENT".
"Hence the medicinal
employment of Pulsatilla will be all the more efficacious when, in affections
for which this plant is suitable in respect to the corporeal symptoms, there is
at the same time IN THE PATIENT A TIMID LACHRYMOSE DISPOSITION, with a TENDENCY
TO INWARD GRIEF AND SILENT PEEVISHNESS, or at all events a MILD AND YIELDING
DISPOSITION, especially when THE PATIENT IN HIS NORMAL STATE OF HEALTH WAS GOOD
TEMPERED AND MILD (OR EVEN FRIVOLOUS AND GOOD HUMOUREDLY WAGGISH) It is
therefore ESPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR SLOW PHLEGMATIC TEMPERAMENTS; ON THE OTHER
HAND IT IS BUT LITTLE SUITABLE FOR PERSONS WHO FORM THEIR RESOLUTIONS WITH
RAPIDITY, AND ARE QUICK IN THEIR MOVEMENTS, even though they may appear to be
good tempered."
Hahnemann's constitutional portrait includes the character of the
individual in the time of health as well as disease. His temperamental picture
includes the attributes of the natural constitution (timid lachrymose
dispositions), the Hippocratic temperament (slow phlegmatic temperament),
positive natural traits (good-tempered, mild, good humouredly waggish when
healthy), and negative emotions (inward grief and peevishness). This remedy
portrait includes congenital, positive and negative natural qualities of the
person in the state of health and disease. This information is included within
the totality of the signs and symptoms. The vegetable kingdom reflects many
recognizable constitutional portraits like Bry. Cann-i. Cham. Chin. Cimic.
Coff. Croc-s. Carb-v. Cycl. Lil-t. Lyc. Hyos. Ign.
Nux-m. Nux-v. Op. Puls. Sabin. Staph. Stram. Thuj. Verat. etc.
When a plant remedy suits the innate temperament, spiritual and
emotional disposition, and the general symptoms, it will act very deeply on the
whole constitution. A pure simile between a plant remedy and a human being
results in very deep therapeutic actions. In some cases a medicine not known
for its antimiasmic powers will cure a complex disease and chronic miasms. In
other cases the plant remedy will need the assistance of chronic intercurrents
and complementary remedies from the other kingdoms. There is no absolute line
drawn between remedies that are psoric and those that are apsoric. The full
therapeutic range of a constitutional remedy can only be found by observing its
action on the individual to whom it is administered.
Plants and Miasms
Remedies such a Lycopodium and Thuja are well documented for their deep
actions against inherited and acquired miasms. Other plant remedies are better
known for their curative powers against virulent acute miasms and the primary
state of the chronic miasms. Some of the plants do not act as deeply as the
minerals and nosodes in chronic diseases but their use in overall case
management is essential. For example, It is not always wise to begin treatment
of a dangerous miasmic pathology with deep acting antipsoric plants, minerals,
animal poisons, and nosodes.
The apsoric plant remedies come into action during mental or physical
crisis. They are well known for acting on different conditions, constitutions,
regions, organs and tissues thus suiting the symptoms of pathological crises.
For example, when treating active TB miasm where the tubercles have already
formed, deep-acting psoric plants, minerals, animal remedies and nosodes are
counter indicated. The administration of deep acting remedies like Lycopodium,
Iodum, Sulphur, and Tuberculinum can be dangerous at this time. It is best to
begin with the apsoric plant remedies like Acal, All-s, Bals-p, Bry, Bapt,
Dros, Mill, Puls, Sang, Still, etc, to ameliorate the hectic fever, reduce
tubercles, and the danger of complications.
Once the organic pathology is slowly reduced, and the patient gains
vitality, the deeper acting mineral remedies and nosodes can be used to
complete the cure. Giving constitutional remedies at the wrong time may end the
suffering of the patient by dispatching them to another world. Other types of
pathological crises are similar. Cases with advanced degenerative pathology
must be treated in layers. It is here that the specific regional targets of the
plant remedies become highlighted. In general, the nutritional plants and herbs
are the most gentle, the toxic herbs are more heroic, and the poisonous plants
are violent. The ant miasmic plants may have very acute stages but they also
reflect the more insidious long-term actions shared by the mineral remedies and
nosodes.
The Plant Temperament
The plant temperament represents the struggle between rapidly changing
emotions and mental control. The strong emotions of the plant remedies tend to overcome
the intellect leading to confusion. Many plants express quick changes, deep
feelings, sensations, and alternating moods. The plants are closely related the
cycle of the day and night as well as the changing of the four seasons.
Emotional fulfillment is very important to the plant temperament as they
reflect the beauty of nature's grasses, flowers and trees. Under continual
stress the plants tend to progress toward the mineral and animal complements
which express similar symptoms. The plants are prone to crises brought on by
physical and emotional traumas that cause acute-like acerbations of the chronic
miasms and pathology. The apsoric plant families reflect sudden onsets, rapidly
changing stages, crises and complications while the psoric plants possess
insidious onsets, steady movements toward pathology and chronic degenerative
states and miasms.
Ailments from Mental and Physical Trauma
The plant temperament is very susceptible to ailments from emotions.
Ailments from anger is found in the Ranunculaceae (Acon, Puls, Ran-b. Staph.),
Papaveraceae (Chel, Op, Sang.), Menispermaceae (Cocc.), Solanaceae (Bell. Caps.
Hyos. Stram.), Loganiaceae (Gels. Ign. Nux-v. Spig.) and the bilious Compositae
(Cham. Card-m. Tarax.), The over joyous states are clearly reflected in the
Ranunculaceae, Solanaceae, Rubiaceae, Liliaceae, and Iridaceae (Croc.).
Ailments that include fear, fright and shock suit Ranunculaceae, Papaveraceae,
Solanaceae, Loganiaceae, Liliaceae, Euphorbiaceae (Manc.). Plants that often
suffer complications of physical trauma and shock are reflected in the
traumatic Compositae (Arn. Bell-p. Calen. Eur-p. Mill. Echi. etc.).
Nervous Excitement
The plant temperament is disposed to nervous excitement and is < the
slightest noise and disruption. The plants are dependent on their environment
and oversensitive to the emotions of others. This nervous excitement exacts a
great toll on their emotional disposition and moves them toward nervous
breakdown. This tendency is seen throughout many of the plant families
including the Umbelliferae (Asaf, Con. Cic-v. Sumb.), Rubiaceae, (Chin. Coff.
Ip.), Loganiaceae (Gels. Ign. Nux-v. Spig. Stry.), Ranunculaceae (Acon. Cimic.
Clem. Hell. Hydr. Puls. Ran-b. Staph.), Solanaceae (Bell. Caps. Dulc. Hyos.
Stram. Tab.) and in the Compositae (Cham. Cina) and Anacardiaceae (Anac.
Rhus-t. Rhus-v.). The Gentianflorae Order is quite characteristic of nervous
excitement as it contains both the Loganiaceae and Solanaceae families. The
plant remedies tend to make gestures that reflect their emotional excitement,
which take the form of chorea in serious cases.
Rapid Alternations and Mood Swings
The plant temperament is oversensitive to environmental changes and
prone to rapid crisis. The alternating symptoms and rapid changes in plant temperament
are seen in the Ranunculaceae, Umbelliferae, Liliaceae, Iridaceae, Loganiaceae,
Rubiaceae, Solanaceae, Valerianaceaea and Myristicaceae (Nux-m). The plant
temperament quickly alternates between cheerfulness and sadness and jesting
with anger and quick repentance. They are playful, singing and dancing at one
moment and the next melancholic or hysterical. In the rubric for hysteria with
"fainting" there are 18 plants, 2 minerals and 2 animal sources. The
plants are very "faint' remedies when compared with the minerals. They are
easily made faint by emotions and excitement so their thoughts can vanish in a
moment. The alternation of mental and physical symptoms is also characteristic
of the many plant families.
Fantasy and Disappointment
The plant temperament is prone to imaginations and fancy of an exalted
nature. This is found in Anacardiaceae, Solanaceae, Cannabinaceae, Rubiaceae,
Umbelliferae, Papaveraceae, Myristicaceae, Compositae, Loganiaceae,
Ranunculaceae, etc. This symptom runs through most of the plant families
alternating with opposite states. Many of the plant temperaments feel that this
world is a bad dream and try to remove themselves from this reality by living
in a world of fantasy. They often feel most at peace in nature surrounded by
the good earth, plants and animals. The plant family is quite amorous, sexual,
and fertile (Solanaceae, Rubiaceae, Loganiaceae, Ranunculaceae, Lycopodiacae,
etc.). They seek to have ideal relationships that most often clash with
reality. Ailments from unrequited love and grief are found among the leading
remedies of the Solanaceae, Ranunculaceae, Loganiaceae, Cucurbitacae (Bry.
Coloc.), Liliaceae (Verat. Verat-v.), etc.. Such remedies are very useful in
the acute and crisis state and may need complementary mineral or animal
remedies to complete the cure. Some plants react by having many sexual
relationships while others withdraw sexually or escape into fantasy and
masturbation. If the plant temperament can not find emotional happiness they
withdraw into a world of fantasy.
Dream-like and Dreams
The plant temperaments often feel as if they are in a dream because they
can not relate to what others consider reality. This is found in the
Anacardiaceae, Solanaceae, Rubiaceae, Loganiaceae, Umbelliferae, Papaveraceae,
Myristicaceae, Iridaceae, Ranunculaceae, Valerianaceaea, and Cannabinaceae
(Cann-i. Cann-s.). The plant remedies are prone to states where fantasy and
reality are mixed in a creative and destructive ways. When emotional stress
increases to the breaking point, the plant temperament enters delirium ,
hysteria, hypochondriasis and melancholia. The rubric, dreams from emotional
causes, is led by plants such as Acon. Stram. Gels. Ign. Nux-v. Op. Cann-i.
etc.. This rubric is based on 21 plants, 8 minerals and 3 animals. This is a
sign of how deeply the emotional disposition and subconscious mind are affected
in the plant remedies.
Duality and Separation
A deep sense of duality runs through the plant temperament as seen in
Anacardiaceae, Loganiaceae, Iridaceae, Cannabinaceae, Myristicaceae,
Papaveraceae, and Leguminosae (Bapt, Lath, Phys), This duality is shared with
the animal poison remedies. The only mineral known for a strong sense of
duality is Phosphorus. The plant remedies are prone to so many emotional
changes that they no longer feel like one person. The sensation of feeling
"scattered" is most famous in Baptisia, where it reaches fullest
expression. The duality of the plant temperament runs in line with feeling as
if in a dream and the withdrawal into fantasy. This duality affects their
emotional disposition so they are never emotionally fulfilled nor feel
complete. They are always looking for a soul mate or partner to make them
whole. They are often dependent on others for fulfillment which makes them
prone to emotional disappointments. The duality of the plant remedies leads to
full breaks with reality in the form of hysteria which demonstrates that the
subconscious emotions are gaining control over the rational mind.
Rage and Frustrated Love
It may come as a surprise that the rubric for rage includes 60 plants,
24 minerals, and 3 animals. These plants include the leading remedies of the
Anacardiaceae, Ranunculaceae, Umbelliferae, Solanaceae, Loganiaceae,
Papaveraceae, Liliaceae, Lycopodiacae, etc. The rage of the plant kingdom is
often quick to rise and is often followed by repentance. It is an emotional
explosion rather then the calculated revenge of the minerals or the competitive
battle of the animals. This rage often alternates quickly with other emotions
such as happiness and sadness. Their rage is a last emotional cry for help
before they completely lose all mental control. They need their emotional
feelings to be heard or they will compensate with mood swings, fantasy,
hysteria, fainting, acting, hypochondriasis, melancholia and nervous
breakdowns. The source of the problem is often frustrated love, disappointment,
and confused sexual instincts. These compensations are a desperate cry for love
and attention. A well-nourished plant is usually healthy.
Destructiveness and Emotional Sabotage
The destructiveness of the plants is usually an emotional cry for help.
The plant temperament will make an emotional scene at the most difficult of
times causing everyone present to stop what they are doing and take notice.
This is a form of emotional sabotage that seems mindless but has a definite
subconscious purpose. Destructiveness of the plants is clearly seen in the
rubric for children, which has 9 plants (Anac. Bell. Cham. Cina. Hyos. Nux-v.
Staph. Stram. Verat.), 1 mineral (Hep), 4 animal remedies (Canth. Lach. Sep.
Tarent.) and 3 nosodes (Carc. Med. Tub). The hysterical fits of plants are
destructive of clothes, objects, and they may throw things. When a plant remedy
loses mental control they can strike, bit, kick, scratch, or kill in a fit of
passion. Sudden attacks suits remedies like Bell. Hyos. Stram. (Solanaceae)
while more chronic states suit anti-miasmics like Lyc. Nux-v. and Staph.
The Stages of Life
The plant remedies flourish in an atmosphere of love and kindness. They
are sensitive to the emotional and physical environment and suffer when
overexposed physically and mentally. They are affected
by the long-term effects of emotional and physical trauma and have a
tendency toward crises. The emotional life of the plant remedies is very
important, as they are dependent on their lover, home, mother, father and
siblings for attention. If this domestic environment is dysfunctional they
begin compensating for the lack of love by making emotional scenes and having
hysterical-like emotional attacks.
The cause of their problems is unrequited love by a fantasy or real
lover.
When in the functional stage the plant temperament is cheerful, amorous,
and sensitive but under acute stress they react with acute disorders, emotional
crisis, and alternating mental and physical symptoms. The plant remedies feel
things very deeply and they suffer when their emotions are ignored or
repressed. The first stage of stress leads toward acute like hysteria,
delirium, faintness, anxiety, fright, confusion and panic attacks. They are
full of tears then suddenly react with laughter and other mood swings and have
trouble maintaining mental control. Their delicate plant nervous system can not
stand much strain without emotional and physical symptoms. The males tend to
become more unruly and repress their emotional pain and sensitivity with angry
outbursts that produce bilious, nervous and other concomitants.
In the 2nd phase the plant temperament is one of resistance
in which their repressed material is transformed into compensations. In the
stage of adaptation they use all the mental control they can muster to overcome
their mood swings and emotions, especially in front of people. They try to
control themselves but they can not suppress their repressed emotions. As time
goes on they become more and more sensitive to their physical and emotional
environments. As their frustration increases it transforms into irritability,
contrariness, and attacks of rage that are a final cry for attention. If this
desperate call for love is ignored they turn destructive.
In the 3rd stage what little mental control the patient has
is lost to a sea of rapidly changing emotions and sensations. Their frustrated
love of life is now transformed into rage and destructiveness. Now the
hysterical fits, emotional rages, and emotional sabotage demands immediate
attention to their provocative actions. They will do dangerous things or act as
if they are going to injure themselves or others. In the phase of exhaustion
stage they may fall into the opposite state of withdrawal and melancholia where
they are dreamy, withdrawn, comatose, or lost in state of fantasy where they
don't wish to recognize anyone or wish to know anything. Here the plant
temperament falls to nervous breakdowns, insanity and suicide.
The above symptoms are therapeutic hints of the plant remedies rather
than definitive rubrics. Only a complete analysis of the signs, befallments and
symptoms of each individual case will demonstrate the correct mineral, plant or
animal remedy. This is rather straightforward where there is a full display of
constitutional symptoms. There are, however, certain conditions, signs and
symptoms that cause the homoeopath to study the lesser known intercurrent and
regional plant remedies. These smaller remedies do not normally show through
the polychrests on repertorization. This therapeutic lacuna includes a great
number of plants that play a pivotal role in complete case management.
An excellent way to learn the plant remedies is to study botanical
families and species in groups. On this basis one then learns the relationships
of remedies to other related plant, mineral, and animal remedies. In this way
the homoeopath can work from the polychrests to the smaller remedies and from
the smaller remedies to the polychrests. One leads naturally to the other and
vice versa.
Part ?:
[David Little] 1996-2007
The Remedies of the Animal World
Samuel Hahnemann introduced the animal kingdom to the homoeopathic
materia medica in 1817 with the introduction of the Molluscae, Sepia, the
cuttlefish. Sepia is included in the antipsoric remedies published in the
Chronic Diseases in 1828 and has become one of our constitutional polychrests.
The Founder's three animal remedies were Sepia (ink of the cuttlefish), Ambra
grisea
(the bilious, fatty excretion of a sperm whale), and Calc. (oyster
shell). The animal remedies form the smallest number of homoeopathic remedies
and possibly the most homogeneous of the three kingdoms. To get a larger
understanding of the animal remedies our focus shifts to study the nature of
their sources and their habitats. Farrington offers us a clue to the animal
character in his “Comparative Materia Medica”, in Lachesis and other Allied
Remedies, starting page 317.
"Medicines derived from
the animal kingdom act energetically and rapidly. They vary in intensity from
the fatal snakebite to coral, sponges, etc. which are more or less modified by
their mineral constituents"
The animal remedies are the most rapidly acting and destructive family.
The spectrum begins with the poisons of the Ophidians (Elaps. Crot-h. Lach.
Naja), Arachnida (Lat-m. Mygal. Tarent.), Insecta (Apis. Canth. Vesp.), Medusae
(Medus. Physal-p.) and runs to the slower acting remedies that are influenced
by their mineral constituents. For example, some mineral influenced remedies
are Cor-r. (Calcium and Iron), Spong. (Iodine), and Calc. (Calcium). As in the
plant remedies we find that poisons act most quickly and violently while those
with strong mineral affinities tend to be slower acting. This shows the
suitability of certain animal remedies for crisis and others for more chronic
miasms and degenerative diseases. In general, all foreign animal substances that
are not nutritional act toxically on the human organism and invoke strong,
instinctive, defensive reactions. E.A, Farrington offers a few more clues about
the animal remedies in his work, “A Clinical Materia Medica”, a study of
Homoeopathy from the view of the three worlds. Vide Lecture II, Animal Kingdom,
page 25.
"Many of the animal
poisons are distinguished by the violence and intensity of their action, and by
the decided alterations which they produce in both structure and function. The
blood is deranged in its circulation, composition and quality. The nervous
system suffers and even the lower tissues are affected. The whole tendency of
these remedies is to produce diseases, WHICH are NEVER of ASTHENIC CHARACTER
and ALWAYS of a DESTRUCTIVE FORM, tending thus to local as well as to general
death of the body. We therefore, look upon these poisons as medicines which
suit deep-seated diseases, such for example, as are accompanied by changes in
the quality of the blood; such as profoundly affects the nervous centres."
Since the ancient Greeks, healers have categorized reactions of the
vital force into the functional polarities, sthenic (hyper-functioning/=
strong, vigorous, or active), and asthenic (hypo-functioning/= weak/slow).
These categories are symbolized by the polarities of the primordial
homoeomeries, fire and water, as well as earth and air. In general, the more
poisonous an animal substance, the more sthenic the initial symptoms it
produces in the provings. As the mineral constituents become more dominant the
nature of the symptoms align with the mineral family. For example, Spongia
reflects the sthenic tendency of Iodine and the Halogen group (17-VII), while
Calc. is more similar to the more asthenic symptoms of the Earth Alkali group
(2-IIA).
The Development of the Non Chordate Phylums
Azoic and Archeozoic Eras
Zoology records the evolutionary history of the animal world. The Azoic
Era (5000 million years) begins with the origin of the Earth and the appearance
of inorganic elements and organic molecules. In the Archeozoic Era (5000-3500)
viruses formed a bridge between the inorganic minerals and the organic
molecules and the first living cells appeared. The Animal Kingdom is divided
into two major categories, the Non Chordates (no neural tube), and Chordates
[neural tube-notocord (= neural tube that evolves into the spine and brain)].
In the Five-Kingdom classification, bacteria and blue-green algae
(cyanobacteria) are in the Monera Kingdom and the protozoans are in the Protist
Kingdom. Most of the nosodes come from viruses and bacteria although Psorinum
is an animal mite (Insecta). The nosodes form their own family portrait and
will be dealt with in the following instalment. The Fungi Kingdom is separated
from the Plant Kingdom, and the animals are divided into invertebrates and
vertebrates. The three lower kingdoms represent the most primitive forms of
life.
Proterozoic & Paleozoic Era
By the Proterozoic Era (2000-600) viruses, bacteria, and blue-green algae
(cyanobacteria) flourished in the Precambrian seas. This period introduced the
Porifera, (sponges), Coelenterata, (corals, medusae, sea anemone,
hydromedusae), Platyhelminthes (flat worms, flukes, tape worms), Ascheliminthes
(round worms) and Annelida (jointed worms). The Paleozoic Era (600-225) was one
of great expansion among the animal phylums and plant species in the seas and
their first adaptation to the land environment. The Paleozoic Era includes 6
periods.
1. First is the Cambrian Period (600-500) where viruses, bacteria,
blue-green algae and red algae flourished and the 25 non-chordate invertebrate
phyla became established. This period saw the appearance of Mullusca (oysters,
squids) Echinodermata (starfish and sea urchins) as well as early Arthropoda
classes, the Crustacea [crabs), Insecta (cockroach), Arachnida (scorpions,
spiders), Chilopoda (centipedes) and Diplopoda (millipedes).
2. The Ordovician Period (500-435) brought the origin of the first
chordates, the lower Chordata (rudimentary notochord), or Acraniata (no
cranium), and the higher Chordata or Craniata (notocord, vertebrae, and
cranium). The lower chordates are divided into two classes, the Urochordata
(notochord present only in larval tail i.e. sea squirt) and the Cephalochordata
(notochord along entire body i.e. lancelet). In the lower chordatas the neural
tube is in its rudimentary spinal development. The higher Chordata or Craniata
(notochord, vertebrae and cranium) are divided into the Agnatha (without jaws,
the jawless and armored fishes) and the Gnathostomata (jaws and paired
appendages), which includes all other vertebrates. In the higher chordates the
neural tube is connect to a brain that is contained in the bony skull.
3. The Silurian Period (435-395) saw the origin of the jawed fish and
Arthropods, wingless Insecta, and scorpion-like Arachnida and the first Lichens
moved to land. This interesting plant is a symbiotic combination of algae and
fungi. The Insecta, Arachnida and Lichens adapted to the new environment and evolved.
4. The Devonian Period (395-345) is called the Age of Fishes as Pisces
ruled the oceans. This period spawned the origin of the Amphibia that left the
seas seeking new territory on land. The fern allies and ferns developed along
with the early gymnosperms like the Cycads and Cordaitales.
5. The Carboniferous Period (345-275) is called the Age of Amphibians.
The great swamps and trees supported the amphibian transition from sea to land
and eventually became coal beds. The close of this period witnessed the origin
of the first winged insects and reptiles.
6. The Permian Period (275-225) witnessed the mass extinction of many of
the marine invertebrates. At the same time, modern Insecta and Reptiles
flourished on the land. This period saw the evolution of the first deciduous
plants.
The Mesozoic (Middle) Era (230-65) began with heavy glaciation and the
extinction of many previous species. It encompasses the rise and fall of the
dinosaurs, the origin of mammals, and the rise of modern birds and placental
mammals. The Mesozoic Era is divided into three periods, the Triassic Period,
the Jurassic Period, and the Cretaceous Period.
1. The Triassic period (230-180) experienced heavy glaciation that
caused the primitive gymnosperms to give way to the higher gymnosperms. In this
epoch the primitive amphibians became extinct and
the great reptiles like the dinosaurs appeared.
2. The Jurassic period (180-135) is called the Age of the Reptiles. It
gave birth to the first toothed birds and mammals and gave rise to the flowering
plants (angiosperms).
3. The Cretaceous period (135-65) covers the extinction of the giant
reptiles and toothed birds and the origin to the ancestors of modern birds and
placental mammals.
Cenozoic Era (65-0) from sixty-five million years ago to the present
day. This period introduced the modern monocotyledon and dicotyledon plants as
well as birds and higher mammals. This era is divided into the Tertiary and
Quaternary Periods.
The Tertiary Period
1. The Paleocene epoch (65-54) introduced the archaic mammals and first
primates.
2. Eocene epoch (54-38) diversified placental mammals, and brought the
birth of the ancestors of modern horses, cattle, elephant, crocodiles, turtles,
etc.
3. Oligocene epoch (38-23) saw the appearance of monkeys and apes and
the ancestors of cats, dogs, bears, etc.
4. Miocene epoch (23-6) found mammals flourishing and the early
human-like apes (hominids) appeared.
5. Pliocene epoch (6-2) gave rise to land mammals. Marine life was fully
established as it is today.
The Quaternary Period
1. The Pleistocene epoch (2 million-10, 000 years) witnessed the
extinction of the great mammals and the rise of early human beings.
2. The Holocene epoch (10,000-to present) is called the Age of Man,
which is the home to modern humans, mammals, birds, fishes and insects. Farming
and animal husbandry developed. The year 2000 is at the turning point for
humanity, as the species shall either find solutions to the worldwide
ecological and social problems or face extinction.
Classification of Human Beings
All racial groups, Mongoloid, Negroid, Caucasoid and Australoid, are
stocks of the species Homo sapiens, which is classified as follows:
1. The Kingdom Animalia as humans require complex organic food and pass
out faeces and nitrogenous waste materials.
2. Subkingdom Exmetazoa as humans have digestive tract, tissues and
organic systems.
3. Phylum Chordata as humans have notocord and visceral pouches in the
embryonic stage and dorsal hollow brain and nerve chord throughout life.
4. Subphylum Vertebrate or Craniata as humans have a cranium around the
brain and a segmented vertebral column around the spinal cord.
5. Division Gnathostomata as humans have jaws to support the mouth.
6. Superclass Tetrapoda as they have four limbs.
7. Class Mammalia as humans have hair, pinnae, and mammary glands.
8. Subclass Theria as human beings are viviparous (live birth).
9. Infraclass Eutheria as humans have true placenta and prolonged
intrauterine development.
10. Order Primates as humans have nails over the digits.
11. Suborder Anthropoidea as humans have rounded head and facial muscles
that provide emotional expression.
12. Family Hominidae because humans have erect posture, bipedal
locomotion and forelimbs (arms) that are shorter then hind limbs (legs).
The Non Chordate Phylums divided into 25 phylums of which 8 are in the
Homoeopathic Materia Medica. The phylums are listed from the lowest to highest
order.
1. Porifera, sponges (Bad. Spong.).
2. Coelenterata, corals, medusae, sea anemone, hydromedusae (Corr-r.
Medus. Physala).
3. Platyhelminthes, flat worms, flukes, tape worms (isopathy).
4. Aschelminthes, round worms (isopathy).
5. Annelida, jointed worms (Sanuisuga-leech).
The Porifera and Coelenterata are sometimes combined and called the Radiata
based on their radial symmetries. The Porifera, and the Coelenterata corals,
are very strongly affected by their mineral constituents and reflect their
mineral analogs. Medusa and Physala are remedies that show the rapid onset and
symptoms associated with the animal poisons. The worm remedies are old
isopathic remedies in many cultures and were experimented with by the
homoeopathic-isopaths of the 19th century. We have no provings of the
helminthes although they cause serious diseases in their human host. Perhaps
this is a lacuna in our animal materia medica?
The next important groups are the Mollusca and Echinodermata. They share
many homoeopathic symptoms and are suitable for some similar conditions. The
Murex and Cuttlefish share many symptoms. The remedies made from oyster and
conch shell show the characteristic symptoms of their related mineral remedies
(the Calcium group). The starfish shares their seabed environment with the
oysters.
These deep acting antimiasmic remedies have an action on the phlegmatic
temperament, the hydrogenoid constitution, and the sycotic miasm. Such remedies
particularly reflect mistunements of the watery element, the genitourinary
system, and venereal diseases.
6. Mollusca Class:
1. Cephalopoda (Sep.).
2. Pelecypoda (Calc. Pecten.).
3. Gastropoda (Conch, Murx.
Helix.).
7. Echinodermata (Aster.)
The Arthropoda is the next important phylum. The Homoeopathic Materia
Medica includes remedies from four of the five classes of Arthropoda. This
phylum develops a homogeneous set of signs and symptoms, which is similar
throughout its classes. At the same time each class of Arthropoda has its own
unique family characteristics.
8. Arthropoda Class
1. Crustacea (Astac. Hom. Lim.
Onis).
2 Insecta (Apis, Blatta,
Canth. Coc-c. Vesp.).
3. Arachnida (Androc. Lat-m.
Mygal. Tarent. Ther.).
4. Chilopoda
(Scolopendra-centipede).
The symptoms of the Crustacea, Astac. (crayfish), Hom. (lobster) and
Limi (king crab) are very similar as they reflect the nettle and bilious rash
of the shellfish family. All of these remedies are very allergenic and manifest
a similar pattern of symptoms. Onis, the sole land Crustacea, develops symptoms
more like the Insecta. The Insecta and Arachnida are easy recognizable by their
family symptoms although each remedy has unique differential symptoms. The only
Chilopoda remedy at this time is the centipede.
The Chordate Phylums
The Craniata of the Phylum Chordata include the subphylum Vertebrata and
the division, Gnathostomata. This includes the Pisces and the Tetrapods,
divided into the four classes, Amphibia, Reptilia, Aves and Mammalia. They all
share the complete neural tube but the brain and nervous system demonstrates
different states of evolution in the fish, land animals, and human beings.
The Two Superclasses
Pisces and Tetrapods
1. Pisces, Class Osteicthyes (Eryth. Gad. Ol-j. Trach-d, Trach-v.).
2. Tetrapods Class
1. Amphibia (Bufo, Salam. Trito.).
2. Reptilia Order
A. Lacertilia, lizards (Amp.
Helo. Lacer.).
B. Ophidians (Elaps. Crot-h,
Lach. Naja, Vipera).
3. Aves (Corvus Corax Principalus (corpus) and (sanguinious), Serinus
Canaria, Indian Eagle, Ovi Gallinae Pellicula, Calcarea Ovi Testi).
4. Mammalia (Ambr. Carb-an. Cast. Hipp. Meph. Mosch. Ol-an.).
A. Milks (Lac-c. Lac-d. etc. )
The use of a homoeopathic remedy often depends on its source.
For example Ol-j is made from the bile of a Codfish. The bile remedies
(Ol-j. Fel-tauri) have a deep effect on the hepatic system, digestion, and
choleric temperament.
Trachinus is a poison fish whose sting acts similarly to the other
animal venoms.
The poisonous fish, lizards, snakes, and spiders all cause rapid
destruction of tissue and chronic sequels.
The Mammalia includes remedies made from preputial sacs like Beaver
(Cast.) and Musk Dear (Mosch.), as well as the anal sac of a skunk (Meph.). Of
course, Moschus is sexual and hysterical
while the Mephitis is nauseated and revolted. The milks form a remedy
group within the mammal family and reflect many animal world characteristics.
This can clearly be noted in Lac-c, the most
proven and clinically confirmed of the milks.
Therapeutic Hints
Acute and Chronic Diseases
The animal remedies are suitable for both acute and chronic complaints
depending on constitution, disease conditions, and circumstances. The heroic
poisons mimic the most dangerous states of acute diseases, virulent miasms, and
toxic states. This includes virulent miasms like influenza, scarlet fever,
yellow fever, meningitis, diphtheria, typhoid, ebola, and other potentially
fatal acute diseases.
The rapid destruction of the blood and vital centers is almost
immediate. The rapid movement and destructiveness of the animal world simulates
this activity when compared with the more stationary
plants and stable minerals. The animal remedies are suitable for crisis,
acute disorders and miasms, and destructively chronic diseases. The animal
remedies reach the most destructive phases of pathology, like ulceration and
necrosis, very quickly. In general, the plants mimic the rapid development of
crisis and acute diseases while the mineral remedies are slower and more
insidious like chronic states.
The animal world remedies reflect both acute and chronic states in equal
measure. As the animals are the highest order they reflect both the attributes
of the minerals and the plants they depend on for life. They are especially
indicated in potentially fatal crises or acute disorders as well as chronic
diseases that have the character of the rapid destruction of organic tissue. A
chronic disease with the tendency toward acute-like crisis and destructive
organic pathology suits the animal remedies well. The Crustacea (Astac. Hom.
Onis), mistunes the choleric temper and produces bilious constitutions and
causes allergenic liver-rash and hives (shellfish reactions). The Insecta
(Apis, Canth. Vesp.) are famous for intense burning, heat, redness, and other
signs of fiery inflammation. The Arachnida (Lat-m. Tarent.), and Reptiles
(Helo.), Ophidians (Crot-h. Lach. Naja) share the rapid onsets and destructive
degenerative states of the venomous creatures. If one survives the potentially
fatal crisis the poisons move on to chronic sequels and progressive
degenerative diseases. Many of these poisons are known for the darker reds and
blue-black colors of necrotic degeneration associated with the destruction of
the blood and excess of atrabilious humour.
Animals and Constitutions
The animal remedies of the materia medica reflect many clear
constitutional types that are well known by their mind/body portraits (Ambr.
Apis, Aster. Bufo, Calc. Carb-an. Lac-c. Lach. Sep. Tarent).
The first animal portrait was of the Mollusk, Sepia, the Cuttlefish.
Hahnemann wrote how the brownish-black ink of the Sepia produced a dejected,
weepy, gloomy melancholic state that is pensive, anxious, apprehensive, and
suffers aversion to work and indifference to the family. Melancholia is an
excess of "black bile" that is associated with feeling
"blue" or suffering "dark moods". Sepia also affects the
weepy phlegmatic humour and mistunes the sexual system producing a downward
pressure as if everything would protrude from the pelvis. The complexion is
yellowish and the face often has a yellow or brown saddle across the nose and
cheeks demonstrating the hormone imbalances associated with this remedy. The
cuttlefish has a luminescent brownish body with white spots and stripes and a
beautiful violet lateral fin that acts as a colorful, scintillating cape. The
image of the Cuttlefish squirting its dark brown cloud as a 'smoke screen' to
attack prey and hide from an enemy is symbolic of many of the symptoms of
Sepia. These images are part of Sepia's signatura rerum.
Animal Remedies and Chronic Miasms
The animal remedies play an important role in the treatment of chronic
miasms. The animal substances have a clear action on the non-venereal and
venereal miasms. Bufo, Lac-c. Lach. and Sep. have been confirmed in all the
four miasms Hahnemanni. The animals reflect some of the most degenerative and
corrupted states of the miasmic process. They over stimulate the life force
producing sthenic states and plethora that become progressively destructive in
nature and may end in exhaustion. The animal remedies produce some of the
foulest, vilest and most degenerative states of physical and mental pathology.
The clinically confirmed antimiasmic remedies are relatively few in number so
they are listed below:
1. Psora (Ambr. Apis, Bufo, Calc-ostr. Canth. Carb-an. Coc-c. Crot-h.
Elaps, Lac-c. Lac-d. Lach. Sep.).
2. Pseudopsora (Bufo, Calc-ostr. Carb-an. Lac-c. Lac-d. Lach. Ol-j. Sep.
Ther.).
3. Sycosis (Apis, Aran. Aster. Bufo, Calc-ostr. Cast. Canth. Coc-c.
Crot-h. Elaps, Dor. Lac-c. Lach. Mosch. Murx. Ol-j. Sac-l. Sep.).
4. Syphilis (Apis, Bad. Bufo, Canth. Cor-r. Crot-h. Eryth. Lac-c. Lach.
Sep. Spong.).
Animal Temperament
The mineral remedies have a direct effect on the intellect and
intelligence (Geist) while the plants initially mistune the emotional
disposition (Gemut). The animal remedies have a profound action on the animal instinct,
the vital force, and human sexuality. These remedies deeply affect the
subconscious and instinctive levels of the human being ruled directly by the
vital force. The animals stir primitive subconscious emotions over which the
rational spirit has little control. This struggle is between the higher
neocortex ruled by the rational spirit and the old instinctive reptilian and
mammalian brain centers. In reality such troubled souls are fighting with the
"beasts" within them. This conflict can bring out some of the lowest
qualities of a human being. Farrington offer more hints in his “A Clinical
Materia Medica”.
"You will find, too, that
these animal poisons are apt to affect the mind, especially the emotions. They
arouse the lowest qualities in human nature, and produce a condition which is
truly shocking. Some of them arouse the filthiest lust, the most intense anger,
and passions of a kindred nature. So we may find many of these drugs suitable
for persons affected with insanity, whether it be the result of functional or
organic, cerebral changes, whether or not it be reflex from irregularities in
bodily functions."
The spiritual and emotional symptoms of the animal world are distinct
yet complementary to the images of the minerals and plants. The animal poisons
are well known for stirring up the instinctual level within human beings and
producing "animalistic emotions" with altered states of
consciousness.
Instinctive, Subconscious, Animalistic
The instinctive animalistic emotions of the animal remedies are found
within all the animal remedies to one degree or another. The virulent poisons
like the Insecta, Arachnida, Reptiles and Ophidians produce the most rapidly
developing delusions, delirium and dreams. The animal realm is under control of
the subconscious mind rather than the rational human spirit. These emotions are
seated in the "reptilian brain" which rules over our early
evolutionary epochs and are not under the conscious control of the individual
ego. The battle to control the "beast" within is an essential theme
of the animal world remedies. The old reptilian brain has not changed much
since humans lived in caves and is confused by the rapid changes of the last
century. The struggle between the animal and human nature within our species is
the source of many myths, fables and religious teachings.
Combative, Aggressive, Possessive and Jealous
The animal remedies tend to be dominant, competitive, aggressive (Apis,
Androc. Lach. Sep.), envious (Calc. Cench. Lach. Sep..) and jealous (Apis,
Bufo, Calc. Cench. Lach.). This jealousy is of a very sexual nature and they
are envious toward other dominant types in the "herd". The animal
remedies like to be the leader and will do almost anything to get to the top.
The animal temperament lives by
the Darwinian law, the survival of the fittest, and tries to control
their territory and keep "intruders' out so they collect the best
"food" and "breeding stock". In the modern world much of
this animal instinct is compensated for by the intellect, but as time passes,
the rational spirit loses control to the impulses of the animal realm.
Altered States, Delusions, Heaven or Hell
The animal remedies produce exalted states of fancy (Ambr. Apis, Bufo,
Canth. Crot-h. Lac-c. Lach. Sep. Spong. Tarent.) and visions (Calc. Canth.
Carb-an. Crot-c. Lach. Sep. Spong. Tarent.). They are also prone to fearful
states where they feel threatened. The animal remedies amplify subconscious
instincts and undermine the rational spirit producing delusions and delirium
(Apis, Canth. Crot-c. Crot-h. Lac-c. Lach. Lat-k. Mosch. Tarent.). The animals
have delusions of phantoms (Ambr. Calc. Canth. Carb-an. Lac-c. Lach. Sep.
Spong. Tarent.), of persecution (Calc. Crot-h. Lach. Spong.), and that they
are sick (Calc. Mosch. Murx. Sep. Tarent.). The Ophidians hear voices
(Cench. Crot-c. Crot-h. Elaps, Lach.).
Fear, Fight or Flight
The animal remedies respond to danger with immediate fight or flight.
This response is instinctive in nature and takes place with no contemplation.
This state is neither like the emotional panic of the
plants or the loss of reason seen in the minerals. The animal remedies
express a state of high tension, fear, and fright in which the instinct for
self-survival overpowers the rational mind (Ambra,
Androc. Bufo, Crot-h. Coc-c. Elaps, Lach. Mosch. Murx. Sep. Spong.
Ther.).
Violence and Intense Anger
The animal temperament is more apt to fight over sex or territory than
over higher principles. When they become angry or afraid they can attack with
great ferocity (Bufo, Canth. Coc-c. Crot-h. Form.
Lach. Lat-m. Mosch. Sep. Spong.). The animals can be very hard on their
own species and will use force to control other submissive creatures. Some will
destroy those who are in competition with
them for mates, territory, and leadership roles. The animal anger is
explosive and very dangerous to self and others.
Excessive Vitality and Perverted Sexual Instinct
The animal remedies mimic plethoric states of vital energy that is seeking
an outlet. The animal substances pervert the sexual instinct and produce states
of nymphomania, lasciviousness and "satyriasis" (Aster. Bufo, Canth.
Lach. Mosch.) ). In the healthy state the animal remedies are vital and sexual
and seek release through sexual intercourse or masturbation (Ambr. Apis, Bufo,
Lach. Meph. Sep. Tarent.). The animal's desire for sex is physical rather than
emotional like the plants or mental like the minerals. The animal remedies have
the potential to descend into the lowest levels of human sexual activity and
can be completely immoral and shameless (Bufo, Canth. Mosch. Murx. Tarent.).
Drinking and Substance Abuse
The animal remedies have a desire for alcohol and are substance abusers
(Bufo, Cocc-c. Crot-h. Lac-c. Lach. Meph. Mosch. Sep). Using alcohol to
antidote the effects of snakebite is common to many traditional cultures.
Lachesis offers a clear picture of the relationship of the Ophidians to
drinking. They crave alcohol because it makes them "feel better". In
the beginning drinking is part of an outlet for strong instinctive energy and a
way of letting go of tension. It does not take long before the delusions and
confusions hidden in their subconscious mind begin to surface. When drunk their
minds become a kaleidoscope of strong repressed emotions and carnal desires.
This combination may stimulate unsolicited sexual advances or rape while under
the influence. Drinking also brings out the kind of violence that leads to
full-fledged animal attacks and brutality.
Senility, Madness and Insanity
The animal remedies demonstrate a great number of symptoms similar to
madness and insanity (Ambr. Apis, Calc. Canth. Carb-an. Crot-c. Crot-h. Lach.
Mosch. Murx. Naja, Sep. Tarent.) These remedies are suitable for mental
disorders based on functional changes as well as organic pathology and chronic
miasms. Under acute stress or crises the animals tend to become hysterical
(Ambr. Bufo, Calc-ostr. Canth. Crot-h. Elaps, Lach. Mosch. Mygal. Sep. Tarent.
Ther.). As time goes on and the stress builds their mind become more delusional
until they enter true madness. The animal remedies have a desire for alcohol
and are substance abusers (Bufo, Cocc-c. Crot-h. Lac-c. Lach. Meph. Mosch.
Sep). Using alcohol to antidote the effects of snakebite is common to many
traditional cultures. Lachesis offers a clear picture of the relationship of
the Ophidians to drinking. They crave alcohol because it makes them "feel
better". In the beginning drinking is part of an outlet for strong
instinctive energy and a way of letting go of tension. It does not take long
before the delusions and confusions hidden in their subconscious mind begin to
surface. When drunk their minds become a kaleidoscope of strong repressed
emotions and carnal desires. This combination may stimulate unsolicited sexual
advances or rape while under the influence. Drinking also brings out the kind
of violence that leads to full-fledged animal attacks and brutality.
[David Little]
The marine animals (Ambr. Aster. Calc. Murx. and Sep.), and Amphibia
(Bufo) end in exhaustion while the Insecta (Apis, Canth.) tend to amorous
frenzy or shamelessness. The animal venoms (Ophidians, Arachnida, Lacertilia)
tend to produce altered states with raving, raging, and delirium. The animal
remedy's battle for survival ends in the most hideous types of senility,
dementia and insanity. The animal instinct for self- preservation is very
strong but they sometimes end their torment with suicide (Ambra, Calc. Crot-h.
Lac-d. Lach. Naja, Sep. Tarent.).
Stages of Life
The animal remedies thrive in a competitive environment. In the
functional stage the animals are strong, vital and active individuals who are
sexy and full of animal magnetism. When this natural power is channeled in
creative directions they are capable of more energy output than the average
human being. They are ambitious, strong willed, and are not easily defeated. As
children they need lots of room and are difficult to keep indoors for long
periods of time. They are prone to sibling rivalries, jealousy, and envy. This
makes them it difficult for them to get along with other children. In a
dysfunctional home or abusive environment they become wild and unruly and may
imitate the most negative of behavior. As they are sexually magnetic they may
fall victim to sexual abuse. As they grow older sex becomes a power over which
they have little control. The animal temperament may have sex for the sake of
sex alone. They demand neither the emotional support that the plants need nor
the appreciation that the minerals expect.
When the animal remedies are placed under stress they react with crisis
much like the plant remedies. This crisis, however, displays dangerous signs
and symptoms immediately. The alarm reaction of the animals is violent and
potentially destructive. Only the most poisonous plants and minerals approach
the rapid destruction that the animal substances and poisons produce. This is
why many of the animal remedies are so useful in virulent acute miasms and
poisonings of the most dangerous nature.
In the stage of resistance and adaption the protracted battle with the
beast within begins. As time goes on their sense of healthy competition
descends into unhealthy rivalries, envy, and combativeness. They may
intellectually realize their faults but they can't help themselves when they
feel challenged. The animal instincts and the lower emotions that they seek to
repress drive them to provocative actions. The more stress they experience the
more they react from instinct rather than intelligence. Life becomes a struggle
that they intend to win at all costs. Their sexuality also transforms from a
healthy state of vitality to a desire to conquer and control which makes them
jealous of any other potential mates. This leads to constant conflict in the
home with angry outbursts and accusations. They have difficulty with other
animal types of the same sex. Life becomes a struggle for them and everyone
around them.
In the final stage of exhaustion the rational spirit and higher emotions
can no longer compensate for the baser instincts and perverted sexuality of the
animal realm. At the same time, their former tendency toward altered states of
consciousness is transformed into delusional states. Their jealousy now takes
on insane forms of suspicion when there is no reason behind such emotions. They
now see those who they perceive as a threat as enemies and begin the final
battle for supremacy. They do not realize that the true obstacle is the beast
within them. Their instinctive fears are projected onto the outer environment
and they may become dangerous. The law of the jungle takes over from more
civilized norms and they lose what little humanity they still possess.
The above rubrics for the animal family offer a glimpse of the general
nature of the animal remedies. Many of the animal remedies are poorly
represented in the repertorium. A study of the characteristic symptoms of the
animal world and its remedy families helps put these remedies into perspective.
[David Little] 1996-2007
The Development of Nosodes
The advent of Hahnemann's theory of the miasms caused great interest in
the chronic diseases and their anti-miasmatic remedies. One of the direct
consequences of the publication of “The Chronic Diseases” was the development
of the use of miasmic organisms as potentized homoeopathic remedies. The
earliest experiments with nosodes were carried out by C. Hering in Surinam,
Guiana, South America between 1827 and 1833. In the five years Hering spent
studying plant and animal species, he paid special attention to the virulent
snake and spider poisons as well as miasmic substances.
This was the time period when Hering captured the Bush Master snake (=
Lach.) that supplied the first venom for the proving of Lachesis. In 1832
Hering said:
"During the experiments
on the serpent poison, I have given out the idea that the hydrophobic virus
should be a powerful pathological agent. I presented the same hypotheses
regarding the virus of variola [small pox]. I expect no less as regards the
psoric virus, and I invited my colleagues to make provings."
It seems that shortly after Hahnemann published his chronic disease
theory, Hering performed the first proving of Psorinum on himself. Hering
originated the method of using a miasmic agent as a basis
for a remedy and he used the term "nosode". The Greek word
Noso is a prefix which is added to give the idea of a disease indicating its
morbid root. This term is also connected with the Latin word "noxa",
the root of the term noxious or damaged. This implies the use of potentially
dangerous noxious materials as a basis for a potentized remedy.
Hering is responsible for greatly expanding the materia medica of
homeopathy and adding seven (7) new categories of potentized remedies. At the
same time, he was one of the true defenders of the four cardinal rules of
Homoeopathy: similars cure similars, the single remedy, the minimal dose and
the potentized remedy. Hering's 7 uses of idem in Homoeopathy include:
1. The use of poisons taken from insects, snakes, and other venomous
creatures (Animal poisons).
2. The use of remedies made from miasmas (Nosodes).
3. The introduction of potentized miasmas and morbid secretions taken
directly from the patient's body (Auto-nosodes).
4. The use of homologous organs, tissue and secretions (Sarcodes).
5. The use of potentized miasmic products as nosodes for the prevention
of infectious diseases (Nosode prophylaxis).
6. The use of chemical and nutritional elements innate to the human
organism (Chemical and elemental relationships).
7. The use of potentized genus groups as curative and preventative
remedies for individuals, groups, and habitats. Hering suggests potentized seed
of weeds or dangerous plants to eradicate and destroy those plants and
potentized insects or animals to remove and prevent infestations of dangerous
species (Isodes).
Hering continued to experiment with nosodes of acute and chronic miasms
and invited others to conduct provings. He recommended the use of potentized
watery excrements of cholera, the black vomit
of yellow fever, the desquamated skin of malignant scarlet fever, to
bind bags of milk sugar in contact with the skin of typhus patients, the use of
leucorrhoeal matter, etc., as well as psorine (Psorinum) gleet-matter
(Medorrhinum), pthisine (Tuberculinum) and syphiline (Syphilinum). Many ancient
isopathic remedies were introduced into the Homoeopathic Materia Medica by
dedicated homoeopaths of the 19th century. C. Hering, W. Gross, Wilhelm Lux,
Father Collet, Swan and Burnett immediately come to mind.
After Hering's introduction of the nosodes, Johann Joseph Wilhelm Lux, a
well known homoeopathic veterinarian, began to conduct experiments with the
isopathic use of disease materials in potencies.
In December, 1831, Lux was asked if he knew any homoeopathic remedies
for the treatment of bovine plague and anthrax. Lux replied that he could not
suggest any remedies off hand but he offered
the following suggestion. He told the person to take a drop of blood of
an animal infected with anthrax, and a drop of the nasal mucous of a cow with
the plague, and prepare a 30c potency of the
material. During the epidemic in 1832 many veterinarians relied on the
complementary use of the nosodes and standard remedies to treat the animals
under their care.
On December 24, 1835, Jolly of Constantinople reported to Hahnemann that
Russian doctors had cured a number of cases of bubonic plague with a 30c nosode
prepared from the serous exudation of plague buboes. Hahnemann was interested
in the new nosode movement on the basis of these clinical experiences but he
was concerned because most of these nosodes were not being proved. So in this
way the revolutionary ideas contained within the 1828 edition of The Chronic
Diseases changed the way people thought about contagious disease and stimulated
the integration of nosodes into the homoeopathic pharmacopoeia.
Aqualia Aqualibus Curentur
All of this was going quite well until Lux decided that the healing law
was not "similars cure similars" but "same cures same".
With this in mind he declared that "idem" not "similars"
was the key to the healing arts and coined the term “Aqualia Aqualibus
Curentur” in place of “Similia Similibus Curentur”. This, of course, was
exactly what Samuel Hahnemann was afraid would happen so he became quite
defensive of Homoeopathy and critical of crude isopathy. Even before Lux’s
statements upset the climate of the research into the nosodes, Hahnemann felt
that Psorinum should be proven more completely before being included in the
materia medica section of The Chronic Diseases. In Hahnemann's mind the idea of
using unproved disease substances on patients just because they suffered from
the same contagion was far too limited.
Hahnemann felt that the isopathy of Lux was in truth only part of a
greater homeopathic principle because all the remedies were potentized to at
least the 30c dynamization. If it was potentized energy how could one call it
the same thing as the original diseased substance? Hahnemann thought that under
these conditions:
"….it would not remain
idem (the same) as it could only be useful to him in a potentized state, since
crude itch substance which he had already in his body as an idem is without
effect on him. But the dynamization or potentizing changes it and modifies
it".
In the light of Hahnemann's logic the use of the miasmic material
without potentization was crude isopathy, and as Lux himself was using
homoeopathic potencies, his treatment was still within the realm of
Homoeopathy. Vide The Chronic Diseases, the chapter called "The
Medicines".
"Thus potentized and
modified also, the itch substance (psorin) when taken is no more an idem (the
same) with the crude original itch substance, but only a simillimum (thing most
similar). For between IDEM and SIMILLIMUM there is no intermediate for any one
that can think; or in other words between idem and simile only simillimum can
be intermediate. Isopathic and aequale are equivocal expressions, which if they
should signify anything reliable can only signify simillimum because they are
not idem."
The major difference between isopathy and Homoeopathy is that a
homoeopathic remedy is proven and based on symptoms brought out in patients so
it has a much wider application because its symptomatic picture is much more
expanded. The simple isopathic prescription can only be used for the same
condition it causes. If the miasmic substance is not potentized, or transmuted
in some way,
it is often an extremely dangerous method. The modern vaccines have more
in common with crude isopathy than Homoeopathy because they are unpotentized.
This limits their usage to the treatment and prevention of one single disease
condition. On the contrary, a homoeopathic nosode has been proven so it can be
used as part of the greater materia medica. This allows it to be prescribed
more accurately
as well as to be applied in many different situations.
The first generation of homeopaths who introduced the use of the nosodes
were Hahnemann, Hering, Lux, Gross, and Stapf. Hering gathered a tremendous
amount of first hand experience in proving
and using nosodes and applying idem remedies to acute and chronic
diseases in the field. Hering introduced all these new remedies yet he clearly
pointed out their limitations when used by idem.
All these idem preparations cannot be regarded as absolute specifics,
but only as chronic intercurrent remedies, which serve to stir up the diseases,
and render the reaction to the subsequently administered homoeopathic remedy
more permanent.
In 1836 Hering stated that:
HE NEVER SUCCEEDED IN CURING BUT
ONLY AMELIORATING DISEASES WITH THEIR OWN MORBID PRODUCTS.
This statement was made after 7 years of rigorous clinical trials. He
gave a perfect example of the proper use of idem in a case of suppressed
syphilis which would not respond to antisyphilitic remedies like Mercury so he
used Syphiline (his syphilinum) as an intercurrent. This brought out the
cutaneous eruption and chancre which was then perfectly cured by Mercury
followed by Lachesis. He had many similar cases. Without constitutional treatment
it is impossible to perform the perfect cure.
The nosodes are only curative by themselves when they are administered
by the totality of the symptoms. Then they are the constitutional simillimum.
IF DISEASE PRODUCING PRODUCTS ARE ADMINISTERED BY IDEM THEY ARE ONLY
USEFUL AS INTERCURRENT REMEDIES WHICH HELP TO REMOVE OBSTACLES TO CURE AND MOVE
THE CASE FORWARD. Their remedial actions must be complemented by constitutional
remedies if a complete cure is going to take place. THIS IS THE PROPER USE OF
IDEM REMEDIES WITHIN COMPLETE CONSTITUTIONAL CASE MANAGEMENT.
The Homoeopathic Uses of the Nosodes
When a nosode is administered by the totality of the symptoms it is a
constitutional simillimum just like the mineral, plant and animal remedies. The
nosodes belong to a genus of primitive miasms which
are the first life forms on our planet and symbiotically related to the
development of the first plant algae. Viruses, bacteria and fungi are ancient
genus groups and some produce disease in human beings. The minerals are the
first remedies on the developmental chain followed by the miasms, fungi,
lichens, fern allies, ferns, gymnosperms, dicotyledons and monocotyledons, and
finally, the animal remedies. The nosode genus group has a very special place
in Classical Homoeopathy.
Hahnemann wanted the nosodes to be well proven before they are entered
in the materia medica. He was quite concerned that Homoeopathy might become
mixed with isopathy which gives remedies solely by causation. Swam, who is
given credit for introducing contemporary Medorrhinum and Syphilinum, was asked
if it was correct to use unproven nosodes. He replied that 100's of years of
suffering these genus diseases, and their complications, provided a
"natural proving".
This rather controversial answer does have some merit. It is obvious,
however, that the most characteristic indications of the nosodes are those that
have come out in provings or on patients under treatment. Nevertheless, there
are specific ways that the miasms disease-tune the vital force producing a
characteristic group of symptoms. Hering noticed that certain characteristic
symptoms are associated with the indications of miasmic intercurrents and
nosodes. Just as the homoeopath who works with families of remedies recognizes
the symptoms of the plant, mineral and animal remedies, Hering recognized the
characteristics of the nosode family picture. These characteristics includes
indications of the miasms concomitant to lack of vital reaction to well chosen
remedies; constant changing of symptoms after administering remedies;
fragmented pictures of several constitutional remedies and one-sided miasmic
pathology with few characteristic symptoms.
Such individuals often have a sense of being tainted, guilty, dirty or
feel like life is a burden, they never feel comfortable or satisfied in any
environment, they have discolored complexions and a look of suffering in the
face when relaxed, and they are prone to self-destructive impulses, cravings
and habits. A differential analysis of the rest of the mental and general
symptoms will immediately uncover which chronic miasm and therapeutic nosode is
at the root of the picture.
Making a comparative study of the plant, mineral, animal and nosode
group symptoms is very helpful. The symptoms of the nosode group are
indications to study the case from the miasmic point of view. From a study of
the totality of the available symptoms one can uncover which miasm is active or
which nosode the vital force is calling to one’s attention. At such a time an
intercurrent may be useful in removing obstructions to the cure or bringing out
a clearer picture. All miasmic intercurrents should be complemented by
constitutional remedies at the appropriate time to complete the cure.
One’s attention may be called to the use of a nosode when the patient no
longer progresses under the influence of a constitutional remedy because well
chosen remedies do not act, hold or only change
the symptoms. Another important indication for the nosodes is a 'never
well since syndrome' when it can be traced to a chronic miasm such as
suppressed gonorrhea or a suppressed skin disorder, etc.
A miasmic block in the case can also produce one-sided states with a
lack of symptoms yet the general history or indication of the miasms is in the
background.
The nosode group characteristics are a signal to investigate the chronic
miasms and map their signs and symptoms as well as looking closely for the
symptoms of the major nosodes and anti-miasmic remedies. Normally one will find
objective signs and subjective symptoms that will individualize the remedy if
it is indicated. Over the years the use of nosodes as chronic intercurrents has
proved
of assistance to constitutional treatment if used correctly.
I would advise students of Homoeopathy to study the use of chronic
remedies deeply and integrate intercurrent remedies carefully into practice
when needed to assist the cure. The isopathic concept seems so easy (using the
same against the same) that many star-struck beginners think they have found a
short-cut way to do Homoeopathy. They do not have enough experience in the more
traditional approach to Homoeopathy to understand those special moments when
intercurrents are complementary to constitutional treatment. Others are prone
to falling into old allopathic thinking combined with new homeopathic remedies.
This leads to the abuse of idem in potency and can cause the disruption of the
constitutional state. In the name of treating layers, removing drugs and
blockages, some practitioners give too many remedies by idem while ignoring the
totality of the symptoms of the patient.
A Synopsis of Nine Ways to Administer the Nosodes
1st indication for the nosodes is when the mentals, physical
generals and particular symptoms are characteristic of the proving of the
remedy. This makes the nosode a CONSTITUTIONAL REMEDY.
An example of this would be the use of Syphilinum in a person who fears
the night because of the suffering it brings, fears going insane, despairs of
recovery, has delusions that they are dirty, tainted,
or impure causing them to compulsively wash their hands, etc. The
symptoms confirm both the miasmic diagnosis and the simillimum. In such cases
the derangement of the vital force occurs in such a manner that it takes the
symptoms of the nosode. In some cases this state may or may not be directly
linkable to the corresponding miasma. Others are born with this tendency due to
the inherited miasms.
2nd condition for using a nosode is when WELL CHOSEN REMEDIES
DO NOT ACT, HOLD, OR JUST CHANGE THE SYMPTOMS. This is usually caused by the
chronic miasms such as psora, sycosis, pseudopsora, and syphilis. This is one
of the reasons why it is important to know what miasms are in the background of
a constitutional syndrome. Otherwise the prescriber may think they are choosing
the wrong remedies and further confuse the situation by picking more and more
new ones. An example of this usage of a nosode is Psorinum's keynotes: Lack of
reaction; when well-chosen remedies fail to act, especially in those who are
extremely sensitive to cold, suffer from profuse sweating, filthy smell, dirty
looking skin, and tend to be very pessimistic about their recovery, etc.
Another example of this rubric is Tuberculinum's keynote: When symptoms are
constantly changing and well-selected remedies do not improve, especially in
those who have light complexion, narrow chest, lax fiber, low recuperative
powers and constantly catch cold. There may also be fear of cats, dogs, and
animals in general, a desire to travel, and a deep discontented state with a
tendency to curse, swear, and a desire to break things, etc.
3rd use of a nosode is when there is a LACK OF SYMPTOMS.
There are times when there are very few symptoms by which to prescribe. These are
often one-sided cases where a strong inherited or acquired miasm has repressed
the ability of the constitution to show symptoms. Other than the signs related
to the pathology of one or another of the miasms, the symptoms in these cases
are not very characteristic of any chronic remedies. This may be a chronic
state caused by a miasmic dyscrasia. Vide the discussion of Tuberculinum in
Kent's Lectures: "It seems from looking over the record of many cures that
this remedy has been given many times for just that state on a paucity of
symptoms, and if the records can be believed, it has many times balanced up to
the constitution in that anemic state, where the inheritance has been phthisis.
It is not the best indication for Tuberc., but where the symptoms agree in
addition to that inheritance, then you may have indication for the
remedy.". There are two things that may happen after the ingestion of a
nosode for such a condition. First of all, the symptoms may improve and bring
the constitution toward the state of health. Second, the symptoms of the
patient may become more plentiful as the suspended layers within the
constitution become more active. The new state allows the homoeopathic
practitioner to prescribe a chronic remedy based on the newly arising syndrome
and advance the case forward.
4th use of a nosode is when a person has not recovered from a
miasmic infection, and its suppression. This state is called "THE NEVER
WELL SINCE SYNDROME" (NWS). An example of this
condition is the use of Medorrhinum in a person who has a history of
sycosis from which they have never recovered. Perhaps a new layer of disease
has been added to their constitution by a suppressed gonorrhea that changed
both their physical health and personality. They no longer manifest the symptoms
of a constitutional remedy because the acquired miasm has become the active
layer and suppressed their natural temperament. Once they may have been of
sharp intellect, clear memory, and of a calm nature, but all that has changed
for the worse. Now they have become very hurried as if time passes too slowly,
they can't follow the thread of a conversation because they are losing their
memory, and they've become fearful of the dark, superstitious, and suffer from
delusions that someone or something is always behind them. This last symptom is
very indicative of the paranoid suspicious state of sycosis as it represents a
subconscious fear that something is going on "behind their back" and
is about to "get them".
The never-well-since syndrome can also be applied to acute miasms. There
are times when a person has never fully recovered from an acute illness or
miasm. The unresolved acute state still has an effect on the vital force as it
has formed a layer within the constitution. If this imbalance is strong it will
become the dominant layer and repress the older weaker symptoms. This is often
caused by acute miasms like influenza, diphtheria, measles, mononucleosis, and
whooping cough from which the patient never really recovered. Of course, a
proper chronic remedy may remove the effects of an unresolved acute miasm, but
when it does not, a nosode of the offending miasm will often cure. Nosodes for
these acute miasms are available from homoeopathic pharmacies under names like
Influenzinum, Diphtherinum, Morbillinum, Pertussinum, etc.
5th use of a nosode is WHEN PARTIAL PICTURES OF THE
CONSTITUTIONAL REMEDIES MANIFEST YET NO ONE REMEDY COMPLETELY FITS THE CASE.
Such cases seem to be fragmented and disorganized, but in actuality, this
pattern is characteristic of the miasms and nosode group. An investigation of
the miasms behind the fragmented picture may reveal the symptoms of the nosode
family. Differential analysis will quickly show which miasm is involved and
what nosode may remove the state. Such an intercurrent often improves the state
of health and regularizes the natural symptoms pattern. After the nosode has
done all it can do the symptoms will point more clearly toward a constitutional
or anti-miasmic remedy. In this way a nosode can bring order out of chaos and
clarity out of confusion.
6th use of a nosode is WHEN A MIASMIC LAYER OBSTRUCTS THE
PROGRESS OF A CONSTITUTIONAL REMEDY that was improving the patient. This use of
a nosode is called a miasmic intercurrent. Suppose one has a patient whose
symptoms point to an inherited pseudopsoric miasm and the case works out to fit
Pulsatilla perfectly. This is all coherent because Pulsatilla
is a strongly anti-tuberculin medicine as well as the individual's
constitutional remedy. After several months of solid improvement the patient
begins to relapse with the same symptoms, and to one's great surprise, the
Pulsatilla no longer works. Although there is no change of symptoms calling for
a new remedy, the old remedy has become completely ineffective. If the
underlying symptomatology shows
the tubercular miasm, the homoeopath can try to unlock the blocked case
with a tubercular nosode, such as Tuberculinum. In the above example the
tubercular nosode sets the stage for the reintroduction
of the Pulsatilla by re-sensitizing the vital force.
Two things may happen after the introduction of the miasmic
intercurrent. The nosode may move the case forward by removing the active
symptoms. When this happens it is best to stay with the nosode as long as the
improvement lasts. If this improvement ceases the remaining symptoms may be
treated with the former chronic remedy. If the patient does not show any
improvement on the nosode after a sufficient amount of time, the former chronic
remedy should be re-introduced. Under these conditions the previous remedy
often acts just as dramatically as it did the first time it was given. This
effect has been witnessed by many experienced homoeopaths over and over again.
Although the miasmic intercurrent may not radically improve the case by itself,
it can cause the patient to become re-sensitized to their original
constitutional remedy. There are times when this technique is extremely useful.
7th way for using a nosode is when the remedy is RELATED TO
THE DISEASE GENUS. An example of this method is Clark's use of Pertussin
(Coqueluchinum) against whooping cough. Clark once wrote, "I have found in
this nosode a specific for a large proportion of cases of this disease. It
should be given every four hours to begin with, and if it does not cut short the
case in a few days, or materially modify its severity, another remedy may be
chosen from the following."
Another area where the isode may be of use is in the case of
complications caused by vaccines. In this case a nosode of the offending
vaccination may be appropriate to remove the side-affects of an immunization.
Closely aligned with using idem is the use of remedies to desensitize a person
to specific allergies. Most individuals are allergenic to more than one antigen
at a time so the chronic remedy, with or without a miasmic intercurrent, is
usually much more effective. Nevertheless, in some very stubborn allergies
where this is not the case, the isopathic method may prove a useful adjutant.
The use of organs and glandular preparations (organotherapy &
hormonotherapy) is also based on idem. This includes remedies like Thyroidinum,
the dried thyroid of the sheep, and Adrenalin, the internal secretion of the
suprarenal glands. This method has also proved useful in some cases of thyroid
disease.
8th use of a nosode is for HOMOEOPATHIC PROPHYLAXIS to
prevent specific infectious diseases. An early example of this was
Boenninghausen's successful use of Variolinum to prevent smallpox. Nosodes may
also be used as a method to protect children from the miasma they have
inherited through their parents. James Kent stated in his Lectures on
Homoeopathic Materia Medica: "If Tuberculinum Bovinum be given in 10m,
50m, Cm. potencies two doses of each potency at long intervals, all children
and young people who have inherited tuberculosis may be immuned from their
inheritance and their resiliency will be restored.". This, of course,
relates to children who show symptoms of the TB miasm such as nervousness,
temper tantrums, emaciation, anemia, swollen glands, frequent colds, etc.
9th use of a nosode is as a homoeopathic remedy made from the
patient's own disease substances. This is called the AUTO-NOSODE. This method
has sometimes helped patients when nothing else seems to work. Hahnemann once
had a patient suffering from phthisis that was not responding to well chosen
remedies. This led him to prepare an auto-nosode made from the saliva of the
patient. Auto-nosodes have been made from sputum, blood, urine, pus,
leucorrhoea, exudates from skin eruptions, and microbes from cultures of the
patient, etc. This is often tried when nothing else works. Nevertheless, with
observation homoeopaths should be able to develop the characteristic symptoms
of the auto-nosodes.
One can see from many of these indications that a good knowledge of the
acute, half-acute and chronic miasms is very important in understanding the use
of nosodes. As they are disease products knowledge of disease goes hand and
hand with their usage. The study of the acute, half-acute and chronic miasms,
and their action on the system of mass defense, is an important part of
classical Homoeopathy. Some modern homoeopaths no longer pay any serious
attention to the miasms and do not study the nine ways to use nosodes. Some are
Neo-Kentian prescribers but they do not seem to understand that Kent studied
the miasms and used nosodes in various ways depending on the circumstances. It
seems at this time, however, the miasms are making a necessary come back as
they are an integral part of homoeopathic pathology. Dare to Know!