Naja
mossambica = Speikobra,
Mosambique/Zulu: Mfezi,
Afrikaans: Spoegslang
http://ir.dut.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10321/61/Taylor_2004.pdf;jsessionid=C124E57D6DF5E7BC8C9F0BF3789EC4E2?sequence=12
Vergleich:
Comparison.:
Naja. + Naja-mos.
Repertorium_naja_+_naja_mossambica_+_ophiophagus
Siehe: Schlangen allgemein + Cobras general.
+ Repertorium.
(Naja haje. + Naja mossambica. + Ophiophagus Hannah).
An evaluation of the homoeopathic drug proving of Naja Mossambica in the
light of a doctrine of signatures analysis and a comparison between the proving
symptons and the venom toxicology
[Lorna Smal]
Poisening: Cytotoxic effects: The venom
contains various proteases which cause cellular damage and hyaluronidase which
encourages the spread of the venom through the tissues.
Complement activation by an alternate pathway triggers enzymes that
cause cell damage, while C3 and C5 are thought to give rise to the formation of
anaphylatoxins which cause the release
of histamine from mast cells and increase vascular permeability. Other
complement reaction products induce polymorphonuclear infiltration. The release
of lysosomal enzymes from dead
polymorphs also causes vascular damage and tissue injury (Tilbury,
1982).
The venom causes cytolysis where the tissue is destroyed and there is
coagulation and thrombosis of the blood (this produces a barrier against the
spread of the venom throughout the body). Bleeding occurs which adds to the internal
pressure, increasing the possibility of ischaemia, causing swelling,
induration, haemorrhage as well as ecchymosis, blisters and necrosis
(Chapman and Visser, 1978).
When only a small volume of venom is injected, instead of blood
extravasation, the swelling is caused mainly by plasma exuding from injured
vascular beds.
The local swelling at the site of the bite can be divided into two
categories:
1. There may be little evidence of extravasation, with the limb
appearing either soft or hard.
2. Haemorrhage may be evident as ecchymosis and bleeding from fang
marks, with solid massive swelling.
Necrosis is usually seen in the second category. The necrosis is
extensive and may be superficial or deep. Necrosis occurs from direct tissue
destruction and occlusion of major vessels.
Severe pain and tenderness is experienced in both categories. In severe
cases the limb may become solidly flexed which suggests serious muscle
involvement caused by haemorrhages or tissue fluid
accumulation. Evidence has been found of recanalization (as though after
a thrombosis) in the deep venous system. Thrombophlebitis (thrombosis with
inflammation of a vein), of the Long Saphenous
vein was also observed (Chapman and Visser, 1978).
Naja mossambica venom has anticoagulant properties like most other snake
venoms.
Cytotoxic symptoms are:
Local burning pain
Swelling
Redness
Superficial necrosis
Extensive blistering
Abscess formation
Extravasation of blood (ecchymosis)
Tissue destruction
Necrosis (can be extensive and have a curiously patchy appearance and
occurs within 48 hours of the bite)
The area around the fang punctures darkens.
Blistering may follow.
Necrosis usually is confined to the skin and subcutaneous tissue but may
be quite extensive.
A putrid smell is characteristic.
Oedema (in the effected limb if the lymph vessels and lymph glands are
damaged or obstructed)
Shock (with „toxic’ appearance)
Infection (due to pathogens introduced during the bite or at a later
stage)
Rare and unusual symptoms have been recorded by victims with greater
sensitivity to the venom:
Vomiting
Abdominal colic
Dizziness
Headache
Sweating
Urticaria
Hyperpyrexia
Drowsiness
Haemorrhage at sites other than the bite
Subconjunctival haemorrhages
Haematuria
The neurotoxic symptoms are found to a lesser extent, compared to the
cytotoxic symptoms.
Neurotoxic effects:
Cobra venom contains postsynaptic neurotoxins that competitively bind to
nicotinic acetylcholine receptors to produce depolarising neuromuscular
blockade. One group in this category has 60 - 62 amino acids and 4 disulfide
bridges. Another has 71 - 74 amino acids and 5 disulfide bridges. It is
suggested that a similar toxin to the curariform neurotoxin that is found in
Naja
Nigricollis venom is found in the venom of Naja mossambica. This is
responsible for the rapid death by respiratory paralysis in its prey and is
evidenced in humans by the local effect of temporary paresis of the pupil
constrictors in a patient having been spat in the eye (Tilbury, 1982).
Neurotoxic symptoms are:
Swelling
Pain spreading widely from the site of the bite
Low blood pressure
Profuse perspiration
Fever
Hyperpyrexia (from hypothalamic interferance)
Vertigo
Vomiting
Convulsions
Unconsciousness
Alteration of mental status e.g. Drowsiness and euphoria
Lethargy
Strabismus
Blurred vision
Restlessness
Frothing around the mouth
Chest pain/tightness
Tachycardia/bradycardia
Cyanosis (due to respiratory distress)
Progressive, spreading paralysis causes:
Ptosis (cranial nerve dysfunction)
Opthalmoplegia
Dysphagia (which results in too much saliva present in the mouth,
leading
to the sensation of drowning in own saliva)
Dysphasia (speech incoordination)
Muscle weakness
Paralysis of the neck muscles, causing the head to fall
Paralysis of the sphincters results in incontinence
Paralysis of the diaphragm and accumulated secretions leads to severe
respiratory distress and respiratory failure
Death is preceded by quiet unconsciousness with shallow respiration.
(Marais, 1992)
According to Smith (2004), some people having received a bite from a
neurotoxic snake have displayed signs of euphoria and unconcern for the fact
that a deadly snake had bitten them. If the bite were left untreated the
euphoria would progress to shallow, laboured breaths, unconsciousness and
death.
Even though Naja mossambica has a neurological component to its venom,
the neurological symptoms are usually slight and overshadowed by the cytotoxic
symptoms. Fatalities are rare (Marais, 1992).
Direct effects of the venom on the eyes
Snake venom in the eye results in immediate, intense burning pain (venom
is rapidly absorbed by small blood vessels close to the surface) and
blepharospasm. It is difficult to open the eye, tears flow copiously, membranes
around the eye become swollen and severely inflamed and the eyeball appears
very red with severe conjunctivitis. Extreme photophobia is seen. There is a
temporary impairment/blurring of vision. Without treatment the lids swell, the
membranes of the eye develop haemorrhages, uveitis, keratitis and ulcerations
of the cornea within 24 hours, which is followed by blindness. The eyes should
be washed with water or milk as soon as possible and for a bite immobilization
and pressure bandages should be employed (Marais, 1992) (Patterson, 1987).
Systemic toxicity does not occur with eye exposure. The eyes < rubbing and
extremely sensitive to light. The nasal membranes also become irritated.
[Tilbury (1982:308)] typical untreated case of envenomation would
progress as follows:
0 - 3 hours: moderate to severe pain at the site of the bite associated
with a progressively enlarging area of swelling and warmth of the affected
area.
3 - 5 hours: first signs of tissue necrosis may appear at the site of
the bite, either as a dark discolouration or asa raised blister.
Serosanguineous fluid may begin to ooze from the bite.
5 - 9 hours: the discolouration begins to spread from the bite site,
often caudad (towards the end of the spine) and occasionally in a „skipping’
fashion, leaving areas of normal skin in between.
9 - 48 hours: plumcoloured discolouration reaches its maximum extent
between 36 and 48 hours and becomes sharply demarcated.
48 - 72 hours: swelling reaches its maximum. The plumcoloured
discolouration darkens to black. Blisters may now appear in the discoloured
area, but usually first appear at the periphery of the necrotic area.
Day 3 onwards: the swelling gradually subsides. Blisters coalesce to
form a blistered rim around the edge of the lesion.
Day 6 - 8 onwards: the necrotic area may be debrided. The subcutaneous
tissues under viable skin could be destroyed; forming subcutaneous burrows
which may extend quite far from the demarcated area of necrosis. After
debridement the resulting ulcer invariably has peripheral undermining.
Necrosis was observed to involve mainly the subcutaneous tissue, sparing
the muscles and deeper structures. This is presumably due to the Mozambican
spitting cobra’s relatively short fangs depositing the venom in the
subcutaneous space where it spreads through the superficial lymph drainage
system.
Five of the patients vomited, one after drinking a homemade potion and
one after receiving anti-venom.
Two patients reported diarrhoea. Drowsiness was noted in four patients;
three were children with severe swelling and required resuscitation for
hypovolaemic shock. Patient sixteen was noted to be very
drowsy on admission three hours after the bite, but there was no severe
swelling or other neurological symptoms.
The only neurological sign seen in these patients was drowsiness.
The dominant feature of the bite is a characteristic cytotoxic lesion,
the venom having a far more destructive cellular toxicity than that experienced
in Puff adder (Bitis arietans arietans) bites.
Tilbury (1982) believes than many bites attributed to puff adders are
actually from the Mozambican spitting cobra. According to Smith (2004), the
snake may inject venom in variable quantities, resulting
in cases that range from being very serious with widespread tissue
destruction, to cases where the amount of venom injected was insufficient to
cause any serious symptoms.
An example of a potentially life-threatening bite:
A one-year old girl was bitten by a Mozambican spitting cobra at Leeukop
Game Ranch near Pongola. The maid sleeping in the room with the girl and her
sister got sprayed in the eyes by the cobra. She ran from the room with the two
girls. Only after treating the maid’s eyes, it was noticed that the little girl
had been bitten on her left upper wrist. The girl’s family first rushed her to
Pongola hospital, then to Vryheid hospital and then to Entabeni hospital in
Durban. Due to incorrect treatment and misdiagnosis the little girl appeared in
danger of loosing her limb. She was being treated for the neurotoxic venom,
which is commonly associated with cobras, when in fact the venom of the
Mozambican spitting cobra is predominantly cytotoxic.
Toxicology
A wealth of information is obtained from the study of the toxicology of homoeopathic
remedies. Precise records kept of the effects of a poisoning (or in this case a
poisonous snakebite) give a clear picture of the possible action of the remedy.
A poisoning may be viewed as a crude 'proving' and may be regarded as
invaluable according to the homoeopathic principle that what a substance can
cause it can cure (the law of similars). Hahnemann believed that the noxious
and poisonous character of these substances were sure revelations of the power
of these drugs to extinguish curatively similar symptoms occurring in natural
diseases, that their pathogenetic phenomena were intimations of their
homoeopathic curative action (Hahnemann, 1998:191). The toxicology provides us
with a clear picture if the organs and body systems that the remedy will
effect. In the proving of Bitis arietans arietans (Wright, 1999), the
toxicology was taken into account to provide a more complete picture of the
action of the remedy on healthy human beings, thereby widening the possible
therapeutic spectrum of the homoeopathic proving of Bitis arietans arietans.
Another remedy, which has its toxicology comprising a large proportion of its
symptomology, is Naja tripudiens (Demarque, et al. 1997:262).
Indigenous snakes are particularly intriguing because other snakes
(Lachesis muta, Naja tripudians, Crotalus horridus) have been extensively and
successfully used in homoeopathy.
Bitis arietans arietans (Puff adder) and Bitis gabonica (gaboon adder),
both South African species have recently been proven and have produced
interesting symptomatology pictures.
It was hypothesized that the proving of Naja-mos. would produce vivid
and remarkable symptoms and become an indispensable remedy in the materia
medica. The researcher chose Naja-mos.
due to its similarity in family and genus as Naja. Naja., is known
generally as the common, Asiatic, Indian or spectacled cobra. Naja. has been
invaluable in cardiac cases both in orthodox and
homoeopathic medicine.
The Mozambican Spitting cobra or Naja-mos. although related and from the
same family as the Indian cobra, has some very different components to its
venom.
The significant differences in the properties of the venom should impact
on the symptoms experienced in the proving. The researcher will be comparing
the differences between Naja. and Naja-mos.
in the mind and dream aspects of the proving.
It is one of the most dangerous snakes, inflicting fatal bites but more
commonly spitting its venom. The commonest victims are young African women who
get bitten while they are busy around
their home at sunset. The snake is very quick and alert, when threatened
or confronted, it raises almost 2/3 of its body, spreads its long narrow hood
and hisses loudly in readiness to spit
venom at its enemy when the latter comes into range. The fangs are
specially modified with the discharge orifice on the anterior face rather than
at the tip. The snake has to lean well back to
ensure that the venom is directed both upwards and forwards. It can
eject venom with its mouth only slightly open by lifting its upper lips in the
form of a snarl. The snake can also eject venom
from almost any position making it dangerous to the unwary that may
expect it to eject venom only from the reared-up position. Venom is effectively
ejected from 1,5 - 2 metres but in large
snakes has been recorded up to 3 metres. Venom directed at the eyes and
causes instant blindness, which can become permanent unless immediate remedial
measures are taken.
The snake seldom attempts an actual bite. It is also one of the snakes
that feign death when threatened.
The venom of Naja-mos. has few neurotoxic and primarily local cytotoxic
effects and is produced in copious amounts. Bites result in local and extensive
cytotoxic effects.
1.
local
PAIN and swelling/may spread quickly up the affected limb. Painful, tender,
enlargement of the regional lymph glands is typical.
Blisters may develop as soon as a
few hours to 24 hours after the bite. Most marked at the site of the fang marks
and may form a ring around a defined area of darkened or pale numb skin.
2.
Blisters
may also extend up the bitten limb, discontinuously in the form of
"skip" lesions.
3.
Earliest
signs of tissue death or necrosis are changes in colour and sensation, the
appearance of blisters and a smell of rotting flesh. Areas of necrotic tissue
and deeper tissues may slough off spontaneously. Tissue loss may be massive,
ext. up the bitten limb, along the path of the lymphatics in the form of
discrete "skip" lesions separated by areas of apparently normal skin.
4. Complications can include
secondary infection of dead tissue, sometimes with bacteria (Clostridia)
causing tetanus or gas gangrene (first vomiting); this may require extensive
surgical removal/amputation.
Other complications include keloid formation;
chronic ulceration with or without infection of the underlying bone and in
worst cases can lead to cancerous changes later.
There is absence of neurological symptoms and
few fatalities. Anti-venoms are not effective (in delay of treatment). Most
fatalities occur particularly in infants and children due to shock.
Hypoglycemia caused by leakage of plasma out of blood vessels in the bitten limb
resulting in swelling, shock and a severe depletion in blood volume. Venom may
also affect the heart directly.
When venom is spit into the eyes an additional, unique form of toxicity
is found: acute ophthalmia,. Naja-mos. can spit venom into a person's eyes from
up to 3 metres away. Immediate and intense pain results, with blepharospasm,
tearing, and blurring of vision. It is difficult to open the eye, tears flow
copiously, membranes around the eye become swollen and inflamed and the eyeball
appears very red. Without treatment the lids swell, the membranes of the eye
develop haemorrhages and keratitis and ulcerations of the cornea within 24
hours, which is followed by blindness. Systemic toxicity does not occur with
eye exposure, but corneal ulcerations, ireitis, and permanent visual impairment
or blindness has been reported in untreated cases.
Antisocial
There was a strong desire to be alone, not wanting to be around people,
unsociable. A strong feeling of irritability and a need for own space and quiet
was noted (36F 00:). People who usually love people, felt averse to company.
They felt quiet and withdrawn and didn’t want to make the effort to socialise,
these feelings were noted to be very unusual and out of character (35F :XX).
Provers felt distant and not as friendly as usual, being unable to get
into a „party mood’ (35F 02:). Feeling reserved and serious, quite low. Worse
for crowds and authorative people.
Anxiety
There was stress and worry and anxiousness about work and things that
had to be done, or for no particular reason. Anxious feeling in the pit of the
stomach. Anxiety, frustration and agitation
(38F 02:08:50) was experienced.
Worry and tension. Anxiety throughout the day. There was difficulty
coping (29F 01:) and being overwhelmed with everything. Restlessness.
Carefree
This ranged from not caring “everything just seemed to glide off my
back” to being light hearted and carefree. Not worried about work or the things
that normally irritate, just want to go have fun
(38F 05:). Not worried about responsibilities or what is expected of a
person. Unmotivated and indifferent, not being able to take things seriously
(exams).
Delusions of separation
There was a strong feeling of separation. The feeling of floating, of
getting a lift with their body rather than being in it. The soul being
separated from the body (03F 01:15:55), the head being separated from the body.
A sensation of lightness in the limbs. The feeling of something strange
happening to the top half of the body. Didn’t feel themselves. Light headed and
airy.
Depression
Feeling down, tired and heavy. Dull and withdrawn. Not themselves,
distant and not as friendly as usual. Just want to sleep and not wake up
(suicidal thoughts). Feeling low and averse to company.
Not happy.
Depression and mania
An interesting fluctuation between extremes of emotion. This theme
overlaps with the theme of heightened emotions. Provers were experiencing
serious depression followed by loudness, laughter and silliness.
“I felt very depressed tonight.. withdrawn and quiet, then I just got
loud again (29F 00:20:00). “Acting loud and silly, laughing and doing stupid
things” (29F 00:). Feeling miserable (29F 4:20:30). “Feeling like I can’t
handle life and I just want to curl into a little ball and give up”.
Feeling jovial, confident, giggly. “Feeling good, happy, quite
excitable” (38F 03:10:15). “Am feeling absolutely horrible..want to
cry..feeling extremely low..alone and miserable” (38F 03:19:30).
“Very happy again!!! Feel a bubble of happiness coming up in my chest,
then need to laugh uncontrollably. Dancing around, laughing and hugging everyone”
(38F 04:).
“Feel dull, have no energy. Want to give up on everything.” (36F 00:).
“Optimistic, happy, have energy. Alert, awake, in a good mood.” (36F 01:).
“Sad and depressed, tired, unfocused and antisocial” (36F 03:)
Desire Company
When prover 29 was sad and troubled she had the desire to be with
someone (29F 13:). Provers also recorded feeling sociable and confident.
Feeling relaxed and talkative and happy to see friends.
Difficult Concentration
There was huge difficulty concentrating on work in many of the provers.
There was the sensation of being on a cloud (38F 01:13:20) and being light
headed and airy (35F 01:). Frustration that it took a long time to do something
short. There was lethargy, feeling distracted and a considerable lack of focus.
Relaxed and lazy,
fighting to study. Feeling floaty, drifting along can’t concentrate.
Mentally slow. Indecisive and getting words wrong in sentences (29F 00:).
Thoughts in a jumble. Slurring of words (31F 01:).
There was a lack of concentration accompanied by slow movements (05M
00:04:40). Feeling dull and demotivated. A thick feeling in the head, feeling
dumb. It was noted that huge focus and attention was needed and that short term
memory seemed deficient.
Heightened Emotions
There is an overlap of themes between „Heightened emotions’, „Depression
and mania’ and „Irritability’. In „Heightened emotions’ the rapid movement
between polar moods is observed. An extremely elevated mood is followed by the
plummet to an incredible low mood and visa versa. “Emotions oscillated greatly
today, quite sensitive and emotional.” (28M 07:).
“Mood swings” (42F 04:). “Had mood swings at work today. I would be
upset and swearing, then angry and swearing, then happy again.” (31F 02:).
“Unsettled emotions” (28M 07:). “Heightened emotions - joyous and happy,
then low” (38F 00:21:07). Emotions were felt to be messed up and “emphasized to
the extremes” (38F 04:). There seemed to be an increased sensitivity to what
people said.
“Overreacting to things that normally would not phase me” (31F 03:).
Feeling emotional and depressed because of a dream (29F 12:).
Getting nervous and sick because of dissection, couldn’t touch the body
part, started crying.” (29F 12:). “..feeling absolutely horrible, constant
feeling that I want to cry.” (38F 03:19:30).
Provers noted that the emotions that they were feeling were often for no
reason. “Felt like crying for no reason.” (03F 02:15:50). “Very good mood, no
reason to be in one though” (38F 04:).
“Felt sad about nothing when I woke up” (03F 03:08:00). Provers also
noted the strange symptom of being irritable and frustrated on waking (38F 11:).
Then feeling quite happy later (03F 03:10:57).
Irritability
Irritability was very marked in all of the provers. There were instances
of being abrupt and rude, grumpy and irritable and snapping at others (29F 01:).
There was irritability over small things aggravated by tiredness, heat
and humidity (02M :XX). Unusual shortness of temper was noted (01M 05:21:00).
Waking up and feeling irritable for no reason (38F 11:).
Irritable with self and family for no reason (34F 11:16:00). Feeling
frustrated, restless but at the same time like doing nothing (03F 13:11:30).
There was the desire to relieve extreme irritation through physical violence.
Depressed and annoyed, “Irritated, frustrated - want to hit something/
someone.” (36F 04:). Feeling “..very irritable, get angry easily, want to let
frustration out physically.”
(35F :XX). Little things causing irritation, hostility and impatience
whilst driving (provers 02 and 05). Irritated by being pushed around, with an
intense aversion to authorative people
(36F 10:). Easily irritated, overreacting, wanting to be alone (provers
26 and 25). Jumping to conclusions. “Moody and better for nothing!” (42F 05:).
Laziness
There were feelings of being depressed, unsociable and lazy. Being
relaxed and unmotivated and feeling as if they were on holiday. Finding it
difficult to study and would rather go and have fun.
Mania
Hysterical laughter and the sensation of going mad. Uncharacteristic
giggling fits in the evening. “Feel like I am going mad, this is unusual. I feel
as though I am not able to keep all the bits of my mind together. The feeling
doesn’t worry me, it is usually accompanied by much laughter.” (03F 05:21:30).
“..not all there!! Can’t take much seriously - feel lightly drunk.” (05M
00:06:10).
Feeling in high spirits but semi dazed. Acting loud and silly, giggling,
saying things without thinking. Feeling excitable. The sensation of a bubble of
happiness coming up in the chest, then needing to laugh uncontrollably. Dancing
around, laughing and hugging everyone.
Motivation and Enthusiasm
Provers felt energetic and motivated to work and study and get things
done.
They were enthusiastic and could focus well on work. Trying to do too
many things at once. Feeling positive. “Feeling on top of the world, in a very
good mood, can overcome all obstacles with a smile on my face. Am great, very
happy. More confidence, more energy. Jumping around instead of moping around.”
(39F 01:09:55). Able to concentrate, well rested and energised. “At peace with
the world, can motivate myself better than usual” (03F 14:10:25).
Optimistic and feeling better about the future.
Paradoxical thoughts
There was the feeling of being in two minds, of own desires being in
conflict with the needs of others. Wanting to have fun but feeling guilty.
“Want to do what is right, trying to restrain myself from what I want. Feeling
spiritual” (36F 05:). Needing to do work but wanting to relax, “..not want to
do work - prefer to go have fun.” (35F :XX).
It was observed that there seemed to be two trains of thought in some
provers that was often reconciled by quiet time and introspection. Overreacting
to things but after contemplation being able to put things into perspective
again.
Restlessness
Feeling hot, bothered and rushed. Busy and hyperactive. Feeling that
something that should be quick is taking a long time (38F 12:). Feeling that
there is lots to do but there’s not enough time. Tired, restless, want time to
hurry up - frustrated.” (03F 02:10:10).
Spaced Out
This was a common symptom in many of the provers. They felt spacey,
drowsy and slow. Light headed and dreamy. Not focussed on the conversation or
the surroundings (29F 01:).
“Feeling floaty, just drifting along, can’t focus.” (03F 03:11:30). Felt
surreal on waking (03F 11:).
Mellow, dreamy, slow, wasting time. Feeling dreamy, disorientated, “Not
completely on earth.” (36F 05:). Light headed, difficulty focussing, feeling
distant (35F 01:).
Feeling stoned (31F 01:). Light headed, stupid, almost stoned feeling
(05M 00:00:25). Dazed. Head feels cloudy (02M 02:).
[Liesel Taylor]
https://ir.dut.ac.za/bitstream/10321/61/12/Taylor_2004.pdf
Mind:
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
Alertness Laziness
Tranquillity Irritability
Desire company Antisocial
Mania Depression
Motivation and enthusiasm Difficult concentration
Carefree Anxiety
Heightened emotions Tiredness
Abrupt - rough - harsh
Absentminded - dreamy
> Activity/inactiv
Ailments from suppressed anger
Alert
Angers easily
Antisocial
Anxious - about business/causeless/about own family/about his money
matters/about others/for paroxysms felt in stomach/from thoughts
Busy at night
Carefree
Cheerful
Company - < mental symptoms/aversed to (> when alone/desires
solitude)/desires it
Concentration - active/difficult (cannot fix attention/on attempting to
concentrate/vacant feeling/with headache/reading/studying/talking/working)
Confusion - talking/”As if intoxicated”
Actions contradictory to intentions
Dancing
Delusions: body is divided/body lighter than air/body divided in two
parts/floating in air/head separated from body/becomes insane/is intoxicated/is
excited and light/
body and mind separated/separated from the world/separated from the
world/thoughts are separated
Disoriented with everything
Dissociation from environment
“As if in a dream”
Dull - when studying/unable to think long/thinking slowly
Excited easily/emotions heightened/excitement (at night)/# sadness/over
trifles
Frivolous
Frustrated
Giggling
Hurry, haste (eating/in movements)
Impatience (driving)
Indifference (for business affairs/to the dictates of conscience/to
duties/to everything)
Industrious - mania for work
Introspection
Irresolution, indecision (at night)
Irritable (morning/evening/at night/wishes to be alone/#
cheerfulness/causeless?/from conversation/crying and weeping/with
discouragement/to won family/about little things/loved ones/
from mental exertion/when spoken to/with sleepiness/from trifles/on
waking/when working)
Laughing (desires to laugh/foolish/hysterical/loudly/everything seems
ludicrous/silly/uncontrollably)
Laziness with sleepiness
Mania (# depression)
Meditating
Memora - weak (of memory/for facts/for recent facts)
Mistakes in speaking - using wrong words
Mood #
Motivated
Optimistic
Overwhelmed
Passionate
Positiveness
Prostration
Reserved
Restless (evening: 20 h./busy/when attempting to study)
Rude
Sadness (> company/with heaviness of body/would like to sleep and
never to wake/with sleepiness)
Sensitive - to all external impressions/to mental impressions/to opinion
of others
Serious, earnest
>/< Social meeting
Solitude desires it
Spaced out feeling
Speech - inarticulate/incoherent/”As if intoxicated”
Studying
Stupefaction (during vertigo)
Thoughts - disconnected/two trains of thought
Tranquility, serenity, calmness (# active concentration)
Weeping - anxious/desire to weep all the time/easily/after slight
emotion
Will - contradiction of
Vertigo: Morning/+ staggering/”As if elevated”/tends to
fall to the left (sitting)/”As if floating”/”As if intoxicated”/like
swinging/in temples/”As if head turning around”
Head: Forehead - dull above eyes/cold/heaviness
internal/pain (ext. ears/above eyes/behind eyes/between eyes/pulsating)
Constriction
Fullness
Heat
Heaviness
Itching when head becomes warm
Pain [l./r./morning on waking/+ pain in eye/from too eager
attention/bending forward/constant, continued/exertion (body/of
eyes)/increasing gradually - decreasing gradually/from light in general/
Lying/< motion (of eyes)/> external pressure/> rubbing/after
sleep/in small spots ext. all directions/biting teeth together/in occiput/dull
(> rising/l. side/from temple to temple/pressing behind
Eyes/pulsating/sharp/shooting (l./from temple to temple)/in temples (l./r./chewing/ext.
neck/ext. parietal bone/ext. vertex)/pulsating]
Eyes: Agglutinated in morning
Bleeding - subconjunctival haemorrhage
Discharge yellow
Red (l.)
Dry
Heavy
Inflamed [conjunctiva (granular/> cold applications/sclerae red like
raw meat]
Irritation
Itching
Pain [> bathing cold water/< bending forwards/during heat/from
light/lying/< Wind/< sunlight/burning “As from sand”/”As from foreign
body”/pressing outward/sore]
Photophobia
Staring
Swelling (l./lids)
“As if tired”
Twitching in lids
Vision: Accomodation defective/blutted/dim/foggy
Ear: “As if full”
Itching in meatus
Pain l.
Swollen l.
Nose: Catarrh
Coryza (without discharge/> lying/< motion)
Discharge constant
Itching (inside)
Obstruction (morning on waking)
Pain l.
Sensitive
Sneezing - constant/caused by dust/paroxysmal
Face: Discolored (dark circles under eyes)
Eruptions - l. cheek/acne/pimples (itching/on forehead painful/on lower
jaw)
Greasy
Swollen l.
Mouth: Discoloration - white (yellowish)/yellow:
white
Dry (with thirst)/”As if dry”
Tongue - enlarged/swollen/”As if thick”
Eruptions - on tongue/vesicles
Numb gums
Pain sore: palate
Salivation profuse
Speech difficult from swelling of tongue
Throat: Constricted
Red
Irritated
“As if a lump”
Mucus - morning on waking/tastes metallic
Pain - > cold drinks/> eating: ameliorates/burning (with
dryness/drinking water/oesophagus/sore (sore > eating)
Scratching
Swallowing difficult
“As if thick”
Tickling causing coughing
External Throat: Eruptions - itching/pimples
Pain - l./r./pulsating sideways
Tension (r.)
Stomach: Appetite - diminished (daytime/evening/easy
satiety/even after eating)/increased (daytime/even after eating/# loss of
appetite/on waking/with weakness/ravenous)/without relish/wanting (evening)/wanting
with thirst/wanting without thirst)/
Bubbling/gurgling
Disordered
Emptiness > eating
“As if full” - after eating ever so little
Nausea - after anxiety/after excitement/during fever/looking at
food/after sleep
Pain (cramping)
Thirst (daytime/unquenchable/drinking cold water)/THIRST/thirstless
Uneasiness
Abdomen: “As if diarrhoea would come on” (with pain)
Distension
Flatulent on waking
Pain - “As if menses would appear”/cramping (with diarrhoea/during stool/before
passing flatus/below umbilicus)
Rectum: Diarrhoea
Flatus (morning on waking)
Stool: Copious/dark/frequent/small
Bladder: Pain (on urination: urging to urinate)
Urine: dark/colourless in morning
Male organs: Pain in penis
Female organs: Leukorrhea - # bloody discharge/black/instead
of menses
Menses - brown/too late/with leucorrhea/scanty (late)/painless
Pain sharp: ovaries
Respiration: accelerated/difficult - breathing: deep (want
of breathe)/difficult in crowded room/inspiration/felt in throat
Chest: Constricted during fever
Rash
Pain under - r./l. mamma/sides/cramping in heart (cutting)
Back: Pain - in cervical region/in dorsal region:
scapulae/in lumbar region (aching/sore)
Stiff
Tension (in cervical region: evening/on waking)
Extremities: Cold feet
Cramps in l. foot
Eruptions on upper limbs: rash/shoulder: rash/desquamation (of palm of
hand/fingers/about nails)/pimples (legs itching/ankle)
Itching on lower limbs
Pain - l. knee/l. ankle/l. 5th toe/
Twitching - upper arm/thumb/thigh
Sleep: Comatose
(Deep and) disturbed
Falling asleep - difficult/easy
Heavy/interrupted
Restless - at night/from bodily restlessness
Short afternoon
Sleepy - morning on waking/difficult opening eyes
Unrefreshing - morning
Waking “As from fright”
Dreams: some
Generals: r. side/l. then r.
> bending double
Heat and cold
Tends to take cold
Food and drinks: Desires: Choc./coffee/cold drink (water); <: smell
of food/thought of food; Aversion: to food after eating a little/to food when
seen/when smelling food/thinking of eating; Desires: fruit/sweets/water
(carbonated);
Heat - flushes of heat with perspiration/lack of vital heat/sensation of
heat (on exertion)Becoming heated/with nausea
“As if influenza coming on”
Lassitude
“As if strength”
> stretching
Weakness (morning/night/> exertion/in joints)
The researcher suggests that Naja-mos. be abbreviated Naja -mos, in
accordance with the binary system described in Synthesis, 7th Edition
(Schroyens, 1997). 5.3 The Symptoms The proving had to be repeated since the
lack of compliance in the first trial amongst the lay volunteers resulted in a
scanty collection of symptoms. The second trial was conducted with homoeopathic
students from first to fourth year and ensured a better and more complete
remedy picture. Prover symptoms from both the first and second trial were
included in the final write up. The researcher however still feels that to
claim that the proving produced a complete essence picture of Naja-mos. would
be premature (Mortelmans, 1997:201). The proving at best gives one an
indication of the potential of Naja-mos. as a remedy.
More research over an extended period of time into Naja-mos.’s characteristics is required to
attain the quality of completeness required for a true understanding of this remedy.
The concepts resulting
from the proving are discussed in a simple and comprehensive manner
under the various sections of the repertory.
MIND A significant number of contradictions emerged from this proving
and were particularly evident in the mind section. This was to be expected when
one studies other snake remedies regarding the mind symptomatology - for
example: Naja. with regard to the positive, energised emotions versus the
depressive, apathetic emotions and Lachesis muta with regard to its loquacity
versus its moroseness and lack of communication.
THE PARADOXES
The researcher attempted to extract and categorise the paradoxes in
order to discuss them in a clear logical fashion.
Alertness versus lack of concentration
Most provers experienced clarity of mind and alertness following an
initial period of total lack of concentration and focus. Since most of the
provers were students in varying levels of study, this lack
of concentration pertained mainly to studying either for examinations or
when attempting to understand lecture material. At first this lack of
concentration was met with frustration and reluctant acceptance, then with
indifference and a care less attitude that led many to neglect their studies in
pursuit of other interests and pleasures. This lack of concentration was
described as being “distracted”
or “dull, dazed” and a “stoned feeling”.
It suggests that the provers felt as if they had been under the
influence of some kind of narcotic, which may account for the carefree attitude
many adopted subsequently. Mistakes in speaking also occurred, some experienced
it as a slurring of words (31F 00:) or “kept getting words wrong in my
sentences” (29F 00: ). This lack of concentration and distraction appeared
shortly after taking the remedy and was evident throughout the proving.
The alertness felt following this “dazed”, apathetic period resulted in
the provers feeling more energised, positive and focussed on the task at hand.
There was a feeling of motivation coupled with a sense of confidence in oneself
to accomplish whatever task presented.
Anxiety versus Tranquillity
Anxiety was experienced by many provers but was mainly paired with
frustration, agitation or a sense of being overwhelmed by a particular problem or
by life in general. This anxiety was experienced as something that one could
not control which exacerbated the frustration and agitation even more. Although
the anxiety was caused mainly by events occurring around them, many provers
experienced anxiety for no reason. It appears that the various individuals
allowed outside impressions to affect them deeply, to such an extent that they
experienced it as an influence that they had no control over.
The tranquillity evident in the proving emerges as a reprieve
interspersed amongst the periods of tension and restlessness. Tranquillity is
experienced as relaxation, peace and a time to replenish the energies.
Anti-social versus Desire for company
This aversion to company appeared to be related to the depression and
irritability felt by many in the proving. A number of provers felt irritated by
company or by a social gathering and became angry
at being “imposed” upon. Although few provers enjoyed company and were
reputed to be “party animals”, they became withdrawn in company and seeked
solitude. Some provers experienced these contradictory feelings as alternating
symptoms on the same day or on alternating days. All the provers experiencing
this anti-social feeling did not experience the desire for company. One prover
as an underlying need for security experienced the desire for company as a
“wanting to be around my mom all the time, she stayed with me till I fell
asleep” (29F 13:). This prover also felt sad and troubled within whilst
enjoying the company of friends. Others however experienced this need for
social interaction as a positive, confidence building experience. Carefree
versus Heightened emotions
This carefree feeling paired with the lack of concentration and spacey
feeling was a common thread and with it the contrast of heightened emotions
whether positive or negative were experienced by
most of the provers throughout the proving. Carefree was interpreted in
different ways as indifference, laziness, apathy, uncaring and an aversion to
perform one’s duty. The heightened emotions experienced were interpreted by many as
a sensitivity to outside impressions which resulted in emotions such as
weeping, anger and irritation to name a few. Many experienced a vacillation in
emotions
and caused many to overreact to trivial occurrences and lash out at
those around them. This particular paradox relates to most of the other
contradictory symptomatology in the proving. Depression versus Mania
The researcher felt that this was the main theme that emerged from the
proving. The depression encompassed sadness, weeping, and suicidal thoughts to
being serious and reserved. Provers felt unsure, indecisive and withdrawn from
society whilst in this depressive state. One prover had suicidal thoughts, that
didn’t last too long and were dramatically contrasted by the manic state of
laughing, acting silly and being generally loud thereafter. (29 F 00:20: 00)
The depression was vividly contrasted by the manic state in the provers. This
state manifested in provers as laughing uncontrollably, acting silly and loud.
The behaviour was described as uncharacteristic, unusual and being
uncontrollable, a sense of going mad and an inability to take anything
seriously (05 M 179 00:06:10) (03 F 04: 13: 42). The manic state is reminiscent
of the effects of recreational drugs that provide one with a feeling of elation
and energy. A prover mentioned her desire to dance, hug everyone and generally
feeling loved.
38 F 04 and 05:) This is much
like the effects of MDMA (ecstasy). Laziness versus Restlessness
This dramatic contrast between the apathetic versus the energetic hyped
state is again clearly outlined under these contradictions of symptoms.
Laziness is described as an aversion to anything that may
be regarded as work or duty and the subsequent desire for undertaking
nothing. This laziness can be related to other feelings such as being carefree,
unfocussed, antisocial and indifferent and a desire
to participate in other interesting distractions. Restlessness,
associated with anxiety, irritability and frustration was felt by most of the
provers. This restlessness was expressed as being rushed, wanting time to pass
quickly and generally performing daily tasks in a hurried manner. The general
restlessness was described as busy and hyperactive. Paradoxical thoughts - two
trains of thought Provers 35, 36 and 38 expressed a moral dilemma in thoughts
where their desire to do something conflicted strongly with the awareness of
doing the “right” thing.
This detached feeling was particularly marked in prover 03 where her
head felt detached from her body whilst driving a car. She experienced a
sensation of floating and detachment from her surroundings and body when she
was running. Her sense of detachment was associated with dizziness. Her head
felt like it was swinging around when she stood still. Prover 29 had a similar
experience where her upper body felt detached from the lower part of her body
and her hands and arms “were irritated with writing”. Irritability, short
temperedness and impatience Most if not all the provers experienced a general
sense of irritability, short temperedness and impatience.
This irritability was associated with tiredness and an over reaction to
trivial issues. Impatience was obvious when driving and instilled hostility in
the driver due to short temperedness. Heat and humidity appeared to exacerbate
these feelings of irritation. Irritability and hostility was mainly vented on
family and friends. There was no clear cause for the irritation and general bad
temperedness but was more
a state induced by overreaction. Motivation and Enthusiasm This theme is
associated with much energy and optimism. The provers expressed a keenness to
accomplish tasks and a motivation to study.
This is in sharp contrast to the aversion to work found in the laziness
theme above. It should therefore also be contrasted with the laziness state. A
general positive well-being underlies this energetic state.
Spaced out, tiredness
All the provers experienced tiredness in some form or other. Most experienced
this overwhelming tiredness in the afternoon or evening, others felt
unrefreshed in the morning. The tiredness in many cases was associated with a
feeling of being spaced out and dreamy. Some expressed an irritability
associated with the tiredness and being short tempered. Although associated
with the tiredness, being spaced out was also experienced on its own.
Provers felt distant from their surroundings either not hearing
conversations or in one case the morning alarm and as one prover described as
feeling “surreal” on waking. This spaced out feeling was also described as
being stoned and can be related to the unfocused feeling discussed under the
lack of concentration theme. Modalities Ameliorating factors for mental
emotional symptomatology were the outdoors and open air, activity, eating,
solitude and company. Aggravating factors included heat and humidity, eating,
company, morning on waking and mental exertion.
Vorwort/Suchen Zeichen/Abkürzungen Impressum