Comparison Pink with Luna + Magnetis Polus Arcticus + Magnetis Polus Australis + Positronium + Radium bromatum +

Sol + X-ray

Vergleich:

Luna	Magnetis polis australis	Magnetis polis arctus	Positronium	Radium bromatum	Sol	X-ray
Headaches (dull) in forehead, occipital and temporal regions Across head Stinging in eyes Vision acute	Headaches (dull) in forehead, occipital and temporal regions Across head Stinging in eyes Noises in ears “As if vertigo”	Headaches (dull) in forehead, occipital and temporal regions Across head Stinging in eyes Vision acute Noises in ears “As if vertigo”	Headaches (dull) in forehead, occipital and temporal regions Across head Stinging in eyes Vision acute “As if vertigo”	Headaches (dull) in forehead, occipital and temporal regions Across head “As if vertigo”	Headaches (dull) in forehead, occipital and temporal regions Across head	Headaches (dull) in forehead, occipital and temporal regions Across head Noises in ears “As if vertigo”
Mouth dry	“As if heat in the face”	“As if heat in the face” Mouth dry	“As if heat in the face” Mouth dry		“As if heat in the face”
Throat sore and painful	throat sore and painful		throat sore and painful
Stomach: acidity/ Nausea (and thirst) Constipation/diarrhoea	Stomach: heartburn/ Eructations/nausea and thirst Appetite increased Cramping/stitching Abdomen: pain/flatulence Constipation/diarrhoea	Stomach: acidity/ heartburn/eructations/ Nausea Appetite increased cramping/stitching Abdomen: pain/flatulence Constipation/diarrhoea	Stomach: acidity/ heartburn/eructations/ nausea (and thirst) Appetite in-/decreased /stitching Abdomen: pain/flatulence Constipation/diarrhoea	Stomach:	Stomach: heartburn/ Eructations/ Nausea (and thirst) Appetite decreased Cramping Constipation	Stomach: Nausea Appetite increased diarrhoea

Sex desire less /more Menses too early/too late/too short/copious	Sex desire less /more. (female intensive) Menses too early/too short/copious	Sex desire less /more. (female intensive) Menses too late/copious	Sex desire less /more. (female intensive) Menses too early/too short/copious	Sex desire less /more. Menses too late	Sex desire less /more.	Sex desire less /more. Menses too early/too short/copious
Chest: pain, constriction with difficult respiration Back: pain in lumbar region	Chest: oppression/with difficult respiration Back: pain in lumbar region	Chest: oppression/with with difficult respiration	Chest: pain, constriction/oppression with difficult respiration	Chest: pain, constriction	Back: pain in lumbar region
Sleep: deep/unrefreshing Dream: amorous/vivid	sleep: restless/sleepy/ sleepless/unrefreshing Dream: vivid	seep: restless/deep/ sleepy/sleepless (restless mind)/ unrefreshing Dream: amorous/vivid	Sleep: restless/sleepless (restless mind) /unrefreshing Dream: amorous	Sleepy Dream: vivid	sleep: restless/deep/ sleepless (restless mind)	Sleepless (restless mind)/ unrefreshing Dream: amorous
Desires: cold drinks/cold water Weak/restless “As if heat” lack of vital heat	Weak/weary/restless “As if heat” painful soreness throughout the body	Weak/weary/lassitude/ restless “As if heat” painful soreness throughout the body	Desires: sweets/cold drinks/cold water Weak/weary/lassitude “As if heat” lack of vital heat painful soreness throughout the body	Desires: sweets Weak/restless “As if heat”	Weak/weary	Desires: sweets/ cold drinks/cold water Weak/weary/lassitude lack of vital heat painful soreness throughout the body

Wauters states that in the provings done on Pink all provers had dreams associated with motherhood, mothers, pregnancy, giving birth or holding a baby and that these dreams

about “mother Love” provided a strong indication on how best to use this remedy. She further states that Pink made everyone feel well and that it did have a specific action on

the physical body in relation to various skin conditions i.e. dry eczema, acne and skin rashes (Wauters, 1999:113).

Unfortunately, none of these dream symptoms appeared during the re-proving of remedy Pink 30CH. In fact, many of the mental and emotional symptoms that were produced

in this study were also in stark contrast as to what was encountered in the version of Pink related by Wauters (1999:112-114).

The researcher suspects that these discrepancies exist because the ‘symptoms’ documented in ‘Homeopathic Colour Remedies’ by Wauters (1999) were in fact largely attributes

and associations ascribed to the colour pink rather than produced by the remedy itself. For instance, Wauters (1999:112-114) states that pink is associated with universal mother

love and that it pertains to purity and innocence; she further states that the colour pink represents positivity, love, joy and tenderness and that it is also associated with gentleness,

sweetness and naiveté.

As can be seen, none of these characteristics are true proving symptoms but seem to be more esoteric connotations that have been applied to the colour itself (or to the ’heart chakra’

that the colour pink is said to possess an affinity towards) (Wauters, 1999:65-67).

Evident from the proving of Pink 30CH performed during this study in which symptoms: anger/rage/violence/depression/despondency/lasciviousness/lassitude were noted – none

of which appeared or was commented on in the original ‘’proving’’ from Wauters performed on remedy Pink. The researcher therefore feels that further re-provings should be

done on all of the remaining colour remedies in order to ascertain the proving effects of these substances according to proper Hahnemannian proving methodology.

However that remedy Pink certainly does seem to be homoeopathically related to the remedies Ign. Ph-ac. Puls. And Lacs allgemein as suggested by Wauters (1999:114).

Bailey: Ign. one of the most dramatic of remedy types encountered in homoeopathic practice (Vermeulen, 2004:714). In the mental and emotional spheres the Ign. characterized

by contradictory and alternating states; emotional outbursts which are very quickly controlled; spasmodic and erratic symptoms, and exaggeration (Vermeulen, 2004:712-714).

There is also much melancholia, sadness and tearfulness associated with this remedy (Vermeulen, 2000:802).

Other features that bear a remarkable resemblance to the symptomatology of remedy Pink 30CH include a ’highly emotional’ disposition; a desire to be alone; irritability and

’wildness at trifles’; moodiness; and an aversion to company with/without quarrelsomeness (Vermeulen, 2000:802-803).

Puls. another remedy that seems to bear some resemblance to remedy Pink 30CH. Is characterized by a tearful and emotional disposition with highly changeable, shifting symptoms

(Vermeulen, 2004:1109). Vermeulen (2004:1109) states that the symptoms change in an erratic fashion and that the patient may appear mild and pleasant one minute, and peevish

and tearful the very next.

There is also much irresolution, capriciousness, restlessness and weariness associated with Pulsatilla praetensis (Vermeulen, 2000:1297) as found in remedy Pink 30CH.

Ph-ac. has also been designated as a complementary remedy to Ign. (Sankaran, 2003:473; Vermeulen 2000:811), and as a remedy which is ’followed well by’ Puls.

during homoeopathic treatment (Sankaran, 2003:479; Vermeulen, 2000:1226). Thus it is evident that all three remedies are in fact related to each other, as well as to remedy

Pink 30CH.

Sankaran (2006:159) states that the mental state of Ph-ac. is one of excessive sleepiness, brooding, indifference, aversion to business, hopelessness and despair – all of which was

also encountered during the proving of Pink 30CH. Vermeulen (2000:1220) elaborates that there is also listlessness, hysteria, apathy and an inclination to weep in this remedy.

Sankaran (2006:159) further goes on to say that on the physical sphere Ph-ac. characterized by much weakness, a lack of energy and that the individual has an increased disposition

to lie down due to tremendous physical exhaustion.

Wauters (1999:114) does suggest that remedy Pink bears a resemblance to the milk group of remedies as an entirety – the researcher believes that it is most similar to Lac-leon.,

which bears the most similarities to remedy Pink 30CH. In his proving of Lac-leon. Sankaran (2004:153-166) states that the remedy produced symptoms and themes included:

Anger with violent impulses and a desire to smash or break things

Increased assertiveness

Irritability

Quarrelsomeness

Malicious behaviour / Rage

Rude, loud and uncivil behaviour

Feelings of being attacked

Feelings of danger

Feelings of being offended

Increased sexuality

Restlessness with easy prostration

Amorous dreams

Physical weakness and sluggishness

All of above symptoms and themes are remarkably similar to those produced during the proving of remedy Pink 30CH. It is interesting Lac-leon. was used on Prover 7 to antidote

the disruptive, chaotic and violent symptoms that were experienced during the first week following the commencement of the proving.

Pink. a large number of mental symptoms:

irritability,

anger,

rage,

anxiety,

tranquillity,

depression

antisocial behaviour.

Headaches and vertigo

Sleep disturbed: difficulty in falling asleep/sleeplessness from an activity of thoughts and restless sleep in general.

Difficulty in respiration,

acne,

constipation,

diarrhoea,

toothache

copious eructations

Changes in the female menstrual cycle

Libido in both sexes

Affinity of the remedy for the nervous system: numbness, tingling, weakness and pain occurring throughout the various systems of the body.

The hypothesis that remedy Pink 30CH would also share symptoms and themes when compared with the other selected homoeopathic imponderabilia was also confirmed.

Energy

Sensitivity

Irritability, impatience, anger

Psychotic, changeable mood

Heaviness, morose, sadness

Detachment, indifference

Tranquillity

Sex

Vorwort/Suchen Zeichen/Abkürzungen Impressum